Best American Restaurants in Carnegie Hill

Price: Moderate (445)Price: Expensive (392)Price: Very Expensive (163)

534 restaurants available nearby

A photo of Tavern on the Green restaurant

1. Tavern on the Green

4.7

Exceptional(18353)

Price: Expensive

• American • Midtown West

Booked 219 times today

Tavern on the Green, situated in the heart of New York City in Central Park, offers a delightful American cuisine experience. Known for its iconic location, the restaurant has earned a reputation for its classic American food. Patrons celebrate its well-prepared dishes, from Saturday brunch classics like eggs benedict and French toast, to lunch and dinner delicacies like their golden brown crispy chicken sandwich, and sliced prime steak with French dip. Many visitors recommend their truffle oil and Parmesan cheese shoestring fries as a delightful treat. The restaurant has been described as one of the most historic, beautiful, and fascinating American restaurants that "absolutely exceeded our high expectations," making it a regular stop for many on their visits to Manhattan. The ambiance, exemplified by the scenic view of Sheep Meadow, is praised as much as the food, making Tavern on the Green a beloved spot for both tourists and New Yorkers.

2. Bad Roman

4.5

Awesome(1923)

Price: Expensive

• American • Upper West Side

Booked 250 times today

Bad Roman consistently exceeds customer expectations with their exemplary service and delicious Italian cuisine. The culinary team's compelling modern twist on traditional dishes, such as their mouth-watering short rib pappardelle and the unique garlic babka, has been praised in numerous reviews. Their fun atmosphere and attentive staff members further enhance the dining experience. Patrons have commended the team for making every client feel special, with several singling out the stellar service from Ricky and Jay at the bar. Special occasions are made memorable here, with one guest endorsing it as "one of the best New York experiences." Despite the bustling crowd, Bad Roman ensures a unique, indulgent and flawless dining experience for everyone. Their passion for excellence is evident in their dishes and the positive reviews speak volumes about their superior Italian cuisine.

3. Cafe Luxembourg

4.7

Exceptional(8458)

Price: Expensive

• American • Upper West Side

Booked 159 times today

Cafe Luxembourg is offering reservations for indoor and outdoor dining. Walk-Ins are welcome. Our Outdoor Cafe is complete with rain-proof awnings, fans, electric heaters and flexible plexiglass windows for your comfort. *Per the rules and regulations of the DINING OUT NYC Program, Outdoor Seating will no longer be available beginning 11.01.24. Due to demand, we are unable to hold your reservation past the time it has been booked. If you are not present at the time of your reservation, we will offer the table to waiting guests. If you are running late or wish to cancel, please call us at 212-873-7411. We look forward to seeing you soon. The safety and welfare of our employees and guests is a top priority.Cafe Luxembourg has newly installed Merv13 filters, installed in all ducts. The filters trap 98% of airborne particles as small as .3 microns The air is not recycled but forced fresh air. Thank you for your patronage!

4. Island

4.6

Exceptional(1080)

Price: Expensive

• American • Upper East Side

Booked 39 times today

Island restaurant, nestled in the Upper East Side, is celebrated for its exquisite American cuisine. Patrons applaud the consistently wonderful food, noting special mention of the Mahi Mahi, spaghetti with shrimp, and delectable desserts like blueberry cobbler. Reviews highlight the beautiful ambiance of the protected outdoor structure, adding a lovely touch to the dining experience. This neighborhood gem is also praised for its professional, efficient, and friendly service, with efficient servers like Renata and Adriana getting rave reviews. Despite the occasional noise from the bustling Madison street, Island's charm lies in its dependable pleasant spot for lunch or dinner.

A photo of Quality Italian - New York restaurant

5. Quality Italian - New York

4.6

Exceptional(5903)

Price: Expensive

• American • Midtown West

Booked 183 times today

Located in the heart of New York City, Quality Italian offers an exceptional dining experience, renowned for its excellent Italian cuisine. Customers frequently highlight the exquisite taste of dishes such as the Caesar salad, steak, pesto mafaldine, and highly recommended chicken Parmesan. As one reviewer put it, it's "honestly the best food my husband and I have ever had." The restaurant also boasts of a great wine list and an attentive, professional service team, as evidenced by multiple rave reviews. Despite the slight concern over table proximity, customers commonly describe Quality Italian as a "great place", "perfect ambiance", and an "amazing experience". With praises for the food still echoing long after meals, Quality Italian is no doubt a premium choice for lovers of Italian cuisine.

6. Quality Bistro

4.7

Exceptional(2877)

Price: Expensive

• American • Midtown West

Booked 128 times today

Quality Bistro, nestled in New York City, truly embodies remarkable American cuisine that resonates with many patrons. In numerous review snippets, the restaurant's diverse and delicious menu stands out, with the Chateau Briand, pistachio crème brulee, and corn crème brulee receiving special praise. One reviewer tagged it as their 'favorite' amongst all Quality establishments in NYC, reflecting its distinct appeal. The venue’s ambiance is frequently highlighted as 'lovely', 'beautiful' and 'cozy', playing host to memorable dining experiences, satisfying gatherings, and special occasions. The warmth, professionalism, and efficiency of service complement the culinary excellence, affirming Quality Bistro as a superior choice for delectable American dining.

A photo of The Smith- Lincoln Square restaurant

7. The Smith- Lincoln Square

4.5

Awesome(11897)

Price: Moderate

• American • Lincoln Square

Booked 182 times today

The Smith- Lincoln Square, situated close to the renowned Lincoln Center in New York City, consistently receives praise for its excellent casual American food and exceptional service. As a lively bistro that offers a good selection of well-made comfort food and drinks, it is a popular choice for pre-theater meals. Customers laud its extensive menu options, which are both quick to arrive and super delicious, making it the ideal spot to sample authentic American cuisine. Further testament to its high quality are the repeated positive mentions of dedicated and professional staff, suggesting an experience that is as enjoyable as it is gastronomically satisfying.

A photo of Flex Mussels - UES restaurant

8. Flex Mussels - UES

4.7

Exceptional(2732)

Price: Moderate

• American • Upper East Side

Booked 55 times today

Flex Mussels - UES is a renowned restaurant that specializes in Seafood cuisine. The restaurant's menu showcases an array of diverse seafood dishes, from the “Mussels, Mussels, Mussels” options such as the 'Oaxacan' and 'San Daniele' to 'Not Mussels' choices like 'Branzino' and 'Lobster Frites'. As highlighted in the reviews, the Parm Mussels and seafood dishes are nothing short of excellent. Customers laud the freshness of the seafood, from the oysters to the mussels. The service at the Flex Mussels - UES is exceptional, ensuring all guests feel welcomed and satisfied. Moreover, the restaurant's seafood dishes are deemed some of the best in New York City. Whether for dinner or brunch, the Flex Mussels - UES doesn't disappoint when it comes to Seafood cuisine.

9. Zou Zou's

4.5

Awesome(1362)

Price: Expensive

• American • Hell's Kitchen

Booked 172 times today

Zou Zou's is an iconic Mediterranean restaurant, celebrated for its unique spin on culinary favorites. Reviews continue to laud its delicious and inventively prepared dishes, complemented by its vibrant and trendy environment. Patrons highly recommend the variety of dips, the Moroccan Fried Chicken, and the Branzino, among other dishes. The staff is described as attentive and knowledgeable, making for an outstanding experience. Zou Zou’s is also recognized for its alluring ambience and excellent service, with several reviewers eager to return during their next visit to New York City. Whether you're a discerning foodie or someone seeking a novel dining adventure, this restaurant is a must-visit for an unforgettable food experience.

A photo of RH Rooftop Restaurant New York restaurant

10. RH Rooftop Restaurant New York

4.7

Exceptional(4891)

Price: Moderate

• American • West Village

Booked 316 times today

RH Rooftop Restaurant in New York City consistently earns high praise for its exceptional American cuisine and breathtaking ambiance. As part of an upscale furniture store located on the 5th floor, with the restaurant on the 4th, the venue offers a glamorous dining experience. Patrons repeatedly commend the exquisite quality of the dishes such as lobster roll, truffle fries, and burrata. Despite a limited menu, every item shines, reflecting American culinary tradition. The service also impresses with its attentiveness, adding to the diners' overall satisfaction. Reviewers describe it as an "incredibly magical experience" with "fantastic food", "excellent service", and a "beautiful setting". It's a jewel among NYC's restaurants, perfect for any celebration.

‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

Explore OpenTable

Carnegie Hill

American