44 Best Sicilian Restaurants In Cold Spring Harbor

A photo of The Farm Italy Restaurant + Bar Huntington restaurant

1. The Farm Italy Restaurant + Bar Huntington

4.7

Exceptional(2264)

Price: Expensive

• Sicilian • Huntington

Booked 71 times today

The Farm Italy Restaurant + Bar in Huntington stands out as a premier cocktail bar with an "intriguing collection of alluring cocktails" that perfectly complement its exquisite Italian cuisine. Guests rave about the "perfect cocktails and wine pairing," enhancing their dining experience. The ambiance is described as "beautiful and welcoming," making it an ideal setting for a memorable night out. Patrons frequently mention the "superb service" and attention to detail, ensuring every visit feels special. This cocktail bar promises not just a meal but a delightful experience that "never disappoints," inviting diners to return for both its drinks and delectable menu offerings.

A photo of Barrotta’s Supper Club restaurant

2. Barrotta’s Supper Club

4.6

Exceptional(92)

Price: Expensive

• Sicilian • Huntington

Booked 2 times today

Barrotta’s Supper Club in Huntington offers an exceptional blend of American and Italian-American cuisine that has diners raving. With a menu that channels the essence of "old-school Italian dining," every dish feels like a nostalgic journey back to a classic New York City supper club. Diners frequently applaud the generous portions and "delicious" flavors, especially the meatballs and beef Wellington. The lively atmosphere, enhanced by live jazz, creates a "cozy and classy" experience that is both "intimate" and "sophisticated." Guests are warmly greeted, making you feel "like family." Barrotta’s Supper Club is indeed a "must-visit" spot in Huntington.

A photo of The Ivy Kitchen & Bar restaurant

3. The Ivy Kitchen & Bar

4.4

Awesome(310)

Price: Expensive

• Sicilian • Huntington

Booked 9 times today

The Ivy Kitchen & Bar in Huntington Village is a standout for authentic American cuisine, offering a delightful combination of charm and culinary excellence. With a menu that rivals top steakhouses, diners rave about the "amazing food" and "great atmosphere," making it a perfect spot for any occasion. Patrons highlight the impeccable service, with servers like Patrick and Breezy leaving lasting impressions. Enthusiasts of American flavors will appreciate the diverse offerings, from succulent steaks to creative twists on classic dishes. The Ivy truly shines as a "hidden neighborhood gem," delivering experiences that diners "can't wait to go back" for.

A photo of Edoardo's Trattoria restaurant

4. Edoardo's Trattoria

4.9

Exceptional(214)

Price: Very Expensive

• Sicilian • Huntington

Booked 11 times today

A fresh take on classic Italian fare, using premium and locally sourced ingredients.You are welcomed with exceptional service and a warm smile.

A photo of Jonathan's Ristorante - Huntington Village restaurant

5. Jonathan's Ristorante - Huntington Village

4.7

Exceptional(1865)

Price: Expensive

• Sicilian • Huntington

Booked 28 times today

Jonathan's Ristorante delivers first class Italian fare presented by an excellent staff. With a brand new outdoor patio to be enjoyed on a nice afternoon or evening, the elegant yet informal affair can make everyone feel right at home. Jonathan's Ristorante has been around for 24 years, serving up popular dishes like our Tuna Tartare appetizer, Mushroom Risotto with Truffle Butter, or the Mediterranean Branzino. Happy Hour offered through the week is the best way to have a fun night out with friends, serving fresh oysters and hand crafted cocktails. Our Wine List offers an incredible selection by the glass and bottle as well. Jonathan's Ristorante is located on 15 Wall Street in the heart of Huntington Village, with proximity to The Paramount Theatre for a show, Cinema Arts Centre and AMC Loews for a movie night.

A photo of 1653 Pizza Company restaurant

6. 1653 Pizza Company

4.7

Exceptional(159)

Price: Expensive

• Sicilian • Huntington

Booked 3 times today

1653 Pizza Company is a culinary gem nestled in the heart of Huntington Village, Long Island, renowned for its coal-fired pizza that has pizza lovers raving. "Outstanding pizza—nice people working there," exclaims one enthusiastic diner, capturing the essence of the warm and inviting atmosphere. The pizzeria's commitment to quality is evident in every bite, with a menu that is "eclectic and delicious," offering seasonally updated options that keep patrons coming back for more. With "excellent food and service" consistently highlighted by diners, 1653 Pizza Company promises an unforgettable dining experience that elevates the Pizza Bar to new heights.

A photo of Lasagna Huntington Restaurant restaurant

7. Lasagna Huntington Restaurant

4.6

Exceptional(191)

Price: Expensive

• Sicilian • Huntington

Booked 6 times today

Lasagna Huntington Restaurant is a shining star of Contemporary Italian cuisine in Huntington, Long Island. Renowned for its "absolutely delicious" dishes, this gem offers over 17 varieties of baked-to-order lasagnas, allowing guests to craft their own unique creations. The restaurant's dedication to "perfecting traditional recipes while also crafting new ones" is evident in every bite, from the best-ever spinach lasagna to the "incredible menu of pastas". With a focus on fresh ingredients and delectable flavors, it's no surprise that diners "cannot wait to go back again". Whether you're a fan of classic Italian or seeking new culinary adventures, Lasagna Huntington promises an unforgettable dining experience.

A photo of Piccolo Restaurant of Huntington restaurant

8. Piccolo Restaurant of Huntington

4.8

Exceptional(1883)

Price: Very Expensive

• Sicilian • Huntington

Booked 21 times today

Piccolo Restaurant of Huntington is a shining star in the world of Contemporary American cuisine, effortlessly blending New American-Italian flavors with a flair that keeps diners returning for more. Nestled in Huntington, this culinary gem "deserves its reputation" for offering "superb cuisine" that delights the palate with fresh ingredients and creative dishes. The "top-notch" service and "intimate" ambiance create an atmosphere perfect for any occasion, whether it's a romantic dinner or a special celebration. With an "Award of Excellence" from Wine Spectator in 2024, Piccolo's commitment to quality and authenticity makes it a must-visit destination for Contemporary American dining enthusiasts.

A photo of Matteo's of Huntington restaurant

9. Matteo's of Huntington

4.6

Exceptional(1581)

Price: Moderate

• Sicilian • Huntington

Booked 17 times today

Generous portions of Italian classicsOutdoor dining available as well as indoor.

10. CARPACCIO

4.2

Awesome(484)

Price: Moderate

• Sicilian • Huntington

Booked 7 times today

Carpaccio in Huntington Station offers a genuine taste of Mediterranean cuisine, capturing the vibrant flavors and essence of the region. Patrons rave about the "incredible food" that "transports you to a villa under the Mediterranean sun," with dishes like expertly prepared Snapper and Chicken Milanese. The atmosphere combines modern elegance with rustic charm, creating a dining experience that feels both upscale and welcoming. Reviewers are consistently impressed by the "attentive and accommodating" service, highlighting servers like Dani V and Ray for their exceptional hospitality. Carpaccio’s dedication to quality and authenticity makes it a standout choice for those seeking a Mediterranean culinary adventure.

Best Sicilian Restaurants in Cold Spring Harbor

Price

Regions

Neighborhoods

Top Rated

Dining Options

Seating Options

Accessibility

44 restaurants available nearby

1. The Farm Italy Restaurant + Bar Huntington

2. Barrotta’s Supper Club

3. The Ivy Kitchen & Bar

4. Edoardo's Trattoria

5. Jonathan's Ristorante - Huntington Village

6. 1653 Pizza Company

7. Lasagna Huntington Restaurant

8. Piccolo Restaurant of Huntington

9. Matteo's of Huntington

10. CARPACCIO

Explore OpenTable