Baron's Cove

Nice restaurant!

First time and we will be back! Staff was super nice. Food was great and so was the view.

Awful.Severance was terrible.After our appetizers we never received our entreesFinally the server realized the kitchen never made it and put the order in.At this point we were the last table in the restaurant.Three of us got the tuna entree for $38 each.We were told it was sushi grade.It was not it looked frozen and awful.Management did nothing to reduce the check.
It was one of the worst experiences we ever had.

Excellent dinner, beautiful dining room.

Always excellent food and service!! Underrated except by those who know. As good or better than any restaurant in Sag Harbor.

Used to love this spot but Saturday night felt like a whole different restaurant.
1. The service was terrible. We were greeted and introduced by one waiter and then it switched and no one told us. The second water seemed to be very confused, about everything!
2. The wine list- what happened?? There was two selections by the bottle for Cabernet Sauvignon plus the one they offered by the glass.
3. The food was just not good. I had a "quinoa stack" for $28 that was 1/2 a cup of cooked quinoa with a mashed avocado on top. Restaurant cost couldn't have been more than $3.00. Two others got filets which were not fresh, one was the end of the tenderloin and very tough. Another got calamari and it was heavily breaded and over-fried.
4. Overall, I would probably not go back and would no longer recommend this restaurant. We drove from Southampton with friends who never want to leave Southampton. We convinced them it was so great, awesome food, nice wine list, great atmosphere... I feel like we lied.

Perhaps all of the above is due to the fact that it was February, the off season, but it was Saturday night and the restaurant and bar were reasonably full. Others around us were complaining as well.

Hope they bring it back to what it once was. Will not last long in The Hamptons with this type of food and service.

Brought friends from Connecticut who have never been to the east end. They enjoyed the day and ended up at Baron's Cove for dinner. Perfect ending to a perfect day! Everything was so delicious!!

Was there with my wife for Saint Valentine Dinner. Had a great time for dinner. We enjoyed the food/prefix of 4 courses that we shared and also had BB shrimp.
Service was on point. Attentive, friendly and knowledgeable.
I’d would go back again here.

Top choice!! Great food, have not had anything that wasn't really good. Service attentive and server recommended house cocktails which were the right choice for our meal!!

Great setting for brunch with great service and food.

Always a lovely atmosphere on a cold winter night with the fireplace blazing. Food is consistently good as well as the service

Awesome as usual. The striped bass was amazing.

The ambiance is the best. The food is middle range bar food and the cocktails apparently were very expensive . I will do it again soon. Just not everyday

My husband and I had a very nice meal at Baron's Cove. The food, the service and the ambiance were all very good.

Great food and drinks during Brunch, cozy room and friendly staff!

New Years Eve last seating.

They were 20 minutes late in seating us. Service was extremely slow and disorganized. The food was not of the quality I expected for $140 a person, despite the holiday. The lobster was bland and tough. And the band was terrible - who plays “The Way It Is” on NYE??!

The food and service were not good and it was very pricy

Baron’s Cove is an amazing venue, which is unfortunately overshadowed by poor service and disappointing food. We attended a NYE event which had both limited seating and a limited menu. The price tag for the seating was $100/person, no alcohol included. There were 3 options in each of the 3 courses, with dessert only of petit fours. The food was sloppy in presentation, and either cold from waiting or overcooked. While the servers were very kind, they were slow in service, sending food to the wrong tables, and forgetting silverware refreshes and water refills. NYE was my first full dining experience at Baron’s Cove, and sadly, it will be my last.

We had the Christmas Day dinner. It was a set menu, albeit with choices for each course. Portions were large and is he quality good. The upstairs dining room was very seasonally decorated with a large roaring fire. Overall it was very enjoyable and good value for money.

We had dinner at Barons Cove on Christmas Night , the place was done up very Rustic old style lights on the tree and inside as well . Ambiance was perfect .. The waiter was very attentive to us , the food for its price ( although it was Christmas) was to much . The manager who I dealt with when reserving my table as well as at the restaurant was very cordial . They just forgot to give us our leftovers when they wrapped them up , we did not realize it till we got home and we had traveled 1.5 hrs to get there . Otherwise the experience was excellent !

We went with a guest for brunch on December 22nd. The inn was beautifully decorated for the holidays and it was a sparkling winter day so the view of the bay was spectacular. I had the french toast with sausages which was excellent and my husband had the Classic brunch with eggs, french toast, etc. My friend had eggs too. All was great but we felt there could have been a little more on the plate. We're not big eaters but even for us it just seemed a little less than generous. We hope to come back for happy hour soon.

We stayed for the weekend. The waiters there are never that good. Mediocre service. The food is good and the atmosphere beautiful! The bartenders are always good. We will be back though it’s such a beautiful place to stay.

It was my Birthday weekend get away. The food was good, nothing crazy good. The service good. The atmosphere is beautiful!

Had a nice lunch today. We celebrated our birthday. They sung for us and made the occasion special. Glad I spent my b day at Barons.

Great ambiance with attentive staff and tasty food.

Nice lunch and good atmosphere. Really cosy in there!

Our server was very attentive and gave us suggestions. Overall, was a great experience!

Had a nice dinner at Barons! Place was cozy and very beautiful!
Nice ocean view and great service!

Had an excellent meal overlooking the harbor, fantastic service and excellent food.

Nice breakfast and good time there! Had the classic barons breakfast.. really enjoyed it.

Love the ambiance and the beautiful view of the harbor! Delicious lobster roll. Service was wonderful and friendly!

Food and atmosphere were perfect and would return for that reason. The service was friendly and kind, but fell far short of what I would’ve expected from a place of this price point. Felt like I was being served by someone with the same experience level as a high school student on their first day of their summer job.

Service was prompt and professional, food was of outstanding flavor and an extensive wine by the glass selection!

Came for our anniversary - wonderful food and great atmosphere!

Had a great meal taking advantage of the restaurant week promotion. The mussels were insanely good. Excellent ingredients and preparation throughout. The service was exceptional.

I had a memorable dining experience, the ambiance, the seating, the staff, the service and the food was top notch!!!

The service was very rushed and annoying. The ribs were terrible.

Restaurant week brought us here. The setting is wonderful with views overlooking the bay. The food and service were very good. I would definitely go again

Great water view, nice decor and welcoming. Food is good and service is excellent with great by the glass wine choices.

Good scene, the food and service was great, wine selection was also a plus!