Way too crowded during Covid, not enforcing mask wearing at a Marriott resort and service was terribly slow for a place that was not overcrowded.

Service was terrible as they only had three servers and no hostess. Our waiter was continuously searing others and ignore us. Not his fault but managements. Ordered filter med rare and got a filet almost med well. My wife’s was cooked as ordered. 20 min later my second steak arrives (my wife is finished) and my steak is raw in the middle. Are what I could and had to almost grab server to get check. He asked if everyOK and we said no and told him why. He said he would call the manager and see what he could do. He returned later with our bill at full price! No comp, no desert or drink. For a rated 4+star steak house we both were surprised. I’ve had better food and service at a chain. Will not see us again.

The ambiance and service were great, the food was awful and extremely expensive for the portions and quality - wish we chose a different place to spend $200 for 2 people.

We were expecting a nice evening out. We had bad service, never asked me about a drink but my husband had 2. Steaks were Medwell and ordered medrare Everything was slow coming and not a busy night. I can go on but won’t. Talked to other people on way out and their experience completely opposite

Wife ordered a filet mignon cooked med well.
It came out med rear the waiter apologized and brought out another one which was cooked medium.
For the price of the steaks the chef should know how to cook a filet.
Service was excellent and so was the rest of the food.

Incredible meal and service. Great food and the serving sizes were not too large. Our waiter Calvert was very attentive and helpful. Would highly recommend!

Excellent food.

Nice meal. Server disinterested in seeing to our needs. Took our order , served out meal and didn’t see him until the check came despite us being one of only 4 couples there

The restaurant was out of two preferred entree selections. My husband's strip steak, ordered medium rare, had to be returned as it arrived at medium well. My chicken selection was miniature and rather dry. My accompanying "mushroom risotto" was literally just rice with mushrooms. Little culinary talent displayed. A very costly dining mistake.

The restaurant itself was ok and service ok but the food was terrible starting with the what seemed like 2 day old frozen rolls that were cold, any nice restaurant will start with some type of nice warm bread or rolls, the bone in ribeye ordered medium rare had no red at all and was tough, the mac and cheese seemed like it was from a box of kraft mac and cheese, do mind paying for a nice restaurant with quality food but this was worst I can remember and would advise any of my friends to avoid

The experience was saved by the friendly and attentive Server, Calbert.

Great food as usual

Best everything. Not one complaint. Must try.

Awesome food. Steak was a little too salty.

Very good. Service was great. Food was amazing for price. Would highly recommend when staying in the fort Myers area.

Food took way too long to arrive
Will not be coming back

We are locals and tried the restaurant for the first time. Iceberg and Beet salads were good. Recommend splitting. Large in size. I ordered a MR filet and got a MW and he ordered M and got MR. The steaks were okay. Nothing to write home about. Our server, Calbert was very nice. The cheesecake seemed very old. The Courtside is close to home but for the quality and price we will drive to Naples for a good steakhouse.

Great and our server, I believe his name was Campton, sorry for miss-spelling, but he was great! Manager was great as well and food excellent!

Wonderful experience from start to finish.
Highly recommend for a first class experience.
The food and service is outstanding.

We love to go there when we are in town. They have the best She Crab Bisque. They knew it was our anniversary, although I didn’t tell them, and treated us to champagne! They may keep records from previous visits, but it was a nice surprise.

Will be back!

Vacation stay at Marriott’s Sanibel Harbor and a short walk over to Courtside. Food was excellent. Service was superb, and was great to be able to support food service workers during this time. Appropriate social distancing and extra cleaning in place.

It was a Hugh end steakhouse with good food.

Was given a spoiled steak after almost an hour wait. All the food was cooked incorrectly and under the heater. Wait staff was not great either. Overall disappointed.

We were there on New Years Eve. Whatever could go wrong, did! The only good thing about the evening was the company we were with! It appeared they were totally understaffed. Waitstaff, kitchen, limited bar! Did not live up to the standard of previous dinning experience!

This restaurant consistently performs at the highest standards of quality food and service. This staff is so very well trained in the proper procedures when it comes to serving properly. Ladies are always first to order and the first served. Oabsolutely outstanding.

Excellent wine list and they let us pick one from the cellar not on the list.

Steak was great and cooked to correct order.

Staff was great!

Great service, Great food!!!

We had our Christmas dinner here and enjoyed the quietness of the restaurant. There were some tasteful Christmas decorations, but sadly, no Christmas music. We had wonderful service and a lovely spot to sit overlooking the tennis courts. The menu had many attractive offerings and we tried both the filet mignon and the rack of lamb. The lamb was served nicely, but the steak was a tiny piece of meat on a huge plate with nothing else on it- a little disappointing presentation. Both of our meats were fairly tender, but they didn't have much flavor, except for the sauces. There were no seasonings used in the cooking, and that left the meats a bit tasteless. We were surprised that there was no mint jelly available for the lamb- such a standard feature. In general, we enjoyed our experience and will probably return, but we would want to try other offerings.

So horrible we walked out even before we ordered. There were literally 4 tables in the place and waited 15 minutes for our server and got up and left. Do NOT bother evening considering this place.

Excellent food if you are staying at Marriott Sanibel.

This restaurant is a hidden gem in the Fort Myers area. Ambiance, service and food are all outstanding! I had the cowboy ribeye and it was perfect. Try the mushroom risotto, unbelievable!
Service outstanding!

It was our 40th anniversary, and Colbert (our server who is AWESOME) must have arranged for a wonderful dessert for us. Made our night extra special.

Food presentation was unimpressive. A single 5 oz filet laying along on a large plate. Nothing like the pictures they advertise. The place was basically empty and they had run out of all desserts. Very disappointing for how expensive it was. Stay away if possible.

This is my favorite formal dining location in Sanibel. The best steak in Southwest Florida.

Incredibly disappointed. Food was mediocre. Bathrooms dirty. Service was nothing to remake about.

Food temps were off. Flavor profiles were good.

Very good food! Attentive service! One steak was cooked a little rare but better a little rare than overdone! A customer dining in the same area was a very loud talker; not much you can do about that.

It was absolutely amazing celebrating our 30th Wedding anniversary! We felt safe and “Covid friendly” and the food was absolutely spectacular! The host and waiter were also soooo personal and professional. Thank you and your staff for a memorable evening!!

Steak was wonderful, service very good and personable

This restaurant is one of our favorites where the service and food make this a pleasure and wonderful experience
The steaks are fabulous along with the freshest seafood and the portions are very generous
The professional service within the entire establishment make this a great dinning experience