Best American Restaurants in Lake Mary

Price: Moderate (22)Price: Expensive (9)Price: Very Expensive (3)

13 restaurants available nearby

A photo of Stonewood Grill & Tavern - Heathrow restaurant

1. Stonewood Grill & Tavern - Heathrow

4.7

Exceptional(1773)

Price: Moderate

• American • Heathrow

Booked 28 times today

Stonewood Grill & Tavern - Heathrow is a gem of American cuisine. Customers are always praising the restaurant for its delicious food, with special mentions of the tuna steak, delicious hot salmon, seafood trio special, and steaks cooked to perfection. The dining experience is further enhanced by the exceptional service, with staff reportedly going out of their way to ensure customers are satisfied. In particular, Erica is consistently praised for her outstanding service. Numerous reviews highlight the restaurant's warm and pleasant atmosphere, making it a favorite spot for many. The compliments extend to the establishment's beverages and desserts; the Florida Orange Cake appears to be a divine treat. Stonewood Grill & Tavern - Heathrow not only fulfills, but surpasses the expectations of its customers, making it a standout in American dining.

A photo of F&D Prime Modern Steakhouse restaurant

2. F&D Prime Modern Steakhouse

4.7

Exceptional(272)

Price: Very Expensive

• American • Heathrow

Booked 30 times today

F&D Prime Modern Steakhouse has earned rave reviews for its excellent American cuisine. Diners consistently applaud the restaurant for its fresh, delicious offerings, and variety of options, including unlimited small plates and the "magical dining" menu. The quality of the food is emphasized, with comments such as "You can taste the freshness and quality in each bite" and “The absolute best fish I've ever had!". The steakhouse is also lauded for its exemplary service, with one reviewer highlighting how the chef even made an appearance to speak with customers. Given these glowing endorsements, F&D Prime Modern Steakhouse is undoubtedly a standout choice for remarkable American cuisine.

3. Lake Mary Social

4.3

Awesome(420)

Price: Expensive

• American • Lake Mary

Booked 15 times today

Lake Mary Social, a unique culinary gem located in Lake Mary, delivers an outstanding contemporary American dining experience that leaves patrons in awe. Described as a "speakeasy-like establishment," the restaurant offers an exquisite selection of dishes, including fan favorites like sea bass and chicken marsala, showcasing the chef's extraordinary mastery of modern American cuisine. The restaurant's impeccable service, enchanting ambiance, and tasteful decor attract rave reviews. The tastefully arranged plates are nothing short of art, with the restaurant's unyielding attention to detail ensuring the highest culinary excellence. Whether it's the delectable food, the attentive staff, the sophisticated yet comfortable ambiance, or the beautifully crafted drinks, Lake Mary Social never fails to impress, delivering an unforgettable dining experience.

A photo of 347 Grille by Coach Shula - The Westin Lake Mary restaurant

4. 347 Grille by Coach Shula - The Westin Lake Mary

4.3

Awesome(1400)

Price: Moderate

• American • Lake Mary

Booked 4 times today

The 347 Grille by Coach Shula - The Westin Lake Mary is an epitome of excellent American cuisine, as vouched by the reviews. Diners commend the restaurant for a variety of spectacular dishes like the filet mignon steak, almond-crusted, wild-caught halibut, crab cake appetizer, French Onion Burger, and salmon, to name a few. Reviewers also lauded their exceptional service, with waiters such as Isaiah, Brian, and Ritchie providing a warm and welcoming environment. The restaurant's Mother’s Day brunch, featuring prime rib, roasted duck, and salmon, is beloved by many. Repeat visitors attest to the consistent quality of food and service, making 347 Grille an excellent choice for both casual and special occasions.

A photo of 1501 Kitchen & Bar restaurant

5. 1501 Kitchen & Bar

4.3

Awesome(31)

Price: Moderate

• American • Lake Mary

1501 Kitchen & Bar - Modern American cuisine, a variety of gluten-free and vegetarian options, with an incredible happy hour located inside the recently renovated Marriott Orlando Lake Mary.1501 International ParkwayLake Mary, Fl. 32746

A photo of Uno Mas Mexican Cantina - Longwood restaurant

6. Uno Mas Mexican Cantina - Longwood

3.5

Very Good(3)

Price: Moderate

• American • Longwood

Booked 1 time today

Welcome to Uno Mas Mexican Cantina, where vibrant flavors and a diverse menu come together to create a unique dining experience. Indulge in your favorite Mexican dishes, savor our delicious woodfired pizzas, and enjoy our mouth-watering burgers. Complement your meal with our handcrafted margaritas and extensive selection of tequilas. Whether you're here for a family dinner, a night out with friends, or just to enjoy some great food and drinks, Uno Mas Mexican Cantina is the perfect spot for every occasion. Join us and taste the difference!

A photo of Seasons 52 - Altamonte Springs restaurant

7. Seasons 52 - Altamonte Springs

4.8

Exceptional(6355)

Price: Expensive

• American • Altamonte Springs

Booked 88 times today

Seasons 52 - Altamonte Springs is a splendid representative of American cuisine, celebrated widely for its delightful food and superior service. Customers have applauded their experience at the restaurant, appreciating the pleasant ambiance, remarkable meals, and commendable cleanliness of the establishment. It has particularly earned praise for its Magical Dining experience, offering a variety of flavorsome dishes that leaves customers yearning for more. Customers have lauded the Sea Bass and filet mignon, with the Cedar plank salmon also frequently highlighted. The restaurant has demonstrated great adaptability to dietary restrictions, ensuring every visit takes customers 'back to normal living.' All visitors unequivocally recommend the restaurant for its impressive food, service, and setting.

A photo of Permanent Vacation restaurant

8. Permanent Vacation

4.9

Exceptional(251)

Price: Moderate

• American • Maitland

Booked 22 times today

Permanent Vacation, located in Florida, is a top-rated spot for excellent American cuisine. Patrons highly praise the quality of the food and drinks, in addition to the outstanding ambiance and service. One reviewer described it as the “best tiki bar in Florida.” Many others echoed this sentiment, praising the “unique and curated” cocktails and delicious pulled pork dishes. The staff's attentiveness, particularly towards guests with physical limitations, is hailed as respectful and accommodating. The restaurant's fun and unique atmosphere is consistently highlighted in reviews, with patrons recommending the Permanent Vacation for a memorable dining experience. Despite being a relatively new establishment, it's already making a significant mark on the local culinary scene.

9. Jazz Tastings

4.8

Exceptional(542)

Price: Expensive

• American • Maitland

Booked 9 times today

Jazz Tastings is a well-regarded restaurant offering an excellent American cuisine experience. With its focus on quality food and live entertainment, this spot has been described as "an amazing place with great music and relaxed atmosphere", perfect for couples or friends. While it doesn't offer a vast menu, guests praise what is available, such as the short ribs, steak frites, Cajun pasta, and pecan crusted salmon, all "cooked to perfection". Other highlights include the outstanding service and the ambiance, with several reviews calling it "the perfect spot for a date night". Jazz Tastings' commitment to great food and entertainment keeps visitors coming back.

10. The Old Jailhouse

4.6

Exceptional(542)

Price: Moderate

• American • Sanford

Booked 20 times today

The Old Jailhouse is a highly recommended restaurant known for its unique atmosphere and excellent American cuisine. Patrons consistently praise the quality of the food and the attentive service. Highlights from reviews include notes on the restaurant's creative cocktails and a steak pasta dish, indicating a varied menu. The restaurant's setting, maintaining the original bars and architectural features of a former jailhouse, also adds to the appeal. However, what truly sets The Old Jailhouse apart is its commitment to a stellar dining experience - from the knowledgeable staff to the tasteful presentation of dishes - making it a favorite go-to spot for both new customers and regulars.

How is content generated

Discover best American restaurants in Lake Mary

Discover the vibrant dining scene of Orlando / Central Florida East, specifically in Lake Mary, where American cuisine takes center stage. This region offers a diverse array of restaurants that cater to lovers of traditional and contemporary American dishes, ensuring every palate is satisfied. Diners can expect a mix of casual and upscale settings, each providing a unique atmosphere and high-quality food that consistently earns positive reviews. These establishments pride themselves on their commitment to authenticity and culinary excellence, often featuring menus that include gluten-free and vegetarian options to accommodate all dietary needs. The dining experience is enhanced by attentive service and a welcoming ambiance, making each meal memorable. Whether you’re in the mood for classic comfort food or innovative American fare, Lake Mary’s restaurant scene is sure to delight. Perfect for both locals and visitors alike, these restaurants offer a taste of American hospitality and flavor in the heart of Florida.

Explore OpenTable

Lake Mary

American