Harry & Izzy’s is the place to see and be seen enticing locals and tourists alike. From our lively bar centered in the restaurant to our unique dining rooms and broad menu, Harry & Izzy’s is sure to please even the most demanding appetite.View Private Dining Details
Awesome every year
Food is always fantastic! Service is even better. Amy and Jaci are so pleasant and really know the wine list and the menu from front and back! Don't pass "GO" and head right to H&I's!!
Had a reservation and was taken upstairs to the back room which has practically empty. We sat and stewed over such a HORRIBLE table until we told the server we wanted a new table, downstairs where it was busier with more people and a better ambience. He led us downstairs and pretty much just said sir in the bar, it's open seating. Meanwhile nice tables by the windows went unoccupied. A really crappy experience. Not sure I'll come back. Just don't understand why we were taken to such an awful part of the restaurant when we had a reservation and there were clearly better tables available. The hostesses seemed immature and inexperienced and the server Mohimad had an attitude when we asked for a new table. Zero stars.
Good food and service as you would expect.
Excellent, steak was outstanding!
Harry and izzys goes above and beyond every single time i dine here. The waitress my group had on Saturday 4/21/18 was incredible. She was informative and easy to talk to. This place even boxes up unfinished food you may have had for you and puts it in a nice carry out bag. The toasted ravioli appetizer is absolutely incredible.
Had been told by others that Harry & Izzy's and St Elmo's was a great place for a wedding anniversary date, but my wife and I both strongly disagree. The atmosphere was pleasant, the service was good, but the food was absolutely horrible (i.e., Izzy Style New York Strip, Bone-in Ribeye, and Brussels Sprouts with Bacon). I would rather had a McDonald's hamburger and I hate McDonald's. The World Famous St. Elmo Shrimp Cocktail was only ok at best. The best part was their dinner rolls. I definitely will never be going back. Go to Ruth's Chris instead. I paid $170 and got ripped off. I fix a much better steak myself with steaks from Walmart.
We really enjoyed our visit. The prime rib sandwich was delicious, the servers were very attentive, and the ambiance is beautiful.
Family get together
Great classic steak house experience in an environment that is not stuffy or pretentious
Perfect food. Perfect server. Great experience.
Poor table made up by good service and food.
A fun choice for a group. Food was quite good but not exceptional. The Indy martini - two thumbs up. Shrimp cocktail was highly anticipated but beware - even for someone who LOVES horseradish, the cocktail sauce was overpowering (think runny nose, watery eyes). Spinach salad was excellent
Great time and food
Before Pacer game. Nice corner booth on 2nd floor. Tried shrimp cocktail for first time. Waitress gave good instructions so I would not be overwhelmed by spices! Good prime rib sandwich big enough to share. Same for pizza.
Dinner before a Pacers game
Great service and food! Sat at a table around the bar. Cool vibe. We really enjoyed the whole experience. Will definitely be back!
Great food, service was outstanding and very pleasant atmosphere
Great bone in ribeye and Creme brule
Giselle took great care of our group. Wonderful food, well mixed drinks and an insanely good dessert (shared, more than big enough for three) rounded out a lovely evening. The shrimp cocktail is a standout.
Great place to eat!!
Food was amazing. Will be going back from Oklahoma to take my husband! Very pricy though!
Always consistent in being Amazing!! The prime rib pizza is amazing and the shrimp cocktail! Simple items that are way more than outstanding!!!
If I could have scored lower on service I would have. We were treated entirely different by our waiter from the older group sitting next to us. Service was terrible due to the less than helpful server. Beverages were not monitored for refills, he checked on our table maybe twice, we weren't offered a wine menu or dessert. Our group of six left disappointed with the service. Food was to die for though.
SrProm double date .
Everything was great
Our server was very kind and took very good care of us. The food was delicious. It was a great treat before prom and I would recommend, especially for those looking for a nice restaurant to eat out at.
Great food! The ribeye was well cooked and flavorful. The creamed spinach was the best I have eaten. Price is comparable to a good steak restaurant. Service was exceptional and after all you get what you pay for.
Birthday for our daughter- server was wonderful with her
Enjoyed dinner here with a business colleague from another state. Service was very good and we were able to to carry on a lengthy conversation without shouting or feeling rushed. As always, the food was delicious.
Our waitress, Jessica, was absolutely delightful and excellent. The food was outstanding.
Great place with excellent food and exceptional service
Exceptional from the cocktails all the way through the steak to the dessert! I will be back!
Our group was in town for a conference and your restaurant was recommended to us. Food & service was exceptional and will definitely be back.
Experience was good.
I think servers come back too often to take plates.
Very expensive lunch.
Ambiance nothing compared to St. Elmo’s
Horseradish was especially spicy on this visit from what I saw. Even though it is what Harry & Izzy’s is known for, you can have a great experience without eating it...or steak!
The famous shrimp cocktail is a joke. Briny shrimp with a straight horseradish (sauce?) give me a break! Our group was rating everyone's gag, cough and sneeze response.
On the positive side, the prime rib sandwich with homemade chips were excellent.
The steaks are great as is the shrimp cocktail
Although the food was excellent, and the surroundings really great, what really stood out was the extraordinary level of service, from the moment that we entered this restaurant, until the minute that we left. Service just doesn't come any better than what we received at lunch, even though the restaurant was packed, as a result of a convention in town. One would never have guessed, because the service was perfect, and the food great!
Good place for a business meal. Portions on the sandwiches and burgers are large, but order a salad and you will be leaving hungry.
The service was fantastic! Great food selection and quality.