Best American Restaurants in Carroll Gardens

Prime MeatsPrime Meats
(256)
$$$$
American | Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn
Buttermilk ChannelButtermilk Channel
(442)
$$$$
American | Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn
River CafeRiver Cafe
(6622)
$$$$
American | DUMBO / Vinegar Hill, Brooklyn
VekslersVekslers
(12)
$$$$
American | Cobble Hill, Brooklyn
WestlightWestlight
(343)
$$$$
American | Williamsburg, Brooklyn
Henry's EndHenry's End
(507)
$$$$
American | Brooklyn Heights, Brooklyn
DenizenDenizen
(30)
$$$$
American | Williamsburg, Brooklyn
MeadowsweetMeadowsweet
(499)
$$$$
American | Williamsburg, Brooklyn
The BountyThe Bounty
(26)
$$$$
American | Greenpoint, Brooklyn
RiderRider
(106)
$$$$
American | Williamsburg, Brooklyn
Grand Ferry TavernGrand Ferry Tavern
(27)
$$$$
American | Williamsburg, Brooklyn
Forrest PointForrest Point
(22)
$$$$
American | Bushwick, Brooklyn

Best Italian Restaurants in Carroll Gardens

Marco Polo RistoranteMarco Polo Ristorante
(194)
$$$$
Italian | Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn
Aperture Italian RestaurantAperture Italian Restaurant
(30)
$$$$
Italian | Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn
Broccolino Cobble HillBroccolino Cobble Hill
(26)
$$$$
Italian | Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn
Locanda Vini e OliiLocanda Vini e Olii
(491)
$$$$
Italian | Clinton Hill, Brooklyn
Michael's of BrooklynMichael's of Brooklyn
(173)
$$$$
Italian | Midwood, Brooklyn
D.O.C. Wine BarD.O.C. Wine Bar
(43)
$$$$
Italian | Williamsburg, Brooklyn
SocialeSociale
(366)
$$$$
Italian | Brooklyn Heights, Brooklyn
BaranoBarano
(182)
$$$$
Italian | Williamsburg, Brooklyn
MariellaMariella
(31)
$$$$
Italian | Park Slope, Brooklyn
Naked DogNaked Dog
(154)
$$$$
Italian | Greenpoint, Brooklyn
Aurora - WilliamsburgAurora - Williamsburg
(341)
$$$$
Italian | Williamsburg, Brooklyn
LeucaLeuca
(385)
$$$$
Italian | Williamsburg, Brooklyn
The Saint AustereThe Saint Austere
(83)
$$$$
Italian | Williamsburg, Brooklyn
Broccolino - Park SlopeBroccolino - Park Slope
(34)
$$$$
Italian | Park Slope, Brooklyn
Convivium OsteriaConvivium Osteria
(951)
$$$$
Italian | Park Slope, Brooklyn

Popular restaurants in New York Area

Browse some of the most booked restaurants in New York Area

HAVEN Riverfront Restaurant and Bar
(199)
$$$$
Contemporary American | Edgewater
Mitchell's Fish Market - Edgewater
(91)
$$$$
Seafood | Edgewater
Serafina 105
(122)
$$$$
Italian | Upper West Side
Marlow Bistro
(179)
$$$$
Mediterranean | Upper West Side
View all New York Area restaurants
Carroll Gardens Locals Are Talking About
What do you love most about Carroll Gardens?
Social, secure and fun.
M
Mickeyson - New York Area
What do you love most about Carroll Gardens?
There are various cuisine choices based on what you're in the mood for. If you want it, you'll find it!
OT
OpenTable Diner - New York Area
What do locals love about Carroll Gardens?
Still a neighborhood with a long time family feel. While young families are moving in, older people still have a strong presence there. Not much of a hipster element, thankfully.
N
Nancy54 - Salt Lake City

Treat your taste buds: Explore Carroll Gardens restaurants.

Carroll Gardens Restaurants

Aperture Italian RestaurantAperture Italian Restaurant
30 reviews
$$$$
Italian | Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn

Delicious food and wonderful staff More

OpenTable Diner -
Buttermilk ChannelButtermilk Channel
442 reviews
$$$$
American | Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn

Great food!!! More

OpenTable Diner -
The Eatery @ East OneThe Eatery @ East One
1 review
$$$$
American | Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn

Brunch was delicious! More

OpenTable Diner -
Prime MeatsPrime Meats
256 reviews
$$$$
American | Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn

From beginning to end it was awesome. My brothers birthday lunch. Everyone was super friendly and welcoming. More

OpenTable Diner -
DumonetDumonet
14 reviews
$$$$
French | Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn

Delicious food and very welcoming friendly staff. Recommend this place for sure! Great to have nice French bistro in neighborhood! We loved it! More

OpenTable Diner -
GersiGersi
91 reviews
$$$$
Contemporary Italian | Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn

Delightful neighborhood spot. Great vibe, amazing food and attentive service! I don’t know what they did to the eggplant but it was a standout! More

OpenTable Diner -
Marco Polo RistoranteMarco Polo Ristorante
194 reviews
$$$$
Italian | Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn

Food was great. Great ambiance. Small service issue where he waiter forgot about us after dinner was over and we had to wait 15 minutes to order desser but otherwise a great experience. More

OpenTable Diner -
Broccolino Cobble HillBroccolino Cobble Hill
26 reviews
$$$$
Italian | Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn

Very convenient to where I live can walk there.Good selection and enjoyed the food. More

OpenTable Diner -
La CigogneLa Cigogne
98 reviews
$$$$
French | Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn

Fantastic onion soup. I really enjoyed my tartine which is Alsatian pizza. Great wine list. Service was terrific. More

OpenTable Diner -
Cubana CafeCubana Cafe
17 reviews
$$$$
Cuban | Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn

Good food and service and happy hour. Had a nice time. More

OpenTable Diner -
MazzatMazzat
4 reviews
$$$$
Mediterranean | Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn

My family and I had a wonderful time at Mazzat. The food tasted fresh and delicious; if you like Mediterranean food, this is a great option. All of the dishes were excellent! More

OpenTable Diner -

Carroll Gardens Diners' Choice Winners

Carroll Gardens's best restaurants based upon thousands of OpenTable diner reviews
Buttermilk ChannelButtermilk Channel
442 reviews
$$$$
American | Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn

Great food!!! More

OpenTable Diner -
Prime MeatsPrime Meats
256 reviews
$$$$
American | Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn

From beginning to end it was awesome. My brothers birthday lunch. Everyone was super friendly and welcoming. More

OpenTable Diner -
Marco Polo RistoranteMarco Polo Ristorante
194 reviews
$$$$
Italian | Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn

Food was great. Great ambiance. Small service issue where he waiter forgot about us after dinner was over and we had to wait 15 minutes to order desser but otherwise a great experience. More

OpenTable Diner -
GersiGersi
91 reviews
$$$$
Contemporary Italian | Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn

Delightful neighborhood spot. Great vibe, amazing food and attentive service! I don’t know what they did to the eggplant but it was a standout! More

OpenTable Diner -
La CigogneLa Cigogne
98 reviews
$$$$
French | Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn

Fantastic onion soup. I really enjoyed my tartine which is Alsatian pizza. Great wine list. Service was terrific. More

OpenTable Diner -