Best Pizzeria Restaurants in Theater District / Times Square

We visited on 6/4/21 and New York is still emerging from the COVID shutdown. The restaurant was almost empty and there was a hostess and one waitress working. They were both very kind and attentive. We sat outside on the "outdoor seating" they built for COVID. The food was decent but nothing...See More

Great restaurant and will go back again. Thank you.

Pizza is excellent. And our waitress, Nubia was lovely and great.

Best pasta carbonara I’ve ever had!! Food was amazing!!

Great pizza. Well priced wines. Nice outdoor space. Definitely a midtown bargain.

What a wonderful surprise! I had a delicious lunch at Jeannie's. My salad and shrimp puttanesca were both outstanding. And the carrot cake was wonderful. The space is airy and casual, and my server Danny was excellent. He made sure that everything was perfect. (Prices are also VERY reasonable.) A...See More

Really great. Food was excellent and innovative, portions were nice size, everyone was very hospitable, and it was perfect for a comfortable, quiet and relaxed dinner. Would absolutely return.

Everyone was super nice. It felt great to experience a aswome dinner from the other side of the line. Was referred to as being like family, felt every bit of it Thanks guys.

42nd Street Pizza remains one of the most popular in New York thanks to its fresh offerings and classic pizzas. Give their menu a try and see what all the fuss is about.If you're feeling hungry, don't hesitate. Enjoy the top dishes New York has to offer.

Really good food, you won't regret going there at all. I feel like the pizzas could have been cooked a little longer, a little on the doughy side, but the overall experience was great, so I'd honestly go back and maybe just ask for my pizza to be cooked a little more well done.