Best American Restaurants in Lancaster

Price: Moderate (12)Price: Expensive (11)Price: Very Expensive (2)

18 restaurants available nearby

1. The Exchange

4.5

Awesome(912)

Price: Moderate

• American • Lancaster

Booked 41 times today

The Exchange, providing an exceptional dining experience with stunning views of Lancaster City, is recognized for its exceptional American cuisine. Patrons rave about the diverse menu, particularly praising dishes like the Mexican Corn Pizza and Korean Chicken Tenders. One reviewer recommended trying the Braised Short Rib Crunchwrap, emphasizing its memorable taste. They've also complimented the quality of the drinks available. Many have emphasized the enchanting environment and stunning views, which further enhances the dining experience. The Exchange has successfully delivered an appealing combination of culinary excellence, genuine service, and a great ambience, winning the hearts of its customers, and establishing itself as a hallmark of American cuisine.

A photo of Belvedere Inn Restaurant and Bar restaurant

2. Belvedere Inn Restaurant and Bar

4.8

Exceptional(3849)

Price: Expensive

• American • Lancaster

Booked 33 times today

Belvedere Inn Restaurant and Bar is highly praised for its superb American cuisine. Based on the reviews, it offers a fantastic dining experience with its exceptional food, excellent service, and inviting ambiance. Customers repeatedly mention enjoying meals on the beautiful patio, indicating a pleasant setting that enhances the dining experience. Continuous praises for their steak, salmon, and particularly the uniquely flavored Asian salad, are testament to the culinary mastery at Belvedere. The restaurant is also appreciated for accommodating special occasions, such as wedding anniversaries, making it a favored choice in Lancaster. The food is often described as delicious, well-prepared, and outstanding, further cementing Belvedere's place as a gem of American cuisine.

3. 401 Prime

4.7

Exceptional(619)

Price: Very Expensive

• American • Lancaster

Booked 19 times today

401 Prime, located in Lancaster, is a high-end steakhouse that has garnered rave reviews. Known for its exceptional service, expertly prepared steaks, fresh oysters, and creative salads, 401 Prime ensures a topnotch dining experience. The restaurant stands out for its beautiful ambiance—one of the best in Lancaster—providing a royal treatment to all its guests. Reviewers have lauded the knowledge of the staff, highlighting their eagerness for continuous improvement. The steaks earned high praise, with one 75-year-old customer noting that they served the best filets he had ever had. Besides steak, they serve desserts that are not to be missed, their loaded bake potato and shaved Brussels sprouts are appreciated. In addition to the fantastic service and menu, the elegant space and attention to detail add to the overall dining pleasure at 401 Prime. The restaurant is also highly recommended for special occasions.

4. Josephine's

4.9

Exceptional(1300)

Price: Expensive

• American • Lancaster

Booked 14 times today

Josephine's restaurant, located in the heart of Lancaster, is a hidden gem offering superb French cuisine. Patrons have hailed the delightful overall experience and unique ambience, reminiscent of the golden age of Hollywood. According to reviews, the food, service, and even the clean bathrooms stand out as exceptional. High praise is consistently given to the lavish French dishes and cocktails. Customers have raved about everything from the filet and crab cakes to the mussels and pan-seared scallops. The offerings from the French pastry chef were deemed "delectable" leading to the conclusion that Josephine's is the perfect venue for unforgettable meals and celebrations.

A photo of Altana Rooftop Lounge restaurant

5. Altana Rooftop Lounge

4.7

Exceptional(667)

Price: Expensive

• American • Lancaster

Booked 7 times today

Altana Rooftop Lounge is a shining star of American cuisine. The dining experience is elevated, quite literally, by their rooftop seating, which is praised for its fantastic views and ambient atmosphere. Their service is often lauded as excellent, attentive and helpful. The culinary delights include the standout Iberico Pork Tenderloin, shrimp cocktail, and unique Altana burgers. The restaurant also offers an impressive drink selection, with patrons recommending the Bourbon Bramble. While there is an unfortunate comment about a couple of their desserts, the overwhelming consensus is that Altana provides a great dining experience with delicious food, from the appetizers to the main courses.

6. Plough

4.2

Awesome(954)

Price: Moderate

• American • Lancaster

Booked 8 times today

Plough is highly revered for its superior American cuisine, known for its exceptional service and tasty food. Critics and patrons alike praise the restaurant's ability to craft delicious meals with a unique twist. Many of its dishes display a perfect balance of spices, like the Moroccan carrots and the perfectly cooked flank steak, and the freshness of the ingredients is frequently noted. Not only does Plough offer excellent entrees, but even its simple regular coffee is noted to be fantastic. The exceptional service extends to the ability to flexibly address customers' needs, as the staff readily accommodates late arrivals or young diners wishing for dessert first. Whether it's an intimate dinner or a special celebration, Plough's fresh, farm-to-table offerings, and engaging atmosphere consistently exceed expectations.

7. Yorgos Lancaster

4.8

Exceptional(283)

Price: Moderate

• American • Lancaster

Booked 3 times today

Located in Lancaster, Yorgos Restaurant has carved a niche for itself among the locals and tourists alike for its authentic and delectable Greek cuisine. The reviews point to the taverna-like atmosphere and delightful Greek menu options. Diners commend the excellent service, despite a bustling crowd. The Branzino and Lamb chops are celebrated fare, cooked to perfection, while the spanakopita is deemed unmatched. Patrons relish dining on the terrace, enjoying a beautiful ambience and live music. A common sentiment echoed by visitors is feeling as though they are eating cooking from a Greek grandmother, indicating the authenticity and quality of the cuisine. Yorgos Lancaster is a must-visit for Greek food enthusiasts.

A photo of Iron Hill Brewery - Lancaster restaurant

8. Iron Hill Brewery - Lancaster

4.3

Awesome(3294)

Price: Moderate

• American • Lancaster

Booked 24 times today

Iron Hill Brewery in Lancaster is hailed for its excellent American cuisine. The restaurant garners high praise for its variety of dishes and emphasis on quality. Reviews speak volumes about the delicious offerings, from the Moroccan salmon to the pecan crusted salmon, and the unique Tuna Takati. Their rib eye steak has also been particularly commended. Iron Hill Brewery also offers a specialized Oktoberfest menu that adds a German twist to their offerings. The accommodating service alongside the great food creates an ideal dining experience, with many customers consistently returning, confirming the restaurant's consistent quality and warm hospitality.

A photo of Cork & Cap Restaurant restaurant

9. Cork & Cap Restaurant

4.7

Exceptional(1439)

Price: Expensive

• American • Lancaster

Booked 11 times today

Cork & Cap Restaurant, located in Lancaster, has been lauded by patrons for its exceptional American cuisine. Loved for both its atmosphere and food, reviews highlight dishes such as the perfectly prepared braised veal with risotto, the sensational crab cakes, and the succulent roasted duck. Customers also rave about the innovative menu and the freshness of the ingredients used. The restaurant's lobster bisque is commended for its flavor and the generous lumps of lobster meat it contains. With multiple reviewers expressing their eagerness to revisit, Cork & Cap Restaurant is clearly a standout choice for top-notch American fare in Lancaster.

A photo of Gibraltar Lancaster restaurant

10. Gibraltar Lancaster

4.9

Exceptional(2253)

Price: Expensive

• American • Lancaster

Booked 20 times today

Gibraltar Lancaster is widely recognized as one of the best seafood restaurants in the area, with reviews affirming the excellent quality of its seafood dishes, particularly the fresh halibut specials and seafood sampler tower. The lobster fettuccine and almond crusted halibut also come highly recommended, demonstrating the creative culinary skills of their chefs. Patrons not only commend their top-notch food but also the attentive service, solid wine selection, and exceptional ambiance. Regardless if you're a local or living 40 minutes away, the consensus seems to be that the dining experience at Gibraltar Lancaster is well worth the trip.

How is content generated

Discover best American restaurants in Lancaster

Discover the vibrant American dining scene in Lancaster, Pennsylvania, where a variety of restaurants cater to every taste and preference. Whether you're in the mood for traditional Pennsylvania Dutch specialties or contemporary American dishes, Lancaster County offers an impressive array of options. Each restaurant in the area prides itself on utilizing fresh, locally-sourced ingredients, ensuring a meal that's not only delicious but also embodies the essence of the region. The dining experience in Lancaster is enhanced by unique settings ranging from historic farmhouses and rooftop lounges to steamboats and elegant dining rooms, providing not just a meal, but a memorable occasion. Patrons consistently praise the high-quality service, the welcoming atmospheres, and the culinary creativity that define Lancaster’s American cuisine establishments. These restaurants stand out not only for their exceptional food but also for their commitment to providing a satisfying dining experience. With each location striving to offer both a delightful menu and a welcoming environment, Lancaster's American dining scene truly caters to a diverse palette. Whether you're a local or a visitor, exploring Lancaster's American cuisine offerings is sure to leave a lasting impression with its rich flavors and hospitable service.

Explore OpenTable

Lancaster

American