Best American Restaurants in Puyallup

Price: Moderate (23)Price: Expensive (6)Price: Very Expensive (2)

20 restaurants available nearby

A photo of Black Angus Steakhouse - Puyallup restaurant

1. Black Angus Steakhouse - Puyallup

4.7

Exceptional(2435)

Price: Moderate

• American • Puyallup

Booked 17 times today

Located in Puyallup, Washington, Black Angus Steakhouse is applauded for providing a stellar steakhouse experience. Praised for its all-natural beef, patrons rave about the tender steak and prime rib that are meticulously cooked to order. According to a happy customer, the "wonderful" steak was a delightful surprise after a 17-year hiatus from eating beef. Excellent service and the accuracy and quality of the food contribute as well to the high-end dining experience. Customers particularly appreciate the variety, including the surf & turf that is a 'go-to' choice for many. Consistently lauded as the best steakhouse in the area, Black Angus Steakhouse is a true delight for steak lovers.

A photo of The Windmill Bistro restaurant

2. The Windmill Bistro

4.7

Exceptional(658)

Price: Moderate

• American • Sumner

Booked 24 times today

The Windmill Bistro, located in Sumner, is a splendid destination for authentic American cuisine. Customers highlight its "great ambiance", "excellent service", and most importantly "delicious food". Moreover, it's praised for its well-coordinated staff who work as a team, ensuring a smooth dining experience for their patrons. Customers particularly recommend the restaurant for multiple occasions such as dates, girls' nights, or family breakfasts and emphasize on making a reservation due to its popularity. From the reviews, it's also evident that the Windmill Bistro has an impressive selection of cocktails and wines, adding to its appeal as a great eatery.

A photo of Mama Stortini's - Puyallup restaurant

3. Mama Stortini's - Puyallup

4.6

Exceptional(1089)

Price: Moderate

• American • Puyallup

Booked 10 times today

Mama Stortini's in Puyallup is a haven of superb American cuisine that consistently delights its patrons. As indicated by numerous reviews, both the food and service have elicited high praise, resulting in an excellent dining experience. Customers have lauded the restaurant's caring approach to catering for individuals with food allergies, noting the staff's knowledge and attentiveness. The establishment's ability to handle large parties and special events, maintaining high standards in food and service, is another highlight. The unique and delicious food, ranging from amazing Italian dishes to the best spumoni ice cream around, further underscores its quality. With great reviews and high customer satisfaction, Mama Stortini's stands out as a pinnacle of American cuisine.

A photo of BJ's Restaurant & Brewhouse - Puyallup restaurant

4. BJ's Restaurant & Brewhouse - Puyallup

4.2

Awesome(68)

Price: Moderate

• American • Puyallup

Booked 1 time today

BJ's Restaurant & Brewhouse in Puyallup is a renowned spot for excellent American cuisine. The restaurant prides itself on its top-notch service as quoted from a multitude of guest reviews, with one satisfied customer noting that the server Lucas provides unparalleled customer service. The quality and consistency of their delicious meals are repeatedly praised with words such as "awesome food" and "great food." The rapidity of their service even at 50% capacity surprised some customers, embodying their dedication to providing the best dining experience. The restaurant's commitment to safety measures during the Covid-19 era is also lauded. It's no wonder BJ's has become many families' favorite and a "go-to" spot for business lunches and meals with friends.

A photo of Stanley & Seafort's restaurant

5. Stanley & Seafort's

4.3

Awesome(5927)

Price: Moderate

• American • Tacoma

Booked 31 times today

Stanley & Seafort's is a highly recommended seafood restaurant, celebrated for its excellent cuisine and stunning views. The mouthwatering seafood dishes, such as the Seafood Trio, Seafood Louie Salad, and Crab Stuffed Prawns, have been praised by diners, with one guest calling the clam chowder the best they've ever tasted. The restaurant's renowned Prime Rib is also said to be simply unbeatable. In addition to the exquisite food, patrons also appreciate the thoughtful service, celebrating special occasions from birthdays to anniversaries and leaving them with a memorable experience. Stanley & Seafort's is highly recommended for a special date night or to impress friends visiting from out of town. It's a beloved institution in Tacoma, known for its fantastic food, professional service, and classic ambiance.

A photo of McMenamins Elks Temple restaurant

6. McMenamins Elks Temple

4.5

Awesome(1733)

Price: Moderate

• American • Tacoma

Booked 14 times today

McMenamins Elks Temple, located in Tacoma, is highly praised for its quality American cuisine. Patrons rave about the "delicious food" and "great drink recommendations". The elk expedition burger, steak salad, Reuben sandwich and fish and chips are particularly recommended. The food is described as "gourmet" and "full of flavor", while the consistency in quality and service enhances the appeal. Diners also appreciate the restaurant's "fun ambiance", complimenting the "romantic and comfortable" lighting, as well as the stunning views of the water. Anticipating a delightful dining experience, patrons eagerly proclaim, "I'll be back again for sure". McMenamins Elks Temple is truly a gem in Tacoma's culinary scene.

A photo of Over The Moon Cafe restaurant

7. Over The Moon Cafe

4.9

Exceptional(2525)

Price: Expensive

• American • Tacoma

Booked 7 times today

"Over The Moon Cafe" is frequently lauded for its exceptional American cuisine, boasting a thoughtful menu filled with innovative meals that have been crafted with devotion and passion. With selections like Lobster Mac & Cheese, Duck Breast with Port Reduction Sauce, and House Made Bourbon Vanilla Ice Cream, the quality and flavor of the dishes speak for themselves. Reviews frequently commend the restaurant's excellent service, romantic ambiance, and dedication to using fresh, local ingredients. Additionally, the cafe has even been selected three times as one of the top one hundred most romantic restaurants in America, which clearly showcases its relevance to the American dining scene.

A photo of Slahal Restaurant and Bar restaurant

8. Slahal Restaurant and Bar

4.1

Excellent(260)

Price: Expensive

• American • Tacoma

Booked 6 times today

Slahal Restaurant and Bar consistently delivers high-quality Steakhouse cuisine, securing a stellar reputation among its clientele. Evidence of their culinary acumen shines through in reviews, with diners raving about the perfectly cooked Ribeye Steak and impressive seafood offerings. Furthermore, the restaurant's service is mentioned repeatedly in glowing terms, particularly the knowledgeable and attentive staff, such as Tristan and Sam. Although it's noted as not inexpensive, diners assure it's worth every penny. The restaurant's beautiful view and relaxing atmosphere form the icing on the cake, creating an overall dining experience that exceeds expectations. Regarded as one of the best restaurants by many, Slahal Restaurant and Bar is a must-visit for Steakhouse cuisine enthusiasts.

9. Puyalapabs Café

4.4

Awesome(125)

Price: Moderate

• American • Tacoma

Booked 1 time today

Puyalapabs Café offers a fantastic American dining experience, highly recommended by its patrons. Reviews frequently praise its delicious food, especially stand-out dishes like bacon-wrapped stuffed prawns and perfectly-cooked salmon. It's not just the food that gets compliments; customers appreciate the attentive, high-quality service, describing it as on par with fine dining. The café's ability to handle busy nights efficiently, provide an engaging atmosphere, and deliver personalized customer service - such as the case where a manager stepped in to serve guests - are greatly admired. Celebrations at Puyalapabs Café are made special with thoughtful touches like surprise chocolate birthday cakes. The restaurant's commitment to providing an outstanding experience makes it a must-visit destination for lovers of American cuisine.

A photo of Italian Supper Club at Stadium Golf restaurant

10. Italian Supper Club at Stadium Golf

5.0

Exceptional(1)

Price: Moderate

• American • Tacoma

Booked 2 times today

Gather ‘round with friends and family at Stadium Golf’s brand new dinner experience. Nestled in the heart of Stadium District, our Italian Supper Club is moving in for the summer featuring Chicago tavern-style pizza, lasagna, pasta, and meatballs so good you’ll forget your mama’s. But don’t take our word for it…come by and try our new menu for yourself before it’s gone! Available after 5:00pm Wednesday–Sunday. Serving cocktail classics like espresso martinis, spritz, and negronis alongside beer and wine. With our state-of-the-art Trackman golf simulator bays, two pool tables, and arcade games, we're all about having fun with friends! Bring the kids—all ages are welcome.

How is content generated

Discover best American restaurants in Puyallup

Discover the rich tapestry of American cuisine across Seattle, Eastern Washington, Puyallup, and Tacoma. These areas are renowned for offering an array of dining experiences that cater to every palate, showcasing the diversity and innovation of American culinary traditions. Whether you're in the mood for a classic steakhouse, contemporary American dishes, or specialties that blend American influences with international flavors, there's a restaurant to satisfy your cravings. The dining scene here is vibrant and dynamic, characterized by a commitment to quality and authenticity, ensuring every meal is not just eaten but experienced. Visitors and locals alike praise the attentive service, the comfortable and inviting atmospheres, and the high-quality ingredients that make each dish memorable. Ideal for food enthusiasts and casual diners, these restaurants provide a gastronomic journey through American cuisine, making each location a must-visit destination for anyone seeking culinary delights in the Pacific Northwest.

Explore OpenTable

Puyallup

American