Enable JavaScript to run this app.
Skip to main content
OpenTable logo
  1. Home
  2. United States
  3. New York State

Best Italian Restaurants in Fire Island

Price

17 restaurants available nearby

A photo of Butera's Restaurant of Sayville restaurant
4.5
Awesome(1394)
Price: Moderate
• Italian • Sayville
Booked 6 times today
Butera's Restaurant of Sayville has created a compelling reputation for being a beloved hub of Italian cuisine. From its origins in Massapequa Park to its current location in Sayville, the restaurant has consistently upheld its tradition of outstanding food, drinks, and service, as quoted from various customer reviews. Noted to be generous with portion sizes and consistently delicious, Butera's offers an extensive menu promising a genuine Italian dining experience. It's a go-to spot for local Italian food enthusiasts and is highly recommended for its excellent service, with the manager, Paul, being highly appreciated for his welcoming attitude. The restaurant is valued not only for its food but also for its warm, customer-friendly environment. Whether it's a family celebration or a casual dinner, Butera's always guarantees an enjoyable experience.
A photo of ITA Kitchen - Patchogue restaurant
4.5
Awesome(238)
Price: Moderate
• Italian • Patchogue
Booked 12 times today
ITA Kitchen offers innovative Italian American cuisine in a lively restaurant atmosphere. Whether it's a date night or dinner with family and friends, ITA kitchen is the perfect destination for a night out.
A photo of Metros on Main restaurant
4.4
Awesome(3)
Price: Expensive
• Italian • Sayville
Booked 3 times today
This is trendy but comfortable.Italian kitchen and pie bar has an amazing atmosphere, Amazing staff, an amazing bar.With specialty signature martini's live entertainment Friday and Saturday. A place where you could call home.Family owned and operated Metros on main where you are familyCome in and enjoy authentic Italian food.Crazy specialty bar pies. Or whatever you might feel like having danny the owner will accommodate
A photo of Stella Trattoria & Bar restaurant
4.8
Exceptional(1106)
Price: Moderate
• Italian • Blue Point
Booked 2 times today
Stella Trattoria & Bar is the epitome of fine Italian dining. The rave reviews are a testament to its culinary excellence, with patrons lauding the spot-on dishes, remarkable service, and beautiful ambiance. From the Chicken Mama to the Lobster Ravioli and the Linguini with Clam in Fra Diavlo sauce, the cuisine exemplifies authentic Italian flavors. The excellent service makes the dining experience memorable, ensuring no wine or water glass goes empty. The place is also acknowledged for its beautiful outdoor setup and generous portion sizes. Stella Trattoria & Bar presents traditional Italian food with a twist, consistently surprising customers with distinct dishes on the menu. It has become the "go-to" Italian restaurant for many, highly recommended for its delightful atmosphere, fantastic food, and stellar service.
A photo of Lombardi's on the Bay restaurant
4.5
Awesome(781)
Price: Moderate
• Italian • Patchogue
Booked 21 times today
Lombardi's on the Bay is renowned for its exceptional Italian cuisine. The authenticity of its homemade flavors, particularly in dishes like the meatball and sauce, as well as the lobster raviolis and rigatoni with meatballs, have been praised by reviewers, with one Italian-American customer certifying Lombardi's Italian food as the "real deal". The restaurant also offers a stunning water view setting, enhancing the dining experience. From standout appetizers like the grilled octopus and Fried Zucchini to main dishes such as the pork ossobuco and seafood tower, every plate promises a generous portion of deliciousness. The warm ambiance, personable servers, and efficient service further establish Lombardi's on the Bay as a top choice for delivering a memorable Italian dining experience.
A photo of Mamma Lombardi's restaurant
4.6
Exceptional(481)
Price: Moderate
• Italian • Holbrook
Booked 11 times today
Mamma Lombardi's is widely recognized for its exceptional Italian cuisine. The restaurant consistently receives fantastic reviews, with multiple patrons emphasizing the remarkable authenticity of the food. Its loyal customers often highlight the large portions, outstanding service, and an impressive array of menu options that provides an excellent representation of Italian culinary tradition. As one customer noted, "Italian authentic food. Delicious and reasonable priced." Another long-term patron said, "The food is as excellent as it was the very first time." Mamma Lombardi's commitment to quality and authenticity makes it a top choice for Italian dining.
A photo of Locale restaurant
4.4
Awesome(681)
Price: Moderate
• Italian • Patchogue
Booked 4 times today
Locale is an exceptional Italian restaurant nested in the heart of Patchogue village, close to the local theater. This restaurant serves both traditional Italian dishes and creative twists, all appreciated by patrons. Praised for its excellent service, great atmosphere, and attentive hosts, Locale has gained a reputation for its impeccable blend of service and culinary experience. As the reviews mention, "The seafood dishes are excellent and the pasta portions are generous", and "Food was delicious and served timely and hot". The restaurant is known for its creative menu, with items such as the Chicken Paillard and baked clams being big hits. This combined with a warm and friendly ambiance, makes Locale a favorite choice for many.
A photo of Marys Pizza & Restaurant restaurant
4.7
Exceptional(43)
Price: Moderate
• Italian • East Islip
Booked 2 times today
Marys Pizza & Restaurant is hailed for its exceptional Italian cuisine, consistently earning high praise from patrons for its sizable portions, fresh ingredients, and excellent preparation. Celebrated as a hidden gem, the restaurant is lauded for its menu's consistent quality and value, with one pleased customer stating: "No matter what you're in the mood for or decide to try for the first time…nothing on the menu disappoints." Notably, special themed nights like Chicken and Seafood nights are a hit, resulting in meals so large that guests often take home leftovers. The restaurant's success extends beyond its food, with its attentive service, warm atmosphere, and reasonable pricing also attracting commendation from diners. It's the perfect location for celebrations, family dining or simply treating oneself to a delectable Italian meal.
A photo of ITA Kitchen restaurant
4.5
Awesome(900)
Price: Expensive
• Italian • Bay Shore
Booked 20 times today
ITA Kitchen is an Italian restaurant highly praised in numerous reviews for its delightful cuisine and exceptional service. Diners describe their dishes as "amazing," "outstanding," and even the best Italian food they've ever had on Long Island. The restaurant has indoor and outdoor seating, with both options offering a great ambiance and beautiful decor. Staff members are frequently recognized as polite and attentive, significantly enhancing the dining experience. The menu includes a variety of vegetarian and vegan options, with most visitors stating they can't wait to return. ITA Kitchen evidently offers an elevated Italian dining experience, indicative of its reputation and popularity.
A photo of Ragazzi Italian Kitchen & Bar restaurant
4.7
Exceptional(3020)
Price: Moderate
• Italian • Nesconset
Booked 25 times today
Ragazzi Italian Kitchen & Bar is highly regarded for its authentic Italian cuisine, providing an exceptional dining experience that consistently leaves customers captivated. A review recurring theme is its remarkable consistency, whether in the quality of the ingredients used, the impeccable service, or the delightful flavors that capture the essence of Italy. A testament to its excellence is the phrase "best Italian place around hands down", with others noting that they frequently visit, some traveling 35 miles. Customers also appreciate its considerate service for gluten-free diners. In all, Ragazzi's is seen as a trusted go-to for Italian food and a top-notch dining experience.
‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.
OpenTable
  • About Us
  • Blog
  • Careers
  • Press
More
Businesses
  • Restaurant reservation software
  • Industry insights
  • Hospitality resources
  • Marketing resources
  • Operation resources
  • How to open a restaurant
  • For restaurants
  • For restaurant groups
Join us on
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Cookies and Interest-Based Ads
  • Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information
  • Cookie Preferences
Copyright © 2024 OpenTable, Inc. 1 Montgomery St Ste 500, San Francisco CA 94104 - All rights reserved.
OpenTable is part of Booking Holdings, the world leader in online travel and related services.
Booking Logo
Priceline Logo
KAYAK Logo
Agoda Logo
OpenTable Logo