Best Italian Restaurants in Amherst

Price: Moderate (20)Price: Expensive (7)Price: Very Expensive (4)

8 restaurants available nearby

A photo of Rizotto Ristorante restaurant

1. Rizotto Ristorante

4.2

Awesome(570)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Buffalo

Booked 4 times today

Rizotto Ristorante is an acclaimed destination for authentic Italian cuisine. Reviewers have consistently praised its "amazing" food, characterized by homemade and classic Italian recipes. The exceptional service, relaxed atmosphere, its value for money and special attention to clients during special occasions, including anniversary and graduation celebrations, have been recurrent appreciation points among satisfied customers. One reviewer even dubbed it as "one of the most Italian-like restaurants in the US." Whether dining on Valentine's Day or on a casual weekend, guests have found Rizotto Ristorante to always deliver a delightful experience. Patrons look forward to returning, highlighting the restaurant's effective recipe for customer loyalty.

2. Giancarlo's

4.8

Exceptional(3406)

Price: Very Expensive

• Italian • Buffalo

Booked 72 times today

Giancarlo's is praised as an exceptional steakhouse, standing out for its perfectly cooked steaks and upscale ambiance. Reviewers laud it as an ideal spot for date nights and special occasions due to its impeccable service and delightful atmosphere. The "6oz filet" and "12oz strip steak" are highly recommended, with customers appreciating its "superb seafood" and exciting menu that provides "many options from small plates to full entrees." This Sicilian steakhouse, described as "the best in the Buffalo area", is also commended for its pizzas and excellent wine list. Despite higher prices, patrons find the food and overall experience at Giancarlo's to be worth it, promising to return for more.

A photo of Trattoria Aroma - Williamsville restaurant

3. Trattoria Aroma - Williamsville

4.5

Awesome(638)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Williamsville

Located in Buffalo, Trattoria Aroma - Williamsville has been consistently praised for its authentic Italian cuisine. With over 15 years of service, owners Reno and Roma are praised for their dedication to maintaining high-quality Italian cuisine, accompanied by an excellent selection of wines. The restaurant’s charm lies in its ability to transport guests to little Italy, with one patron comparing the experience to being in NYC. The ambience of the restaurant is frequently described as comfortable and pleasant, with impeccable service. Additionally, the eatery boasts a menu that never disappoints, featuring creative specials, brick oven pizzas, traditional food, and pasta meals. Trattoria Aroma’s blend of exceptional food, friendly service, and Italian authenticity have left an impression on its guests, many of whom are eager for a revisit.

A photo of Cugino's Italian Restaurant restaurant

4. Cugino's Italian Restaurant

3.4

Very Good(317)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Williamsville

Cugino's Italian Restaurant is renowned for its high-quality Italian cuisine nestled in the heart of Williamsville. Patrons vouch for its impeccable service and charming ambiance. The restaurant, run by the owner-chef Franco, stands out for its exceptional attention to detail and unique offerings like pork osso buco. Cugino's has consistently impressed diners with its homemade pasta and superb dishes. Notably, the owner interacts with customers to ensure guest satisfaction, and the friendly staff are commended for their responsiveness. Customers' experiences at Cugino's have been largely positive, with many recommending the restaurant and eager to revisit, affirming that it's well worth the cost.

A photo of Italian Prime at Salvatore's restaurant

5. Italian Prime at Salvatore's

4.4

Awesome(4233)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Cheektowaga

Booked 2 times today

Established in 1967, ITALIAN | PRIME at Salvatore's is recognized as one of Western New York's premier full-service fine dining restaurant. The chefs have created an inspired menu with Steaks, Seafood and Italian Cuisine. Awards include the DiRONA and the Wine Spectator Award of Excellence — Two Cups. Our team of Chefs are continually updating the menu and services with creative offerings and is now noted as Buffalo's only Italian Steakhouse.The Chandelier Bar, at Salvatore's, has become a destination on its own. The Salvatores have created a relaxing contemporary space for a casual meal, happy hours, weekday specials and live music.Salvatore's Hospitality, also offers two boutique hotels. The Garden Place Hotel and The Delavan Hotel and Spa offer hotel, Spa and dinner packages, perfect for a quick getaway, and out of town guests. Buffalo Niagara International Airport shuttle service is complimentary with your hotel rese

A photo of Rizzo's on Transit restaurant

6. Rizzo's on Transit

3.5

Very Good(624)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Buffalo

Booked 1 time today

Schnitzel and Co has now switched over to Rizzo's on Transit Rd.

7. Oggi Bistro

3.9

Excellent(14)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Fort Erie

new sports bar menu available in bar areawith many options under $30

A photo of Blue Cave Italian Restaurant restaurant

8. Blue Cave Italian Restaurant

4.6

Exceptional(186)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Buffalo

Booked 8 times today

Blue Cave Italian Restaurant provides an outstanding contemporary Italian dining experience. Many of its customers give high praise for the extraordinary service and food, as indicated by multiple reviews. The first-timers are impressed with the patience and helpfulness of the servers, while the regulars keep returning for the top-notch food. They mention items from salads to saffron risotto, and octopus appetizers to branzino entrees, all acclaimed as excellent. Many diners label the dining experience as 'authentic southern Italian' and 'an excellent Italian experience.' There are glowing endorsements about the generosity of the portions and the perfection of preparation. The unique menu, remarkable dishes, and exceptional service make Blue Cave an absolute gem in Buffalo.

‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

Explore OpenTable

Amherst

Italian