choice of Gorgonzola cream sauce or northern Italian Bolognese (veal, pork, beef, lamb)
Pan Roasted Local Grouper
toasted gnocchi, pine nuts, mushrooms, key lime scallion butter
Maine lobster, littleneck clams, Key West pink shrimp, baby scallops, squid, mussels, local fish, spinach, sherry cream sauce
We started with the Goat cheese Souffle which was out of this world. My wife had the Lasagna which she thought was very good just too my=uch meat. I had the fish which was excellent. Service attentive but not overbearing. This is the third time we have been there this year. Each was memorable. Highly recommend.
Antonia’s remains our favorite restaurant in Key West as it has been since we first discovered it in 1986. There are others we love too but for fine Italian cooking, cozy and classy ambience, professional service and rock-solid reliability this is it. Not really for day trippers, Duval crawlers,spring breakers or cruise ship folks. They look in the door and go the other way.
Whenever we come to Key West we MUST eat at Antonia’s. It is one of our favorite restaurants and having been going there for. over 20 years! Food is always delicious and last night was no different. We love everything about it!
Forgot about how good the food is, the pork chop melted my heart. I will be dreaming about those flavors until I may enjoy them again! House made pasta, so fresh. Great wine list and excellent service. Do yourself a favor
Our fist time eating at Antonia's! Antonia's was recommended to us and we could not be more pleased with our experience. We had the calamari and the salmon special for the night. It was wonderful! I highly recommend asking for Robert or Fernando to be your server. Robert was spot on with his recommendation of the calamari and an absolute delight during our dining time. I've know Fernando for years and he is who recommended we eat there while in Key West. Absolutely Delicious!
Exceptional! Delicious homemade pasta (don't tell my Noni). Great Service, great location.
We come to Key West often. This is an overrated restaurant. The food is bland and unimaginative. The service is outstanding. The menu is tired and clearly based on food service products. I never say this: hard pass on Antonia’s. The decent ambiance and sold service do not make up for the blasé taste of the menu.
We ate at the bar against a wall facing crowd. Best seat in the house. TJ the bartender was excellent. Food great. Tables looked noisy. But we loved our time there!
This food was absolutely excellent. The ambience was so pleasant. The only thing was the tables were really squeezed in tight. So this made it a little difficult to have a private conversation.
Excellent, authentic Italian food and great wine selection. Would definitely go back!
Very pleasurable dining experience all around: service, food, ambience.
Long time favorite; still very nice room, well-trained staff, interesting food
Food was ok, not great. Very loud at times too. Not real warm service.
Our favorite place to celebrate a special ocassion... simply the best!
Great food service and atmosphere
We had the good fortune to visit this great restaurant on our last stop in Key West two years ago. It was superb then and was every bit as great this time. Wish we came to Key West more often so we could dine at Antonia’s frequently.
Allen’s service was outstanding. This complemented the great food and drinks.
From start to finish, Service and the meal was outstanding.
We had the lasagna and two diners had a rigatoni special, and all meals were very good. I am giving this restaurant 4 stars only though because the desserts were uninspired and just not great. Even really good restaurants fall down on dessert if no pastry chef is on hand, and I suspect Antonia’s does not have one. I had a brownie that was as ordinary as could be, and was not blessed with more than a teeny bit of ice cream, and three blueberries. My husband had a coconut pie that was just as ordinary, with just the merest bit of flavor. The desserts were disappointing, but the entrees were good.
Ran out of specials at 7 PM, server not at all helpful
Antonia's is always a must when we're in Key West. During our visit this time, Antonia's came out on top of all the restaurants. Service as excellent and food was nicely prepared and presented. A repeater!!
We came to Key West to enjoy the warmth and feel of this special southernmost part of the country. We were pleasantly surprised to fall upon Antonia’s Restaurant during our stay. It was a special find and we now have a favorite place to eat in Key West! Our server Allen made sure we were properly taken care of and it was obvious that he enjoyed his role at Antonia’s. See you next year.
Noisy, good food
Very upscale for Key West and lots of booth seating with warm, welcoming decor. Waiters and Chef are tops for service and cuisine. Best Escargot I've ever had; daily specials are innovative and delicious while their regular menu guarantees your return. Super polished professional waiter Dallon/team don't miss a beat.
Outstanding food and service. Try to get a table outside at sunset overseeing the pool. Could be a little warm but worth the view. Cooler inside and you can always take a short walk to the west for pics at sunset.
We ordered the salmon and the lamb. Both were very good. Service was great.
Great restaurant in Key West not renowned for fine dining.
Dinner was awesome!! We will return on our next time in town
Great place, great food, great ambience ! Would highly recommend this restaurant.
Food and Service were excellent, thank you!
This was our second time here. Food and service are great. Nice quiet place with old time hometown Italian restaurant look feel and food!
We had a simply fabulous meal with 6 . Everything was amazing !
The food was 5 star as was everything else. Comfortable and very pleasant ! Thanks for a great night !
Excellent food and attentive service in a central location in Old Town.
Middle of day, weekday - service uneven, but willingly done -
Very nice food there !
We were not pleased with this choice. The host seated us at a huge booth so large that four of us could not hear each other, despite there being a cozy four-top available nearby. We had a reservation so this did not make sense; no one else was waiting. When one of our group asked the waiter for a suggestion on wine, he gave him the $26 glass -- without indicating the price. We are not cheapskates -- in fact are happy to pay for quality -- but that is a bit higher than usual. He did the same "upselling" on main dishes. Not appreciated. The food was ok but not worth it. Nice ambiance.
Need more beer options. Food was delicious. Service was good. Tables are too close together.
With a host of other choices in Key West, not worth wasting time at Antonia's. The food is overrated. And the service was terrible. No need to elaborate. Try Azur or one to the other restaurants that are off the beaten path.
Excellent food. Large portions.
Antonia's offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (305) 294-6565.
Antonia's is rated 4.6 stars by 1098 OpenTable diners.
You can book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size.