Amazing meal- just as great as ever! First time back in almost a year and it was better than I remember. Service was everything you’d want. My husband and I had octopus and baked clam apps, Red Snapper Livornese and Langostines with Risotto- all perfect. Can’t wait until bar is open so we can stop in for a quick drink and apps which we really miss doing! We’ll be back for dinner again soon!

Great meal at an Italian classic. Staff and the food where terrific

Food highly mediocre. Service top notch. Super expensive

Incredible waiters, such an amazing meal, one you’ll remember for a really long time

I had not been back to Il Mulino since before the pandemic began, and I am very happy to report they have not lost a thing during these awful times. The food was as spectacular as ever, the service impeccable, and the manager Claudio made it feel like coming home again.

Server was fantastic with his customer service, love going there!

Had a lovely birthday dinner for my fiancee here. They provided us with a quiet table in the corner, and the service was exemplary. We shared a few apps, langoustine, and one of their signature pasta dishes. Classic after dinner drink and cake sealed the deal. Always top notch!

Brilliant service - all around. Food was superb.

Service was attentive, professional and friendly. Food was delicious. We sat in outdoor enclosure with very loud fan overhead.

Best service in nyc. Very good food although a bit pricey

Love Il Mulino, one of the best outdoor setups in the city. Food was great, George (waiter) is the man. Thanks for the great service

Best Italian restaurant in NY. Delicious food. Great service. Clean. Safe.

The little house outside was warm and Cozy. Loved dinner and even had a little cheeky Sunday wine.

We had such a wonderful meal and George took such good care of us. Love the cozy and warm outdoor setup!

Amazing!!!

I wasn’t able to go because of the pandemic, but I love this place so much.

Simply The Best Italian In NYC!

We were almost 30 minutes late - we called to let them know and they were so gracious, never mentioned it after we arrived. The food was perfect - we ordered a lot of different things for 6 of us to to share and every single thing was delicious. Our waiter was fantastic - just the right amount of friendly. New favorite restaurant for special occasions.

Sadly it's not the place it once was. We will continue to go because it's an old favorite but we will need to lower our expectations. For a long time it was exceptional.

Amazing! I went here for my birthday with my parents and could not have had a better experience. Would recommend to anyone who wants full service, great wine, and great food.

Love the complimentary bruschetta, zucchini and Parmesan starter. We ordered a pasta to share as a starter. The Bronzino could easily feed two. I recommend adding the tomato from the bruschetta on top with olive oil. If they bring you grappa, lemonchello is also avail. Love this restaurant. One my top 5 in 30 years in NYC.

Amazing food and top notch service!

Great service and special memory!

Amazing evening! Always outstanding! Great service and wonderful food!!! Best authentic Italian in New York City!!!

The food at Il Mulino is very good, but the service was erratic, included too many people who didn't know what the others were doing, and ended up forgetting what we'd requested. Too much "shtick" in the waiters presentations of the food - funny, but a bit silly. And the price was too high: for four people who drank little, and had no appetizers, including tip, the bill was $325. If the ambiance had been better, and the service what you expect from an expensive restaurant, it might have been more worth it, but I'm afraid we won't be returning.

We came here to celebrate my birthday. Everything was perfect! The food was amazing and the service was excellent. We’ll definitely be back soon.

Mother-daughter trip to nyc to celebrate 17th birthday.

A truly authentic Italian experience. I would give the service level higher if able. Our table side prepared pastas were amazing and everything was fresh and delicious. A perfect and cozy Manhattan memory.

Simply the best- every time!

Love it! It’s the best. We try to eat here every time we come to New York. I’m sure the other IL Mulinos are good but I’m sticking with the original. The service cannot be any better!

Authentic tasty Italian. The staff are wonderful. It’s not just a great Italian meal, it’s an amazing Italian dining experience!! Highly recommend.

Valentines Dinner!!! Outstanding Food and Service.

I have traveled all over the US and several European countries for the past 35 years. Il Mullin is by far the best dining experience. The food is outstanding, the service is impeccable and you are treated as a guest not a customer. It is truly a 5 star restaurant. I will come back as often as possible.

Paul
Chicago

The dinner here was fine. Nothing great nor terrible. Out of 6 dishes our party ordered 2 were good and 4 were not very tasty.

The best two dishes were the Lamb and the Flourless desert.

The pastas were not great and the meatballs were mediocre at best. The service was excellent

Great food
Great value
Wonderful service

We were celebrating my nephew's and soon to be niece engagement and the staff was entertaining, gracious and the food and service exceptional! Thanks so very much!

Excellent service. Nothing like it today. Touch of classic NYC.

Il Mulino never disappoints! And restaurant week lunch is no exception. Everything was delicious!

Great place and excellent service. Food is really amazing!! Cozzy and very italian venue

Been going here for years on my anniversary. Always a great experience. Food is delicious and service is outstanding.