Best Contemporary American Restaurants in Gates Mills

An all around wonderful experience. Service, food, ambiance all great! Ehab was extraordinary!

Lively yet cozy atmosphere, had a good experience the second we walked in the door! The hummus appetizer was delicious and all of us enjoyed our entrees. The drinks were great too!

We booked a reservation for 5:00 and actually got a table by the windows with a beautiful view of the falls. Our server Andrew was attentive and checked on us regularly. Overall food was delicious. One’ll minor issue was the lobster bisque wasn’t hot and my husband sent it back, but kitchen corrected it without issue.

The service was excellent! The hostess sat us at a table with a decent view. When the server came over she asked us if we wanted the corner table where we could see entire lake and downtown skyline. It was in the afternoon so it wasnt packed but it was thoughtful of her to move tables for us!

We had 4 different, delicious meals today. Our server, Bianca, was outstanding. She was knowledgeable about the menu and kept our drinks fresh. She was also able to converse with 4 older patrons and was just a breath of fresh air. This is the second time I’ve eaten at OddFellows and plan to go again! The salmon was cooked perfectly, the aioli and potatoes were amazing! My meal mates enjoyed Tai beef, steak and shrimp pasta. We all were very pleased. Making reservations was easy as well.