Il Mulino New York - Downtown

Fabulous little experience but well worth it. This is our sec

Il Mulino is my favorite Italian place. The bruschetta is the best I’ve ever had and the food is always amazing.

Birthday dinner

As always a fabulous experience, delicious food, super service. We will be back next time we are in the city.

Old Favorite classic NYC Italian. Never lets me down!! Bravo

It was awesome food, awesome atmosphere and awesome hospitality.

It was my birthday. They could not ha e been nicer. The food is amazing. The special osso bucolic best we ever had. I love this place.

The most authentic, enjoyable experience for our NYC final evening! So many extras of cheese, bread, etc. that were delicious.
George and his fellow servers were gracious and attentive.

Wha a gem we found in the village. We were full before our orders even came out! If I had to say one negative thing, it would be that the wait staff was almost too attentive. The food was stellar! We were just on our way to the comedy club down the street, wish we had more time to stay and enjoy the ambience of this little treasure!

Start off with complimentary Parmesan and bruschetta which went great with our bottle of Brunello. They also gave us a comp of meatballs and some terrific toasted garlic bread. Had spaghetti amertriciana and veal limon which was outstanding. Four of us had great meals but fruti di mar pasta dish was the best dish on table.

Absolutely loved it! We’ll be back!

Fantastic experience here. Was recommended by a friend, and she did not disappoint! Came to celebrate a friend's recent wedding, and had a great night with impeccable service and delicious food. If you're looking for a small, classy place to celebrate a special occasion, or just somewhere to find delicious food with outstanding service, you can't go wrong here.

Amazing service !!

It is always a treat to eat at IL Mulino, the food and service are among the very best in NYC!

This place used to be tremendous. This week, the appetizers and the "extras" were great. However, during our recent visit, the $44 chicken parmigiana was almost tasteless and nowhere near as good as we have had in many other NYC restaurants for significantly less money. The value just was not there..

Birthday dinner, everything about it was fabulous!

Food always excellent . Place is a bit small but not noisy . Servers provide excellent snd attentive service

The staff was great!!

I was expecting more flavor in the pastas was kinda bland

Been going here since the late 1980's. Many of the staff have been there that long or longer. It's been a staple of the West Village for generations. Very romatic and a celebrity magnate.

The food and service were both excellent. Top notch restaurant!

Amazing food. Best service in nyc.

Wonderful place for a special dinner

First time at this location. Think I noted some of the same personnel from uptown :-) Food and Service superb, always great!

Couldn’t have been better, service and food were excellent

My wife and I were celebrating our anniversary. From the very start until we were finished it was very special. As soon as we sat down, a cheese was served, fresh hot rolls were served, bite size warm garlic bread was served , brochette was served, all without asking. Our meal was outstanding, we had spaghetti carbonara and Dover Sole . Just when we thought we were finished , they served us complimentary after dinner wine and complimentary dessert. What a special treat for the entire evening !

Love it here. Old school Italian at its finest. The food is amazing, the service wonderful, and it is such a warm and lively place, yet romantic. Thank you I’ll Mulino!

Overwhelmingly great service. Food is fantastic. Top 10 experience.

It’s the food! Simple as that.
All the starters they bring before you even order are incredible.

The food is fab and they bring lots of extras for your trial and enjoyment

Fantastic experience,,

They have finally updated the wine list, which before was poorly selected and way overpriced. Now there are very good wine options at a fair price. The food and service have always been 5-stars....probably the best in NYC. I had given them a 1-star review before solely based on their their previous wine list but doing so broke my heart as it has long been my favorite Italian food in NY. I guess they listened as sometimes a shot across the bow wakes up the prior person who ordered the wine. Thank you.

You never leave hungry, everything is the best in the city (pasta, veal, seafood, rack of lamb, even the steak is as good as it gets anywhere). Finally, the single best of the best things is the Maitre D and head waiter, Claudio. He is better than the best. What a great person and the perfect host.

Came for lunch restaurant week and NYU graduation. Perfect all the way.

I’ll Mulino is consistently good The problem is Open Table misrepresenting the availability of reservations.

Perfection, from the moment you walk in the door it is clear you are in for a once in a lifetime experience. You are greeted like you are family, the cocktails are superb, the food is beyond your expectations. We were celebrating our 30th anniversary and it was definitely a highlight in our 30 years together, the staff made us feel wonderful including singing to us as they presented dessert. If you are celebrating a special occasion look no further. Thank you for making our night so memorable.

The rest was empty on Monday. The food as usual was excellent. I do have one comment. Rest week is listed as 3 courses. When we finished our first 2 we were then told that there would be NO desert. If was either or - a first course or desert. This should have been told to us at the start of the Neal not the end. If rest are going to change the rules they should post them on the site.

Delicious food and superb service!and many complimentary appetizers to start off the meal. The atmosphere is charming and romantic.

Very good upscale Italian restaurant with old world charm (at the W.3rd St. location). They know what they're doing.

The best restaurant in NYC

Great food and service