Very happy to bring a guest to Wise Guys. Thanks
Everything was stellar- from the service to the food. A+++
Lovely atmosphere, nice specials and the meats and fish is very fresh and delicious.
Great service and the shrimp and calamari appetizer was delicious!
Wonderful dining experience! Staff was excellent and food was amazing! Will definitely return.
While the meal was very good, I was disappointed in the service and that even though I stated in my on-line reservation that it was my wife's birthday, no acknowledgement was made to her. I checked with them before we left and they confirmed that it had been noted in their records and that usually a card is left at the table. In addition, we ordered a very expensive bottle of Caymus wine and except for the initial pour, our waiter did not offer to pour a glass of wine, something fine dining restaurants usually do. I know it was a busy night, but it isn't a fast food restaurant!
I thought the food was great. Ordered from the early dining menu and cannot believe the amount of food you get for the price, excellent value, great service, great food, what's not to like?
This was our second time at Wiseguys and a huge drop off from our first experience. The porterhouse for two while cooked properly was full of fat and gristle and half of it was not edible and could not be successfully navigated with sharp steak knives. Also had sickness the following morning which the likely suspect was something in the Caesar salad. Very disappointing as we had a great experience here the first time. Service was good, but the meal was not.
We read good reviews. We booked the special which offers entrees and salads for 18 per person. Also offers wines at 5 a glass. When we arrived we were greeted by all the staff and manager. Seated in the back at a great table with Sam...one of the best servers.
You might think you would get less than exciting choices for the special. Not so. Dishes were smaller portions but absolutely great food.
The table splurged on a dessert flight of crime brûlée. Wow.
We loved it so much we made another reservation for the next day for dinner.
By far my favorite restaurant on HHI. Food is exceptional and service is great. They offer great small plate menu giving you opportunity to experience different dishes. Best calamari ever!
Our first time at Wise Guys. Great steaks and seafood! Waiter was efficient but not smothering. Only dislike was that the 2 top was too small and when we asked for (and got) a 4 top, the receptionist was visibly unhappy. We observed several open 4 seat tables for the time we were there. We definitely will go back, but will request preferred seating in reservation.
Very good Service & meals. My wife had a New York Strip that was very tender and very flavorful.
Great food with wide selection and great service specifically Sam
We tried a lot of the menu, from several apps to several steaks, we didn't send anything back but it was an unrewarding meal for all. I expected the steak and lamb to be decent at least but that is not how things turned out. A real disappointment.
So sorry I didn’t find out about this hidden gem when I first arrived in HH- definitely worth a repeat. There is nothing not to like- and something for every taste- big plates, small plates , everything is delicious
Great food, excellent service.....ask to be seated at Sam's table...a great waiter.
Loved the Cabernet wine flight- it was three great wines.
We seemed to be a bit of an after thought in deciding to sit outside.
Server wanted us to order early so "order would be in and she would not forget"
Food was okay. Not great.
Might try another place next time.
Foos was great and service was outstanding. Our waitress was attentive without being obtrusive.
Having been several times in past years, we introduced some friends to the restaurant. They were very impressed with food service and atmosphere. We will no doubt be back again before we leave the island.
The Stone Crabs were not good had all the appearance of having been frozen and had very little taste. The steaks were average not what we were hoping for.
My new husband & I were visiting Hilton Head & found Wise Guys on Open Table. Great place! We enjoyed the She-crab soup (nice sherry flavor although a bit salty), shrimp & grits (delicious!), & the ribeye which was awesome. Tables were so close that we became "close" friends with a couple from Boston. Server Sam was outstanding.
Wise guys was a pleasant surprise, great food. Staff very accommodating and friendly.
Hadn't been here in several years. Was disappointed. Had good wine choices. My husband was very disappointed in his new york strip. The brie appetizer was also disappointing. They were very busy, guess it was just me.
We went with friends during the Early Bird Special. They offered soup or salad plus an entree for $18. A glass of wine was $5. The portions were reasonable. Quality of the food was excellent! Our waitress was bubbly and efficient! Overall, an excellent experience! We will definitely go there the next time we are on Hilton Head Island.
It was very busy. After waiting for 20 minutes for our reservation, we were seated in the bar. Because it was so busy the service was rather slow.
Our waiter, Sam, made our dining experience exceptional. He was very attentive, friendly and waited on us like there were no other tables in the restaurant. The food was great!!!
All steak options are excellent. Wait staff was very attentive
Outstanding place to eat. Sam our waiter was excellent. The total evening was enhanced by the waiters service. Have to eat there more often.
Manager is very accommodating.
We had an excellent meal and Danny was a wonderful waiter. My husband was thrilled because they had a very extensive bourbon listing. It was a bit noisy but we were still able to carry on a conversation.
We really enjoyed Wise Guys. The menu was varied enough to suit any taste and our selections were quite well-prepared. I had an excellent surf and turf specials. My wife had the risotto with scallops. We would order them again. Our server and those who assisted her did an outstanding job. The only thing that prevents me giving 5 stars was the noise level. Conversation at our table was sometimes difficult. There were two fairly large groups who were interacting with each other -- quite loudly at times. That may have been the only reason for the noise level. If so, nothing the restaurant could have done. We will definitely return.
Excellent value for the Early Bird. Regular menu options were tasty, too. Wait staff likes to push additional dishes but they are just doing their jobs. Seating is very comfortable.
We keep coming back each year. The food and the service is excellent.
We had the salmon dinner and the special of surf and turf. The salmon was dry and completely burnt on the outside. The surf and turf consisted of a steak with onions and mushrooms and some shrimp with a cream sauce. The steak was good, but the onions and mushrooms over powered the steak. The shrimp came with a cream sauce which was very salty and made the shrimp almost uneatable. The restaurant seems to be frequented by elderly patrons for the most part , so I am assuming that the spicing reflects that constituency.
I had a 845 p.m. reservation and showed up at 8 and waa seated right away. The server was very polite, attentive and knowlegable. The food came out extremely fast, especially given how busy they were. The food was outstanding and i plan to come back whenever I'm in the area.
Reservations for 3. We were seated right away at a table set for 3 & it was a busy night. Thank you. Great service. All 3 ordered steaks. Perfectly done. Nice atmosphere. Plan on dinner there next time we are in Hilton Head.
Great restaurant with excellent service and friendliness. Menu is hard to beat with great specials from the chef. Apps are good, wine and beverages are good as well.
It's the first time we were there for Early Dining. Very good food, very good value.
We had a wonderful birthday celebration at WiseGuys this week. Service and food was excellent. We will definitely return on our next visit!
As always, our Friday night group of 4 ladies had a perfectly lovely time. The staff makes us feel very special and the food is very good.