Best Italian Restaurants in Fair Haven

Our server Carrie deserves a big shout out for what we as a great hospitality experience. We were celebrating 2 years to the day I had esophageal cancer surgery. Which left me with half of a stomach and esophagus. Needless to say I am not able to consume much food at a sitting. So we shared an order of Chicken Marcella with a spaghetti. Along with a side of mashed potatoes and a side Caesar salad. Carrie without any prompting served each of us our order placed upon two separate plates. Very thoughtful and pleasing to the eye. Carrie’s interest in us having a beautiful evening experience must be in the for front of her mind. Even capped off a wonderful dinning experience with a single strawberry pierced with a single lit candle surrounded by several lemon frosted cookies, scrumptious.

Nothing short of marvelous. Loved the atmosphere and the food was delicious. Very friendly waitress. It’s our new favorite Italian restaurant.

Great food in a beautiful outside setting. Enjoyable evening.

This was our first time here. We were a party of four. I’m going to tell you that a restaurant has one time to make a first impression, and for me that first impression is the host or hostess. If I am greeted warmly, with a smile, I am set up for a nice time. The hostess here never cracked a smile and barely uttered a word. I saw her seat many guests and I never once saw a smile on her face. She’s too young to be so miserable, so unless she was having a really bad night, she may not be the best front person. Let’s get to the food. We sat down and were immediately asked if we wanted drinks. I ordered sparkling water, my husband order wine, our friends order wine and some other drink (I wasn’t paying attention). The drinks came out pretty quickly (within 10 minutes). About 15 minutes later we placed an appetizer order (2 things) and our main courses. One appetizer came out in about ten minutes, the other in about 20 minutes. We were enjoying our appetizers and conversations. We also noticed that people around us who sat down after us had already been served dinner. We said nothing, and continued our conversations. Our reservations were at 6:30 and at 8:15 we still had not been served. Seems they dropped the ball on our order. After a few minutes we were served dinner. We weren’t mad, we didn’t get upset, we shrugged our shoulders and started telling story of other dining experiences where the ticket got “lost.” It happens. When the food arrived, we certainly enjoyed it as it was very good. Our server whose name were didn’t know had one chance to end our dinner on an up note by offering us dessert, but he didn’t. Not mad, but we discussed it on the drive home. One last thing….if you want a relaxing dinner where you can have a conversation with your dinner companion, this is not the place. The noise level is very high. The food is good, but I don’t know when I might be back.

Had a wonderful evening. The the service was spectacular, the drinks were great and the food was spectacular.