Best Italian Restaurants in Carroll Gardens

View all

Best Italian Restaurants in Carroll Gardens

Best American Restaurants in Carroll Gardens

View all

Best American Restaurants in Carroll Gardens

Popular restaurants in New York Area

Browse some of the most booked restaurants in New York Area

HAVEN Riverfront Restaurant and Bar
(310)
$$$$
Contemporary American | Edgewater
Rebecca's
(69)
$$$$
Cuban | Edgewater
Ortomare Ristorante Pizzeria
(25)
$$$$
Italian | Upper West Side
View all New York Area restaurants

Treat your taste buds: Explore Carroll Gardens restaurants.

  • Restaurant List
  • Best Restaurants

Carroll Gardens Restaurants

Treat your taste buds: Explore Carroll Gardens restaurants.

Carroll Gardens Restaurants

FragoleFragole
22 reviews
$$$$
Italian | Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn

Classic neighborhood Italian restaurant with excellent food. More

OpenTable Diner -
Buttermilk ChannelButtermilk Channel
652 reviews
$$$$
American | Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn

Love this neighborhood spot! Great food, great service, wonderful staff!! More

OpenTable Diner -
GersiGersi
194 reviews
$$$$
Contemporary Italian | Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn

Such a cute and delicious find in the neighborhood. Cant want to come back in the summer and dine outside in their garden. Make sure to get the housemade pasta specials! More

OpenTable Diner -
The Eatery @ East OneThe Eatery @ East One
30 reviews
$$$$
American | Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn

Nice breakfast with danish influenced decor and some danish dishes More

OpenTable Diner -
Marco Polo RistoranteMarco Polo Ristorante
232 reviews
$$$$
Italian | Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn

A cozy restaurant good for family dinners or romantic nights. The fettuccine al vino Rosso is incredible! More

OpenTable Diner -
La SlowteriaLa Slowteria
41 reviews
$$$$
Mexican | Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn

Great little place. Good friendly service. The food is good but the portions are small. More

OpenTable Diner -
Broccolino Cobble HillBroccolino Cobble Hill
51 reviews
$$$$
Italian | Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn

Waitress very nice !Good Food.Easy to get a reservation. More

OpenTable Diner -
SansSans
48 reviews
$$$$
Vegetarian / Vegan | Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn

We had a great time. The food was excellent and the service was as good as it gets. More

OpenTable Diner -
La CigogneLa Cigogne
150 reviews
$$$$
French | Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn

Picked this place for my boyfriend to meet the parents for the first time. The service was pretty great, though at times confusing. We had two people who seemed to be waiting our table, checking in at different points so I wasn’t sure if they knew who was really our waiter. And though that sounds great, it was very confusing when we asked a question about something on the menu and then they’d go check, or tell us something different than what we were previously told. Never mind about that, the food is really good. Mom and dad were happy with how their steaks were cooked, boyfriend loved the red snapper dish (me too!) and I enjoyed the mussels. The Brussels sprouts are perfect, tuna tartare is pretty good, but the best part was the Creme Brûlée. Drinks are just okay, I’d stick with a wine. For everything, we paid a pretty penny ($$$), but for New York it was not that bad. 9/10 would recommend. More

OpenTable Diner -
Madcap CafeMadcap Cafe
3 reviews
$$$$
American | Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn

This has quickly become one of our favorite places to have dinner in Carroll Gardens. Especially good is the salad with chicken! The burgers are delicious and the brownie/ice cream dessert is sinfully good. The cocktails are inventive and the wine selection offers a range of choices. I recommend making reservations, as the space is tight. If memory serves, it is located in the old "Hole in the Wall" video store. This place is dang near perfect! More

OpenTable Diner -
Aperture Italian RestaurantAperture Italian Restaurant
38 reviews
$$$$
Italian | Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn

Happened on this place from social media searches. Quaint neighborhood place. We were seated right away. Service was great and the staff was very happy to serve us. Bartender made some great drinks. All of us really enjoyed our meals. The pastas were very fresh and cooked perfectly. We ordered carbonara, the fusilli dish on menu and cavatelli with broccoli rabe and sausage. All were very good. I was somewhat surprised by the cavatelli dish being served in a red sauce. I enjoyed it as it was flavorful but I prefer it without tomato sauce. Dessert was very good as well. We would like to come back from NJ and try more on the menu. More

OpenTable Diner -

Carroll Gardens Diners' Choice Winners

Carroll Gardens's best restaurants based upon thousands of OpenTable diner reviews
Buttermilk ChannelButtermilk Channel
652 reviews
$$$$
American | Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn

Love this neighborhood spot! Great food, great service, wonderful staff!! More

OpenTable Diner -
FragoleFragole
22 reviews
$$$$
Italian | Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn

Classic neighborhood Italian restaurant with excellent food. More

OpenTable Diner -
The Eatery @ East OneThe Eatery @ East One
30 reviews
$$$$
American | Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn

Nice breakfast with danish influenced decor and some danish dishes More

OpenTable Diner -
GersiGersi
194 reviews
$$$$
Contemporary Italian | Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn

Such a cute and delicious find in the neighborhood. Cant want to come back in the summer and dine outside in their garden. Make sure to get the housemade pasta specials! More

OpenTable Diner -
Broccolino Cobble HillBroccolino Cobble Hill
51 reviews
$$$$
Italian | Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn

Waitress very nice !Good Food.Easy to get a reservation. More

OpenTable Diner -
Marco Polo RistoranteMarco Polo Ristorante
232 reviews
$$$$
Italian | Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn

A cozy restaurant good for family dinners or romantic nights. The fettuccine al vino Rosso is incredible! More

OpenTable Diner -
La SlowteriaLa Slowteria
41 reviews
$$$$
Mexican | Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn

Great little place. Good friendly service. The food is good but the portions are small. More

OpenTable Diner -
La CigogneLa Cigogne
150 reviews
$$$$
French | Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn

Picked this place for my boyfriend to meet the parents for the first time. The service was pretty great, though at times confusing. We had two people who seemed to be waiting our table, checking in at different points so I wasn’t sure if they knew who was really our waiter. And though that sounds great, it was very confusing when we asked a question about something on the menu and then they’d go check, or tell us something different than what we were previously told. Never mind about that, the food is really good. Mom and dad were happy with how their steaks were cooked, boyfriend loved the red snapper dish (me too!) and I enjoyed the mussels. The Brussels sprouts are perfect, tuna tartare is pretty good, but the best part was the Creme Brûlée. Drinks are just okay, I’d stick with a wine. For everything, we paid a pretty penny ($$$), but for New York it was not that bad. 9/10 would recommend. More

OpenTable Diner -
SansSans
48 reviews
$$$$
Vegetarian / Vegan | Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn

We had a great time. The food was excellent and the service was as good as it gets. More

OpenTable Diner -