Best Historic Restaurants in Lyndhurst

Fantastic night! Great friends, great food and service! It was great seeing Dante and Phil

This is our first time going here and we were amazed by the service and the quality of the food. There’s little extra touches that they go to that made us really appreciate the meal. We plan on going back there many times in the future.

We had 4 different, delicious meals today. Our server, Bianca, was outstanding. She was knowledgeable about the menu and kept our drinks fresh. She was also able to converse with 4 older patrons and was just a breath of fresh air. This is the second time I’ve eaten at OddFellows and plan to go again! The salmon was cooked perfectly, the aioli and potatoes were amazing! My meal mates enjoyed Tai beef, steak and shrimp pasta. We all were very pleased. Making reservations was easy as well.

This is one of our favorite restaurants in Cleveland. They’ve been delivering consistently creative quality for almost 2 decades. It all starts at the top and is reflected in the warm and friendly service. The flavors are wonderful — they make one pause and smile. Lobster roll and Kobe beef gyoza were our particular favorites this time. We always leave more than satisfied!

Great authentic Italian dishes. Highly recommend the calamari!!