Best American Restaurants in Nutley

Brenda our waitress was excellent Restaurant noisy could use some sound baffles My wife’s short ribs were salty understand they are cooking all day which lead to this Jon

Pretty standard pub food which is what made it amazing.

Food and service was good family friendly great atmosphere

The brookdale is the best. Come here at least once a week. Food is amazing, service also amazing. Can’t beat it

Great food and menu. My signature cocktail very yummy, my husband’s standard one showed up without a straw or garnish. Appetizer wings cooked to perfection and the pizza was terrific! Waitress was very helpful as first time patrons and attentive. Cool atmosphere but WAY TOO LOUD and hated the...See More

Nice lunch spot with great service. Pizza was delicious.

Service was friendly and prompt. Crab cakes were a bit disappointing, more breading than I anticipated. Everything else was amazing.

Staff was friendly and attentive. Delmonico steak was phenomenal. We will be back for more.

Great restaurant, nice atmosphere. Wait staff was very pleasant and accomodating. Would definitely go there again.

Great food, great service and nice outdoor area. Extensive beer selection which was awesome.