I always enjoy dining at Bay Harbor. The food is excellent and the ambience even better. We are treated like family. Just love it there!
This is our go to restaurant for any type of event celebration. In all the time we've eaten here (maybe 20), we've never had less than a fantastic experience. The food is top notch, and the service is great.
Glenda is a fantastic waitress. She is personable, remembers what we like, and is always in a happy mood! We enjoy the quiet atmosphere in the winter.
Great food; great service; great view of the Millennium Force.
Not just for special occasions.
Rather, for ALL occasions!
Our server Abby was great! Very attentive and friendly. We didn’t love one of our dishes and she went above and beyond to make sure we were happy in the end...we will be back just to see her!
It was my wife's birthday, the food was excellent and our server (Kim) was the best. Thanks for a great night.
Great Food Great Service Great View An often overlooked Sandusky gem.
Our server Abby was excellent. Food was great.
Great evening out! The food was delicious. Give the risotto a try. Yum! The service was super with water refills and constant care for our party. The atmosphere was wonderful!! Let's keep this place open all year!!
The Pork Chop rocks,
and the view is great.
When you're done,
You'll be glad you ate.
Beautiful evening with friends.
We returned to Bay Harbor to celebrate our anniversary, and we have several times. My all-time favorite is the king crab legs and I really enjoyed them. Kimberly was very attentive and helpful. We even got a complimentary desert! Fine dining.
The biggest crab I have ever seen! Not to mention the best! Every thing was amazing. Drinks were delicious. And our server was great! Very pleased and will be back again when we are back in Ohio! Thank you again for the amazing meal.
Outstanding Food and (always) Service this Past Friday at the Bay Harbor.
An added bonus: Watching the storm come across the Lake.
A perfect place to dine on the water!
Ingredients were good but lobster bisque and potatoes were both over salted. Scallops were undercooked and coleslaw was bland.
Pork was very undercooked and under seasoned, mashed were under seasoned and very bland.
Was just a lovely relaxing dining experience.
Blackened grouper Oscar was amazing! The service was outstanding.
For a fine dining restaurant, it was good. The food was fresh & cook perfectly.
Great service, great food, great ambiance! We visit every time we go to Cedar Point.
Good was not as good as usual my grouper was salty with the blackened grouper the Walleye was under seasoned lobster tail was good and shrimp was tasty
Our bartender, Glenda was excellent! She catered to our every needs! What a great experience!
Bay Harbor never disappoints. Love the food, view, ambiance and staff. We have been going there for years. Highly recommend the Alaskan King Crab Legs.
Not impressed with the food or service for the price
We will not be returning
Arrived on time for a 7:00 reservation we were told our table would be ready in four minutes, we were finally seated at ten minutes before 8:00. The delay could have been handled much better. As always the view and ambience were fantastic.
Enjoyed the dinner very much, haven't been to this venue for a long time, glad we came back. Parking logistics could be better.
Great water view
We picked this restaurant for our anniversary dinner. Our waitress was Carmen, she was attentive and friendly. She answered all of our questions and provided us with recommendations. The food including the bread and salad was delicious. My husband had the walleye and I have the cheese tortellini.
Great food with amazing views. Kim gives the best service!
It was my husbands and my 42nd wedding anniversary! The food and service was fantastic! I will definitely return!
The food and service are tops.
Order the Pork Chop. Best "meat" dish on the menu.
Crème' Brule' Awesomely awesome.
We had five in our party. One of our members was in a wheel chair. It was easy to get us to our table and seating was comfortable. Our server (I am so sorry I don’t remember her name but she was very helpful and accommodating.. the food was excellent. Two of us had the salmon and it was delicious. The other three had the cod and said the same about it. The food was plentiful to the point where sadly we had no room for dessert. The wine selection was also good. We will definitely be returning.
Be aware, reservations are a good idea and if you will have to pay the $20.00 charge, however it will be reimbursed on your bill.
We had a great time! The food was amazing and so was the service! We highly recommend visiting!
We had dinner on the patio, it was clean with a gorgeous view. The service and food were fantastic.
It was great!
It was a long day at Cedar Point. Wanted to get away from the loud noises and crowds. So glad we found this place! Quiet ambiance, delicious food, great wine list, great service! We had lobster bisque (very yummy), quite possibly the best Cesar salad, shrimp & scallop linguine and fantastic & meaty Alaskan King Crab legs! Felt so good to fill up on real food after a day of park food. Service was impeccable and views of the sunset were amazing. Definitely will be back!!
I had the crab legs. They were delicious. My husband had the linguine with shrimp and scallops. The sauce was very thick. It was all stuck together. Not very good. When we told the manager , she said yeah the cook does that... (She said you should've seen the mushrooms he sauteed.) Really??
Service and food are always terrific.
The view? Priceless!
Our server Abby was the best! We we there for our 7 year anniversary and she was so attentive to everything! She even took time to take our picture in 2 different locations outside! We will be back because of her great service! A+
Our first thoughts were the hostess was very rude and she even had us seat ourselves. No silverware was issued. I had to ask. The fish was very dry. They gave me a replacement
Bay Harbor is rated 4.6 stars by 626 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.