4 Best Authentic Restaurants in Shelter Island

4 restaurants available nearby

How are Featured results ranked

A photo of The Terrace at the Pridwin restaurant

1. The Terrace at the Pridwin

4.6

Exceptional(200)

Price: Very Expensive

• American • Shelter Island

Booked 28 times today

Take your seat on The Terrace, The Pridwin’s signature waterfront restaurant and bar overlooking the scenic shores of Crescent Beach. Enjoy a seamless blend of indoor and outdoor dining, where each table offers breathtaking views of the bay. Rooted in timeless Pridwin tradition, The Terrace presents a reimagined Mediterranean menu that celebrates the best of Long Island sourced ingredients. With a commitment to quality and sustainability, every dish is thoughtfully prepared using fresh ingredients from local farms, fishermen, and artisans. Whether you're here for sunset cocktails or a leisurely dinner, The Terrace promises an unforgettable culinary experience in a setting like no other.

2. Olive Branch Cafe

4.5

Awesome(201)

Price: Expensive

• Mediterranean • Greenport

Booked 2 times today

Turkish Restaurant offering numerous Mediterranean menu items. Unwind in our comfortable atmosphere while sipping of a cup of coffer or tea. Join us for Breakfast, Lunch, or Dinner!

3. ZErdem

4.9

Exceptional(38)

Price: Expensive

• Mediterranean • Greenport

Booked 4 times today

Indulge in the rich flavors and vibrant culinary traditions of the Mediterranean at ZErdem Nestled in the heart of Greenport our restaurant is a haven for food enthusiasts seeking an authentic taste of the sun-kissed Mediterranean coast. From the tantalizing aromas of freshly baked bread to the sizzle of savory grilled meats, our menu showcases a delightful fusion of Mediterranean delights. Immerse yourself in a sensory journey, where each dish is crafted with passion and meticulous attention to detail. With our warm and inviting ambiance, accompanied by exceptional service, ZErdem promises a dining experience that will transport you to the shores of the Mediterranean. Discover the art of Mediterranean cuisine and create unforgettable memories with every bite.

A photo of The North Fork Table & Inn restaurant

4. The North Fork Table & Inn

4.7

Exceptional(2459)

Price: Very Expensive

• Contemporary American • Southold

Booked 43 times today

North Fork Table is an East End institution. Set in a historic countryside home, the restaurant celebrates the bounty of Long Island’s farms, vineyards & waterways with menus by restaurateur & chef John Fraser. The restaurant’s menu focus is seasonally inspired featuring locally grown biodynamic and organic produce, the freshest seafood from the pristine Peconic Bay and Long Island Sound and award-winning North Fork duck and beef. Increasingly distinguished and awarded Long Island wines are highlighted on the wine list, as well as their national and international counterparts.

Best Authentic Restaurants in Shelter Island

Price

Cuisine

Regions

Neighborhoods

Dining Options

Seating Options

Accessibility

4 restaurants available nearby

1. The Terrace at the Pridwin

2. Olive Branch Cafe

3. ZErdem

4. The North Fork Table & Inn

See what locals rave about

Explore OpenTable