Best American Restaurants in East Petersburg

Price: Moderate (12)Price: Expensive (11)Price: Very Expensive (2)

18 restaurants available nearby

A photo of Gibraltar Lancaster restaurant

1. Gibraltar Lancaster

4.9

Exceptional(2253)

Price: Expensive

• American • Lancaster

Booked 22 times today

Gibraltar Lancaster is widely recognized as one of the best seafood restaurants in the area, with reviews affirming the excellent quality of its seafood dishes, particularly the fresh halibut specials and seafood sampler tower. The lobster fettuccine and almond crusted halibut also come highly recommended, demonstrating the creative culinary skills of their chefs. Patrons not only commend their top-notch food but also the attentive service, solid wine selection, and exceptional ambiance. Regardless if you're a local or living 40 minutes away, the consensus seems to be that the dining experience at Gibraltar Lancaster is well worth the trip.

A photo of Belvedere Inn Restaurant and Bar restaurant

2. Belvedere Inn Restaurant and Bar

4.8

Exceptional(3850)

Price: Expensive

• American • Lancaster

Booked 66 times today

Belvedere Inn Restaurant and Bar is highly praised for its superb American cuisine. Based on the reviews, it offers a fantastic dining experience with its exceptional food, excellent service, and inviting ambiance. Customers repeatedly mention enjoying meals on the beautiful patio, indicating a pleasant setting that enhances the dining experience. Continuous praises for their steak, salmon, and particularly the uniquely flavored Asian salad, are testament to the culinary mastery at Belvedere. The restaurant is also appreciated for accommodating special occasions, such as wedding anniversaries, making it a favored choice in Lancaster. The food is often described as delicious, well-prepared, and outstanding, further cementing Belvedere's place as a gem of American cuisine.

A photo of Iron Hill Brewery - Lancaster restaurant

3. Iron Hill Brewery - Lancaster

4.3

Awesome(3297)

Price: Moderate

• American • Lancaster

Booked 24 times today

Iron Hill Brewery in Lancaster is hailed for its excellent American cuisine. The restaurant garners high praise for its variety of dishes and emphasis on quality. Reviews speak volumes about the delicious offerings, from the Moroccan salmon to the pecan crusted salmon, and the unique Tuna Takati. Their rib eye steak has also been particularly commended. Iron Hill Brewery also offers a specialized Oktoberfest menu that adds a German twist to their offerings. The accommodating service alongside the great food creates an ideal dining experience, with many customers consistently returning, confirming the restaurant's consistent quality and warm hospitality.

4. 401 Prime

4.7

Exceptional(619)

Price: Very Expensive

• American • Lancaster

Booked 25 times today

401 Prime, located in Lancaster, is a high-end steakhouse that has garnered rave reviews. Known for its exceptional service, expertly prepared steaks, fresh oysters, and creative salads, 401 Prime ensures a topnotch dining experience. The restaurant stands out for its beautiful ambiance—one of the best in Lancaster—providing a royal treatment to all its guests. Reviewers have lauded the knowledge of the staff, highlighting their eagerness for continuous improvement. The steaks earned high praise, with one 75-year-old customer noting that they served the best filets he had ever had. Besides steak, they serve desserts that are not to be missed, their loaded bake potato and shaved Brussels sprouts are appreciated. In addition to the fantastic service and menu, the elegant space and attention to detail add to the overall dining pleasure at 401 Prime. The restaurant is also highly recommended for special occasions.

A photo of JB Dawson's Restaurant & Bar - Lancaster restaurant

5. JB Dawson's Restaurant & Bar - Lancaster

4.7

Exceptional(1036)

Price: Moderate

• American • Lancaster

Booked 9 times today

JB Dawson's Restaurant & Bar - Lancaster, embodies the essence of good American cuisine. The restaurant menu impresses with a wide variety of gluten-free options like the North Atlantic Grilled Salmon and Cajun Ribeye, indulgent choice meats such as Prime Rib and Strip Steak, and classic handhelds like the Prime Rib Sandwich and Cheeseburger. Reviewers can't help but praise the restaurant for its delicious food, quick and friendly service, and ability to accommodate dietary restrictions such as a shellfish allergy. The Texas Tenders come highly recommended, with customers applauding the generous portions. Regular patrons even rank JB Dawson's above competitors for fast service, food quality, and price. Also, noteworthy is their ability to replace problematic orders swiftly and effectively, further emphasizing their dedication to service. From pasta to steak, the food here never fails to delight, making the JB Dawson's Restaurant & Bar a culinary gem in Lancaster.

A photo of Lititz Springs Inn and Spa restaurant

6. Lititz Springs Inn and Spa

4.4

Awesome(961)

Price: Expensive

• American • Lititz

Booked 5 times today

Lititz Springs Inn and Spa has established itself as a favorite culinary destination of many, offering splendid American cuisine. Reviewers speak highly of its excellent service, great atmosphere, and varied menu that caters to everyone's tastes. Patrons rave about the delicious food with repeated mentions of the outstanding burger, superb chicken corn soup, divine Limoncello cake, and superb flank steak, among other dishes. Its notable qualities doesn't end at the food; the Lititz Springs Inn and Spa also boasts an excellent selection of beer at the bar, further earning patrons' adoration. It is especially appreciated for its attentiveness even during busy periods, its professionalism, and its ability to accommodate a gluten-free diet, making every dining experience memorable.

A photo of Cork & Cap Restaurant restaurant

7. Cork & Cap Restaurant

4.7

Exceptional(1439)

Price: Expensive

• American • Lancaster

Booked 16 times today

Cork & Cap Restaurant, located in Lancaster, has been lauded by patrons for its exceptional American cuisine. Loved for both its atmosphere and food, reviews highlight dishes such as the perfectly prepared braised veal with risotto, the sensational crab cakes, and the succulent roasted duck. Customers also rave about the innovative menu and the freshness of the ingredients used. The restaurant's lobster bisque is commended for its flavor and the generous lumps of lobster meat it contains. With multiple reviewers expressing their eagerness to revisit, Cork & Cap Restaurant is clearly a standout choice for top-notch American fare in Lancaster.

8. Bistro 2two2

4.4

Awesome(105)

Price: Moderate

• American • Lancaster

Bistro 2two2 is a splendid restaurant acclaimed for its exceptional American cuisine. Customers are effusive in their praise for the delicious food, excellent service, and inviting ambience. The reviews highlight a variety of dishes, from succulent meats to sumptuous desserts, with many customers particularly impressed by the unique Duck Comfit and Pinot Noir wine. The restaurant's atmosphere is praised as clean and inviting, and the service consistently receives high marks for efficiency and friendliness. One review fondly recalled a "perfect" business lunch, while others eagerly anticipate returning. Given these commendations, Bistro 2two2 clearly stands out as a premier destination for quality American dining.

A photo of BJ's Restaurant & Brewhouse - Lancaster restaurant

9. BJ's Restaurant & Brewhouse - Lancaster

4.4

Awesome(83)

Price: Moderate

• American • Lancaster

BJ's Restaurant & Brewhouse in Lancaster is renowned for its exceptional American cuisine. Patrons applaud the excellent food and large menu that caters to various tastes. The restaurant's environment is casual, perfect for any occasion. Customers frequently commend the service, noting that the staff is very friendly, attentive, and accommodating. The assortment of delicacies, including tri-tip sliders and the crispy honey chicken salad, receive special mention for their deliciousness. Loyal customers also admire BJ's commitment to safety amidst the pandemic, speaking highly of their implementation of social distancing and other precautions. This has become a favorite dining spot in Lancaster, celebrated for its food, service, and atmosphere.

A photo of Arthur's Terrace Restaurant restaurant

10. Arthur's Terrace Restaurant

3.8

Excellent(133)

Price: Moderate

• American • Lancaster

Arthur's Terrace Restaurant is lauded for its exceptional American cuisine. Customer reviews repeatedly praise the generous portions, well-cooked prime rib, and top-notch service. The extensive offerings, including a buffet on Friday and Saturday evenings, feature a range of delectable dishes that go beyond the typical buffet fare. With its relaxing environment and prompt service, it has managed to please many. The dishes such as the Pork and Broccoli Rabe and the Rib Eye cheesesteak, are highlighted as standout options. With its exceptional food and service, Arthur's Terrace offers a premium dining experience that faithfully represents the American culinary tradition.

‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

Explore OpenTable

East Petersburg

American