1852 Grill Room

Our meal was great. It was the last night of dinner service for the season and it felt like they put as much effort in as you would expect in the beginning of the season.

This place left me underwhelmed. The food was average, but if it wasn't served to a captive audience with few higher end options, it wouldn't impress at all.

The location and view are beautiful. The wait service was literally awful. Waited 15 minutes to get water. Had to ask twice for a drink, was not offered. Extremely slow and unresponsive. The barstaff and front door people were really nice and polite.

The steak and potatoes were well cooked, and quite good. Asparagus was great. Bread was dry. For $160 total (with tip, no alcohol) I'd expect a higher quality experience. I don't recommend.

Best New England Clam Chowder I have ever had! My husband's steak was top-notch! Everything was delicious and our server was wonderful! We look forward to returning on our next visit to the island.

Food was great with nice sized portions. Jeffrey our server took very good care of us. The view over the bay was fantastic!

The food was wonderful. Portions are large so while some reviews indicated that it is pricey, plenty to share with a spouse so overall good value.

The service was incredible from getting sat to checking out. The shrimp was a tad over cooked for the appetizer and my husbands filet mignon tasted like Gas from the grill. It was kind of hard to get over that taste in the inside was undercooked and more like tartare when he ordered medium rare. I ordered the plank white fish and it was incredible.

Tomahawk Steak was fantastic. Our server, Charlie, was excellent.

We liked 1852 Grill so much we went twice while we were on the Island. Great service (Charlie), fantastic food and very nice ambiance. My husband got the Tomahawk steak both times. The salmon was cooked perfectly. Great wine selection too. Highly recommend.

The fish was fresh, and the portions were very nice size. The overall experience was delightful.

Wonderful dinner with a beautiful view of the harbor

Superb dining experience. Service was outstanding and our meals were delicious.

Great selection in the menu. All of the dishes coming out of the kitchen looked great!

We had a great table overlooking the water. Very nice server and wonderful prime rib and walleye. The onion soup seemed like it was made hours ahead and simply thrown in a broiler to heat up

Food was phenomenal and the service was impeccable. The decor could use a little work, found it distracting with all the bold designs and color. Otherwise amazing!

Great Fine Dining Establishment! Outstanding views of harbor!!

Delicious food and beautiful view. Service was great.

We went for our anniversary dinner and it was truly perfect. Beautiful view, amazing food and lovely music from the grand piano. We felt super fancy lol

Really wonderful prime rib, beet salad and key lime pie.
Service was top notch and we enjoyed our visit with John, the pianist, before we sat for dinner.

The best. Went there for breakfast Sunday morning. Wanted to have dinner too the night before but there was no availability. Excellent experience.

We always enjoy the food here; however, as I was eating the wedge salad, comprised of Bibb I declined.

Our waitress, Kayla, was very good ( personable however, we asked a bus boy for silverware with which to eat.

Food and service was spot on. View was beautiful too!

We were sat next to a big window with a stunning view. The cocktails we ordered were delightful. The wild mushroom risotto I ordered was absolutely delicious! My friend also loved her fish dinner. We dined earlier than we normally would due to availability, so when we first arrived there were only a couple other tables seated and our server was very attentive. However, as the restaurant got busier, our server was less attentive. We were not offered a second drink and our plates sat on our table for quite a while before they were cleared.

Great food, great everything! Beats the Grand THATS FOR SURE‼️

Service was outstanding! Lovely piano music added to the ambiance. The only negative was that the food, though delicious, was not as hot as it should have been. However, I would definitely try again.

Had a great experience here glad they had a lot of vegetarian options. And having some higher end veg options go a long way! Service was good and can’t beat the location..

Our waiter was courteous/attentive and the food was delicious. We enjoyed a lake view with piano music while dining.

Everything was wonderful. A bit pricey but great service and food.

The best dinner my wife & I ever had, and we're 70.

Great atmosphere but expensive

Best dinner on our vacation! Fabulous service, meal was perfection. Highly recommend it.

Great location and food was exceptional, only complaint was the service was not up the price point and the courses were delivered on top of each other. Hard to enjoy a bottle wine when your food is stacking up

The service was outstanding. The food, while generous portions, wasn’t what I would expect with a $50+ entree.

It was an enjoyable evening at a very upscale restaurant but, I doubt I’d go back.

We had the pleasure of dining at the 1852 Grill Room for breakfast and dinner. Both meals were outstanding, the service was excellent and the view was beautiful. While dining outside, the weather was absolutely perfect. I’m pretty sure the 1852 Grill Room didn’t order the weather, but it certainly added to the ambience! Very enjoyable stay.

My wife and I had a fantastic meal at the 1852 Grill Room. The food was great and staff friendly and enjoyable to talk to. We ate on the porch and the view of the grounds and harbor is outstanding. We would definitely return.

It was lovely but overpriced.

Beautiful setting, food and service was great. We loved our dinner. We had a window table - what a view!

Tried 1852 Grille Room again as they offered outside dining. Was a very nice night and food and service were good. My wife enjoyed the trout and I had the whitefish which was also good. Their bread was changed ... missing some of our favorites but probably due to season end. But a good dinner. Nice option on the island.

Best walleye I have ever had!

We enjoyed the greeting when we arrived. Our server was very good and kept us laughing. The food was Amazing as we had the steak for two! Wonderful service, great atmosphere and the pianist was great as well! We enjoyed our evening at the restaurant and will come back the next time we visit the island!

Everything we expected and more. Food was outstanding as was the serbice. We will be back.