Best Italian Restaurants in Middleton

8 restaurants available nearby

Johnny's Italian Steakhouse - Middleton1. Johnny's Italian Steakhouse - Middleton0.17 mi
(293 reviews)
$$$$
Steakhouse | Middleton,

"It was not busy, and we sat in a comfortable booth. Our server was polite and attentive. Everything was delicious"See more

Villa Dolce2. Villa Dolce0.74 mi
(423 reviews)
$$$$
Italian | Middleton,

"We love Villa Dolce...great food, ambience and service in happening downtown Middleton. It's always a treat."See more

Vin Santo- Wisconsin3. Vin Santo- Wisconsin0.78 mi
(883 reviews)
$$$$
Italian | Middleton,

"We are regular Vin Santo customers and we have never been disappointed. Always great food and service."See more

Benvenutos - Middleton4. Benvenutos - Middleton0.96 mi
(73 reviews)
$$$$
Italian | Madison,

"Good food. No issues"See more

Cento5. Cento7.18 mi
(1684 reviews)
$$$$
Italian | Madison,

"A wonderful brunch! Loved the corned beef and egg sandwich, and there are still other things I want to come back and try!"See more

Harvest - Wisconsin6. Harvest - Wisconsin7.34 mi
(493 reviews)
$$$$
American | Madison,

"Harvest offers many excellent seasonal choices. My husband had a pork chop that he said was wonderful and I had scallops which were probably the best I've ever had. Also, we both loved the mushrooms. Everything from drinks to dessert was exceptional. I highly recommend."See more

Johnny's Italian Steakhouse - Sun Prairie7. Johnny's Italian Steakhouse - Sun Prairie14.12 mi
(238 reviews)
$$$$
Steakhouse | Sun Prairie,

"Great service and the food was delicious. I always ask what they recommend and they never let me down."See more

Sarento's Italian Restaurant8. Sarento's Italian Restaurant36.98 mi
(131 reviews)
$$$$
Italian | Wisconsin Dells / Lake Delton,

"Other than one alcoholic beverage’s having been less than expected, our entire experience was excellent."See more