Experience the comfort that comes with knowing all of the details are taken care of.
Steakhouse Hash Browns
Dill Potato Salad, Asparagus Slaw, Lemon Aioli
The food is outstanding. “Rare” is another comparable steak house in Madison. But Johnny Delmonico’s has better service and a much cleaner and more enjoyable ambiance. This is definitely the top pick for a steak house in Madison.
Food is always great, but the service is what makes a great dinning experience
You bet! Our waiter Kerry was outstanding. We had a terrific experience!
Granted it was Saturday Night but the noise level made for an uncomfortable evening! Our waiter was “over the top” and contributed to the noise distraction! Food was good but for the price, the celebration evening was a disappointment. We have dined there before and enjoyed those experiences.
We love the calamari - and it didn’t disappoint. However, we did have a couple of disappointments this time around. My steak was pretty chewy. I expect something a bit more tender at a premium steakhouse. I’ve had better rib eyes at the Outback.
Then, my wife’s halibut was over cooked. She didn’t say anything until the next day. If she’d mentioned it at the restaurant, we would have sent it back.
I don’t think we’ll be back real soon.
Yes, Ben was good waiter No MINT JELLY for lamb dish was bad!
Cynthia, our server, was fabulous! We were celebrating 2 birthdays and an anniversary - she was great! Ask for her. Meal was delicious and the drinks were spot on. We picked the right restaurant to celebrate, that's for sure!
Best cocktails, steaks, and service in downtown Madison. Wonderful atmosphere and warm hospitality.
Steak was very seared and and exceptionally fatty. For the price it wasn’t worth it.
Great food! Personable service.
So perfect to catch up w our adult kids, Kerry was wonderful attentive and fun
Everything is top notch. Food, drinks, service, experience- excellent!
Steak was good, but not great. Service was outstanding. Atmosphere was good.
From the moment we walked in, to the time we left it was an absolutely perfect time.
Our food was delicious, our server was friendly and overall we had a wonderful time and a difficult time wanting to leave.
Always great food and service!
Sides were great. Steaks were dry. 6oz filet should not taste dry. Almost as if the cooks were sitting on product too long. Service was outstanding.
My wife and I love this place. From start to finish, the place is fabulous! Kerry our server was excellent and we always ask to be at his table. Brandy old fashion is the best and the food is SOOOOOOOOOO good. Cant wait for next visit.
Perfect setting for a romantic date. Lovely atmosphere and top notch service. The menu had many great options and overall the experience was entirely satisfying. Would highly recommend to anyone.
Excellent in every way
Amazing service, food was well-timed, served at proper temperature and made for a wonderful evening.
Valentines Day....perfect....she fell in love with me all over again!! Probably, because of the food....lol!!!
Went on a Friday night and the food was just ok. I had a filet and it was kind of dry, not what I would expect when paying over $50 for a steak. Service was really good though so at least they got that right. Much better options available in town for a steak.
Service drinks food excellent. Creamed spinach was not creamed.
Food was fantastic and our service was great! Excellent wine selection too!!!
We've lived in the Madison area 26 years and this was our first (but not our last) visit.
Jonathon and Eric made our evening so nice. The food of course Was star and everything was Very Good.
We hope to return soon.
The food was good and we had a very pleasant waitress. My wife was very happy...happy wife happy life.
Amanda was FANTASTIC!!!!! We had an awesome time and will definitely be back!!
Kerry gave us dinner and a show. Fantastic Fellow. Perfect timing. There when you needed him, gone when you didn't. A true professional!
We took our daughter out for her 21st Birthday and they created a menu specifically for my daughter with the headline Happy 21st Birthday Madison. That was so awesome. Our waitress was great and the food was awesome!
You must ask for Kerry to be your server. He's top notch !
Delicious!!! The place is beautiful, great place for a date night. A bit pricey, but worth it. I would suggest reducing the potato portion and offering a salad with the meal.
This was my first trip to Johnny Delmonico's and it was perfect in every way. The waiter was great with recombinations and speedy with the drinks. He gave us space but also checked in enough to make us feel cared for. The dry aged stake was the best I’ve ever tasted. I can’t wait for a return trip.
A bit too smashed in because of restaurant week but always great food.
We found the food to be good but it lacked the elements to be great especially for the Beef Tenderloin restaurant week entree. The mashed potatoes were warn as were the steaks, the au jus was luke warm. Having a hot entree would have ramped up the rating.
Our server was gregarious. However, when boxing up our leftovers she asked if we would like the leftover bread and we said yes however it was not included. She had also offered to obtain the purveyor of the honey served on the nut and cheese board dessert option and she did not do so. Either of those things would have been nice to have and since she volunteered to obtain them it ended up being disappointing when she did not.
Lovely environment and surprisingly not too loud like many restaurants.
Restaurant Week was amazing.
The filet medallions were cooked to perfection. The salad and cheese plate dessert were a great keto friendly option. Only thing is, there could have been a vegetable substitute for the potatoes. I did try them and they were amazing though.
Service was great and as expected for this quality of dining.
Would recommend for casual or business dining.
Wonderful dining experience. Our first time and we look forward to our next visit.
Wonderful dinner for my husband’s birthday.
Our waiter was Kerry - he is fantastic. Food was amazing. We sat the bar for an hour until our reservation (we were early) and were pleased. Restaurant was very busy but we were well taken care of and staff was very attentive.
Had a great time, the food was absolutely perfect, I ordered my steak medium and it came out perfectly medium. I usually order my steak med so I can get it med rare that's my mistake they know how to cook lol it was still a great steak. They make a really good brandy old fashion and the whole dinner drinks and all was half what it would have been at rare in Madison.
Johnny Delmonico's is rated 4.5 stars by 949 OpenTable diners.
You can book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size.