Best Restaurants for Outdoor Dining in Water Mill

Still our favorite restaurant in the world. Yes the entire world. It does not matter what you order to eat or drink, it will be the most amazing thing you ever tasted every single time. Worth the long drive and every penny.

We have been to Calissa many times but this last time it was just me and my son. We enjoyed the pre fixe menu and it was all our favorite dishes for an amazing deal. Highly recommend taking advantage of this deal during a weeknight date. We were so full we had to take home! My son loves the pita and dips and certainly had his fair share. Everything was delicious and it might become a weeknight hotspot for us now.

A Perfect Evening at Almond – Worth the Journey My wife and I had an unforgettable dinner at Almond in Bridgehampton last night, and I can’t stop thinking about it. We started with the duck confit, perfectly crisp and rich. For our mains, my wife had an exquisite scallop dish in a delicate mint sauce, and I had the simply prepared pan-seared striped sea bass on wilted greens: divine. Flaky, fresh, and full of flavor. The real showstopper was the sticky toffee date cake with ice cream. It was quite possibly the best dessert I’ve ever had. I only wish I didn’t live 1,000 miles away because I’d be back next week. A truly exceptional meal in every way. Thanks.

We had the absolute pleasure of having this restaurant cater my friend’s birthday lunch, and it was nothing short of exceptional. The atmosphere was warm, welcoming, and just right for a special occasion—elegant without being stuffy. The food was truly outstanding. Every dish, from appetizers to desserts, was full of flavor, beautifully presented, and clearly made with high-quality ingredients. The mains were especially impressive—generously portioned and perfectly cooked. It’s rare for everyone at the table to be this happy with their meal, but that was definitely the case here. A special shoutout to our server, Mary Ann, who made the entire experience even better. She was friendly, professional, and incredibly attentive throughout the afternoon. She struck the perfect balance between being helpful and giving us space to enjoy the celebration. Her timing was impeccable, she knew the menu well, and her warm energy really added to the occasion. Thanks to Mary Ann and the whole team, the birthday lunch was seamless and memorable. We’re already talking about coming back!

Food was excellent! Good service - highly recommend