Best Italian Restaurants in Bahamas

Price: Moderate (10)Price: Expensive (16)Price: Very Expensive (9)

4 restaurants available nearby

A photo of Carmine's- Atlantis Paradise Island restaurant

1. Carmine's- Atlantis Paradise Island

4.3

Awesome(2110)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Bahamas

Booked 94 times today

Carmine's, located in Atlantis Paradise Island, is highly praised for its authentic Italian cuisine. Numerous reviews commend the sizeable portions prepared in family style, underscoring the value for money given the sheer quantity and quality of the food. A wide array of dishes served, from spaghetti and meatballs, chicken scaloppine to lasagna, demonstrate the varied selection available. In particular, the Caesar salad, lasagna, and porterhouse steak come highly recommended. The ambiance is repeatedly praised as great, lending the restaurant a relaxed, fun atmosphere. In sum, Carmine's offers an authentic, generously-portioned Italian dining experience with excellent service.

A photo of Paranza-Atlantis Paradise Island restaurant

2. Paranza-Atlantis Paradise Island

4.6

Exceptional(356)

Price: Very Expensive

• Italian • Bahamas

Booked 62 times today

Paranza is a renowned Italian restaurant that has earned high praise from patrons for its outstanding cuisine and exceptional service. Reviewers consistently mention the excellent quality of dishes served at Paranza, heavily influenced by a Michelin-star chef. Favorites include the Tortelli, Risotto, beef tartare, lobster risotto, and the unforgettable chocolate torte. The restaurant's service is frequently lauded, with staff members Kingsley, Felicia, and Gladston receiving particular praise for their attentiveness and knowledge. Notably, Paranza's menu caters to dietary needs, including gluten and nut allergies. According to the reviews, the dining experience at Paranza is enhanced by its stylish and relaxing ambiance, making it a must-visit when staying at Atlantis.

A photo of Graycliff Restaurant - Graycliff Hotel restaurant

3. Graycliff Restaurant - Graycliff Hotel

4.7

Exceptional(1002)

Price: Very Expensive

• Italian • Bahamas

Booked 18 times today

Located in the enchanting Graycliff Hotel in Nassau, Bahamas, Graycliff Restaurant is an acclaimed destination for exceptional Continental cuisine. The restaurant stands out due to its traditional Bahamian-inspired fine dining approach that uniquely blends local and offshore flavors. Seafood dishes, particularly the conch chowder, are among the favorites of many diners. Guests often laud the service which adheres to a high, classical standard, and the ambiance which combines sophistication with a distinctive Bahamian overlay. Many reviews describe dining at the Graycliff as more than a meal but an exceptional experience, speaking highly of their attentive staff, the quality of their food, and the overall atmosphere. The wine list is a focal point, and the tasting experience is enhanced by the extensive knowledge of their sommelier. This exceptional culinary experience, paired with a rich history, makes Graycliff Restaurant a unique and highly recommended venue for Continental cuisine.

A photo of Fi'lia at Baha Mar restaurant

4. Fi'lia at Baha Mar

4.2

Awesome(701)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Bahamas

Fi'lia at Baha Mar shines as a beacon of Italian cuisine par excellence, delighting patrons with its varied menu and superlative service. The restaurant's culinary offerings garner high praises for their freshness, flavor, and substantial portions. Notable mentions from satisfied diners include Caprese salad, Carpaccio, Gnocchi Cache Pepe, and Rigatoni Bolognese, all authentic Italian dishes. The service is speedy due to efficient teamwork, with a second team of waiters assisting the primary waiter. The ambiance is equally lauded, described as elegant, vibrant, and energetic. With a culinary experience that's left Italian patrons spellbound, Fi'lia at Baha Mar deserves a toast for its mastery of Italian cuisine.

Explore OpenTable

Bahamas

Italian