Il Mulino New York - Downtown

I had higher expectations- a wine list with older wines was missing, service wasn’t punctual yet started our gracious and friendly. Food was good but not great. I guess I thought this was a top ten Italian restaurant in NYC and maybe it is in the next ten. For instance, I have had much better wine lists - 2010 and much older, at other Italian restaurants at better prices. I have also had much better service and better food choices.

Never a disappointment! Most amazing meal each time we go. The service is impeccable.

Cozy Italian restaurant. Many daily, homemade pasta specials. Attentive service. Good for special occasions. Appropriate attire required.

My sons birthday dinner.

Nothing like it used to be. Food was not fresh. I will not go back

Just plain awesome! Loved it and cannot wait to return! Plus they could not have been nicer to our 6 year old daughter.

Amazing food and service. Very upscale, high end food and experience. Worth every penny. We love it there

It’s an overrated place with less than mediocre food and very terrible service. Very uncomfortable. Dark small crowded room.

One of the best eating experiences I ever had. Service was exceptional very professional and friendly. The food variety and quality was second to done. You think your in Italy 🇮🇹

I greatly enjoyed my Restaurant Week lunch at Il Mulino. The service was very sweet and the staff was welcoming. There was some fried zucchini, bruschetta and a basket of bread to start. All good. My waiter recommended the meatball appetizer and he didn't steer me wrong - it was terrific. For main course, I had the sea bass with shrimp, mussels, clams and a delicious sauce. Spot on! I tasted both desserts, a citrus panna cotta and a pear dessert with zabaglione and whipped cream. Actually didn't like either of these too much. The room could use a little sprucing up - looks like it hasn't been done in awhile. Mainly my experience was very positive and I would definitely come back.

One of my favorite restaurants, food is always amazing, service matches. You would not know this is here walking by, never disappoints. While the kitchen is small, it turns out some of the best food in the city.

Consistently good. The service is always exemplary This is aneighborhood restaurant we always patronize. The food is always good. They take care of us, as hey do all patrons. I give gift cards to Il Mulino as Christmas presents.

Went for lunch during restaurant week. It was nothing special. The service was excellent however.

Great experiance

Incredible food and service. A classic Italian restaurant that is always unique and of the highest quality

Absolutely amazing dinner, service. The waiters make you feel like your at home!

Excellent service food was very good but main attraction ambiance and service

Amazing experience as usual!

This was the best restaurant I have ever been to. Service and food were outstanding.

Another great experience. Relatively small dining area but feels cozy not cramped. The cheese, zucchini and garlic bread they serve within minutes of sitting were delicious. It went up from there. Worth a visit!

One of the top restaurants in NYC.

This was recommended by a friend how insisted we would regret it if we did bot go. He was right. Such great service combined with fantastic dishes, This please is a must for anyone going to New York. It will be an annual stop for us now.

Love this place!!! Makes a wonderful meals feel special even if it is every day!

Love love it!

Best Italian food ever!!!!

Oh My Gosh! From the start where you are given thinly sliced grilled zucchini pieces, to the end with the after dinner drink, II Mulino impresses. The garlic bread, cheese, 5 other options of bread all before your apps come blew us away. The service was impeccable. Gotta check this place out. We will be coming back every time we go to NYC

Fabulous food, hospitality and ambiance! A wonderful evening!

Amazing as always! Wonderful service and delicious food!

Thank you to the whole team at Il Mulino for the wo derful experience. Food was absolutely fantastic. Authen5ic Italian vibe and cuisine

Waiter should have informed us price os rack of lamb and not be chocked,!,,

Best restaurant in New York City. Bar none. Every single thing they prepare is the most outstanding version of that dish possible. LOOK OUT FOR THE SPECIALS. Get the black truffle ravioli, the rack of lamb is unbelievable, and the dessert of the poached pear soaked in white wine and topped with zabaglione will knock you out. Wine list could be improved a bit, but not enough of a flaw to take away from the delicious food. Wonderful, wonderful place.

All went well till I figured they charge me a different dish I ordered and cost $90 instead of the $45 I thought ... they said I ordered something different ... but i thought client is always right ! Did not happen this time

Wonderful restaurant t, wonderful time. Food is outstanding.

As per the last 10000 million times, fantastic. Never a single complaint !

Was very disappointed with the overall experience. The ambiance felt unrefined and claustrophobic with waiters buzzing around and serving very casually and rushed. The food was mediocre at best and very expensive. We had to send back the porcini ravioli special (which came out suspiciously quickly) as it was drowned in a sauce that was too creamy and sticky and tasted like out of a can. The meatballs were average. The veal chops and the rack of lamb specials were ludicrously expensive ($72 and $90, respectively!!) and were not very good. The veal chop was the biggest disappointment of all. While it was appropriately cooked (medium rare) you could not taste the veal at all since it was covered in garlic, garlic crusted, garlic oil, garlic everything! All you could taste is garlic which stayed with me until the very next day. The lamb was over cooked and covered in a sauce which was too sour and overpowering. The best part of the meal was the wine - a brunello for $170. For this price tag do yourself a favor and go to Le Bernardin....not this atrocious restaurant.

Amazing meal food recommendations wine, ask for Rudy and share a grappa with Andrea. The most amazing buffalo mozzarella app and delicious pasta with white truffle and veal piccata to die for! Service impeccable. Overall A+ and we have eaten a lot of Italian food.

Great whenever with whoever for whatever occasion

Il Mulino never disappoints. After dining there for over 20 years you appreciate the culinary experience. Every bite is perfect and you don’t want the meal to end. The Ricotta Cheesecake is to die for!

The dinner exceeding expectation...top notch service and the food was memorable. I highly recommend the veal milanese and the spaghetti carbonara. You will not be disappointed.

Amazing as always. Best place in the city!