Went for my wifes birthday. Dinner was great. Both of our steaks were over cooked first time around. We addressed it with our waitress and she brought us out 2 perfectly cooked ones. Overall it was a great night and the service was exceptional.

It was good but not as good as we are used to pre-pandemic.

Always a great experience dining at J. Gilberts.

Fantastic meal as always! Food cooked exactly the way we ordered.Can't say enough good things about this place.From the staff to the food they serve.Still remains one of my favorite restaurants.

Service and food was excellent!

Our dinner as always was cooked and served to perfection. Our waiter Rob rounded off the experience by prompt and friendly service. He really made our night special.
The tables were spaced apart sufficiently enough where we felt very comfortable dining.

We will definitely be back!!

This is my favorite restaurant. I have been going there since they opened over 20 years ago, and not ONE time did I ever have to send something back. Everything is always cooked to order, and the service is ALWAYS above and beyond. I don't want to brag about it too much, to you all will make it too hard to get a table there!

J Gilbert’s never disappoints!!! Our favorite steak house - hands down. Fabulous food, fabulous service, week-versed staff!!

Exceptional service and food is always perfect!!! Always an excellent experience

We were at the first booth at the bar so it was a little noisier with patrons checking in or staff toting take out orders to and from the bar area.
Evan was attentive and did a great job. Food portions were good; cooked perfectly for our varied requirements and tasty.

Excellent food and impeccable service. Working very well within COVID restrictions.

We had dined here before but hadn’t been back since pandemic started. This was our first time dining in and our waiter Don was very attentive as well as other staff members. Our food was very good and cooked just right. Look forward to going back.

Just had probably the best scallop dinner ever! J Gilberts never disappoints. Friendly and efficient staff, reasonable prices and most consistently excellent food. Kudos to the service staff and kitchen crew!

The steak was delicious and cooked medium just as ordered. The green beans were excellent! The baked potato should be served steaming hot, but was lukewarm. We did not call attention to it while there. Overall great service.

As always great service and food is our favorite. Look forward to our next visit.

Our waiter was awesome.
Extremely kind and always there if needed.

Excellent and attentive waiter and service! Food was delicious as usual :)

The food was excellent! My date and I both had filets that were cooked perfectly.

Post Valentines Day

Excellent restaurant. Always love to go for special occasions and when we want to treat ourselves.

The food was great & the waiter was super nice!

first class dining in all aspects - great quality, great service

Always a great place to go for a great meal along with the service, atmosphere and a quite place to be.

J Gilberts has been a favorite of mine! The food and service are excellent.

Heard so much about this place and it was spoken so highly as if it was a very upscale restaurant....we were the most dressed up ones there it seemed like. Got onion rings as an app and they were okay, nothing crazy. Came specifically for the steaks and that was fantastic! Wish there was more to choose from the sides other than 3 different kind of potatoes. Didn’t have room for dessert since the steaks were huge.

Will not be running back any time soon. Most likely will come back for a happy hour but not for a Valentine’s Day dinner.

As always, the food was impeccable and great friendly service. For those who are concerned, it is extremely clean and they practice all social distancing guidelines.

2 friends spoke so highly I guess I was expecting something monumental, it was very okay and nothing more

The food and drinks were great. We went for anniversary and had a lovely tume.

Food and service was excellent as usual. Sat by a lit fireplace, which added to the evening.

Oddly enough this Steak house couldn’t cook my steak properly. Medium rare came out burnt around the outside and rare in middle. Looks like they used too high of heat, wasn’t worth sending it back but was disappointed.

Great service and great food.

Great atmosphere, great good, and service. Well worth it

Terrific dinner for Valentines Day and Ginny's Birthday! We will be back to use the birthday certificate.

Was wonderful could eat here every night if possible top notch

Food was excellent!

J Gilbert’s never disappoints! Awesome meal as up.

We waiting 25 minutes to be seated even though we had a reservation. It was Valentines day so it was busy and we also requested bar seating that we did not get (no big deal). We frequently receive coupons in our email, and when we had asked if we could apply to our bill it was denied which I thought could've been handled better (the coupon did not have any special limitations or expiration date). Food was very good so that was the only plus.

Valentines day

The best!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Always impeccable service and the food is top notch. Steaks melt in your mouth.