Best Italian Restaurants in Clintonville

Price: Moderate (112)Price: Expensive (48)Price: Very Expensive (9)

33 restaurants available nearby

A photo of Forno Kitchen and Bar restaurant

1. Forno Kitchen and Bar

4.8

Exceptional(2805)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Short North - Arena District

Booked 81 times today

Forno Kitchen and Bar is renowned for its outstanding American cuisine, a fact echoed by many of the restaurant's reviews. Diners acclaim not only the food, but also the ambiance and service, with one customer admitting, "The food was amazing and our waiter was great!" Others rave about the pesto pizza and homemade pecan pie, which is reportedly baked by the owner herself. Known as the "best brunch in Columbus," Forno Kitchen and Bar demonstrates its culinary excellence repeatedly with dishes like the breakfast sandwich and chicken and waffles. This well-loved eatery, beloved for its relaxed yet classy atmosphere and eclectic menu, certainly embodies the spirit and flavour of American cuisine.

2. Gallo's on High

4.6

Exceptional(444)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Columbus

Booked 10 times today

Gallo's on High is highly esteemed as one of the leading American cuisine restaurants in Columbus. Renowned for its excellent service, reviewers regularly praise the attentive waitstaff, particularly a server named Brian. Patrons appreciate Gallo's on High for its diverse menu and high-quality food, from delectable lemon pepper wings to mouthwatering pork chops. Many admire the creative cocktails and feel the prices are justified by the outstanding dining experience. The ambiance is described as cozy and elegant, further enhancing the exceptional dining experience. As one pleased customer states, "This is becoming the best American restaurant in Columbus!"

A photo of Marcella's - Short North restaurant

3. Marcella's - Short North

4.7

Exceptional(5598)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Short North - Arena District

Booked 92 times today

Marcella's, located in Columbus, is highly revered for its superb Italian cuisine. The restaurant has garnered gleaming reviews, with customers often labeling it as the "best Italian food" they've ever had. The menu offers a variety of dishes, with favorites such as the braised beef tortellini and the extravagant giant meatball, scoring high marks from patrons. The consistency in the quality of food and service has earned Marcella's a place in the hearts of many. The service is frequently described as outstanding and attentive, contributing to the warm and inviting atmosphere. With a bustling happy hour and a reputation for never disappointing, Marcella's has definitely carved out its place in the Italian food scene.

A photo of Martini Modern Italian restaurant

4. Martini Modern Italian

4.7

Exceptional(4885)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Short North - Arena District

Booked 59 times today

Martini Modern Italian is a renowned culinary gem in downtown Columbus, renowned for its impeccable cuisine and attentive service. This restaurant consistently receives high praise from its guests, many of whom emphasize the exceptional quality of food and service. Authentic dishes such as osso bucco, lamb pappardelle, and a variety of pasta have been highlighted as star performers. It's not just the food but also the warm ambience and friendly staff that regularly earn Martini Modern Italian five-star reviews. The establishment is also lauded for its accommodating nature, demonstrated by the preparation of a special off-menu vegan ravioli. For those in search of authentic and quality Italian cuisine, Martini Modern Italian is the go-to place.

5. Pelino’s Pasta

4.7

Exceptional(983)

Price: Very Expensive

• Italian • Columbus

Booked 23 times today

Pelino's Pasta is a gem in Columbus, renowned for its authentic Italian cuisine. Numerous patrons vouch for its impeccable and friendly service, praising the staff's invaluable knowledge about the food and wine. Many guests describe the dishes as "amazing," "fresh," and "flavorful," with specialties like Cacio di Pepe and gluten-free pasta, which are highly recommended. The restaurant also takes care in catering to dietary needs, offering house-made gluten-free pasta. The experience is further enhanced with table side dressing and an array of fine Italian wines. While the prices are higher than average, the high quality of the food and an extraordinary dining experience make it worth every penny.

A photo of The Wine Bistro - Upper Arlington restaurant

6. The Wine Bistro - Upper Arlington

4.7

Exceptional(1148)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Upper Arlington

Booked 12 times today

The Wine Bistro - Upper Arlington is a standout gem in the realm of Contemporary American cuisine. The amazing dining experiences, as echoed by multiple reviewers, are marked by a warm, welcoming ambience, professional staff, and an array of interesting dishes that cater to diverse taste preferences. The restaurant's unique offerings include the delectable chicken Pesto flat bread, fresh and perfectly cooked salmon, the Brie and Pear Flatbread, and the unforgettable maple bourbon bread pudding. The establishment also stands as a top-notch wine selection spot, where professionals guide customers through diverse, global wine options. With its cozy wine bar setting and comfortable outdoor patio, The Wine Bistro is a favorite for many, highly recommended for its excellent food, service, and wine.

A photo of Nicola Restaurant and Bar - Columbus restaurant

7. Nicola Restaurant and Bar - Columbus

4.8

Exceptional(1730)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Upper Arlington

Booked 10 times today

Nicola Restaurant and Bar in Columbus has gathered a devoted following, with many patrons stating it as their favorite Italian eatery in Central Ohio. The restaurant is cherished for its well-executed dishes, with diners praising the flavorful seafood, bolognese sauce over gnocchi, and renowned lemon cake. Various reviews laud the authenticity of the food, describing meals as "always delicious" and "consistently exceptional." The staff is also mentioned favorably, characterized as attentive and professional, adding to the overall excellent service. Other highlights include their willingness to engage in Italian conversation and prioritization of the quality of their food. According to their clientele, Nicola Restaurant and Bar does more than just serve good food; they provide an exquisite Italian dining experience.

8. Lupo on Arlington

4.8

Exceptional(242)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Upper Arlington

Booked 20 times today

Lupo on Arlington is a highly-rated Mediterranean restaurant situated in Columbus, offering a delightful dining experience that diners consistently appreciate. The restaurant is renowned for its artfully prepared tapas, fresh seafood, and versatile dishes that reflect the season's produce. Among the standout menu items are the Korean Halibut, Serrano ham, and a silky gazpacho, as noted in the extensive positive reviews. Lupo's innovative approach towards the cuisine is frequently highlighted in the reviews, with one diner stating it possesses "one of the most creative and innovative chefs in Columbus". The restaurant has been listed among Columbus's top restaurants and celebrated for its excellent service, innovative cocktails and revolving menu.

A photo of The Rossi Kitchen & Bar restaurant

9. The Rossi Kitchen & Bar

4.7

Exceptional(356)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Short North - Arena District

Booked 18 times today

The Rossi Kitchen & Bar is a highly-acclaimed American cuisine spot known for its outstanding food and service. Customer testimonials frequently highlight the quality and authenticity of their dishes, from the "hands down best pizza" to the "steak tips and pasta Rossi". The unique concoctions like a honey-topped pepperoni pizza and the "death by chocolate" martinis are particularly celebrated. The ambiance and service are repeatedly praised, with patrons noting the "personable wait staff and management" and the restaurant's ability to create an "easy call for a fun night out." The Rossi's menu, despite being small, is appreciated for its specific focus on quality, promising a satisfying visit every time.

10. Gallo's Kitchen

4.8

Exceptional(1094)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Upper Arlington

Booked 24 times today

Gallo's Kitchen & Bar features Creole and Italian cuisine. The restaurant's atmosphere is comfortable and friendly, providing a casual yet memorable dining experience. Head Chef, Tommy Gallo's culinary linage has ties to some of the best chefs of New Orleans. Offering a menu comprising of entrées, appetizers, sandwiches, soup and salads, providing fresh and flavorsome meals.Popular dishes include Seafood Creole, The Daily Sautéed Fish, Ohio Proud Filet Mignon, Gumbo with rice, Chicken Etouffee, Pasta Russo Bolognese, Gallo's House Marinara, and Gallo's. The Daily Specials consists of creations by the restaurant's chefs. It's based on fresh fish, seasonal produce and local beef to provide customers with a unique dining experience. Gallo's Kitchen also has a bar area known for an expansive wine list, featuring 24 glass pours and over 30 additional bottle listings. The bar also in known for craft cocktails and premium draft and bottled beers.

‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

Explore OpenTable

Clintonville

Italian