Best Cozy Restaurants in Cole Bay

Absolutely incredible ambiance, food, and service! All of the staff was incredibly welcoming and friendly especially the Chef. Seeing an environment with such an inviting and involved Chef shows the hospitality starts from there. He was everywhere and constantly checking in on the customers while maintaining a healthy flow of service from the kitchen. 10/10 will recommend to all my friends and family visiting the island. We will definitely be back!!

Excellent dining experience, food was outstanding, perfectly prepared. For starters we had the salmon carpaccio it was light lemony, fresh & delicious, we both had warm bread with 3 types of butters coffee, a mix of rosemary & thyme, regular butter amazing. 12 oz Strip steak cooked to perfection, very tender. The Chicken Don Ricardo was so good it was accompanied with a salad with spiral beets, goat cheese, strawberries, orange slices over spinach with a light house dressing, for sides we shared grilled asparagus and mushrooms, the mushrooms were scrumptious with a little kick. Isaiah, our server, extremely friendly and attentive. Father’s Day, father’s received 2 complimentary cocktails or 2 glasses of wine, a nice touch.

We took the advice of others and sat at a high top table in the center bar- and got to take advantage of having access to both the Roma and Mr. Chow menus. The bartender happened to grab the chef just as we ordered to make sure our son’s food could be prepared gluten free (celiac). Service was great, food was amazing. Only drawback was that the bar music was a tad too loud.

We had THE best table in the house! Amazing ambiance and service! Food was incredible! Will definitely return!

Loved the ambience, phenomenal meal, and impeccable service delivered by friendly staff. My most pleasant dining experience in a long time!