It was so nice and romantic for my spouse and I! Fast service, amazing food, and just a good atmosphere to be in!
We were there for valentine's day.great service good atmosphere is nice.the steak was disappointing. It was grossly I mean not that tastey.more fat then meat.for $39 way to much for a sirloin with the bone in..didn't want complain. It was a special occasion. We were the 1st there that should hav been ck....
We have eaten at this restaurant before and were not disappointed on our return visit. The service was great, the food delicious and the atmosphere relaxing. I highly recommend this restaurant to anyone looking for a drink at the bar, a nice dinner, or a party for a larger group.
Food and service were excellent as always....I make a special trip to What if when I'm in town
Dinner was excellent as always--good for special occasions. If the restaurant is busy a little noisy. Wait staff is very good.
Very loud table behind us that ruined our evening. Food was good, service was very slow.
This was our firs time there and all the workers were very polite . The bartender actually introduced herself to us since it was our first time and made us feel welcome. Our server was amazing. Very friendly and polite. Will definitely be back and tell people about What If.
Reviews indicated this was a great place and it did not disappoint.
Nice semi-private booths and tables. Outstanding food! Outstanding service!
The food was excellent. Server was very friendly and attentive by checking with us. Booked reservations on line, very easy and able to see hours available. Very good experience, enjoyed our evening. Desert was very good.
This is our annual anniversary “restaurant of choice”. Great food, quiet setting, good service and a good value. Consistently recommend this place to folks who want an elegant meal for a fair price.
Fun place to meet friends for dinner, expansive menu (food and drink), and friendly service.
cozy place. Good food.
Food was excellent; however, service was extremely slow. It took about an hour to receive our salads. Total meal time was two hours for a table of four.
Another great meal at What If. We were only disappointed that the profiterole du jour was s not the peanut butter signature selection. Our server, Bethany, was very attentive and personable. The Sirius 70s station playing was a bit awkward and out of place. We always enjoy What If.
The service on NYE was a little slow, but friendly. My daughters dinner portion of shrimp scampi was extremely small and too “lemony”. The crab cakes were delicious.
Went NEw YEars Eve! The rooms looked festive , warm and inviting. Our waitress was great and the food was great as well. Was a really nice night. It was the first time we were there and I was a little skeptical going into the Howard Johnsons but the place was a great surprise!
Thanks for a really nice night!
The service was outstanding. Great job, Bri! One of my group left their phone behind, and we had a call from the restaurant about the phone before we got home.
Another great visit to What If... we come each year when we visit Hershey... a true hidden gem
Service was slow. We were there nearly two hours. Food was ok. Bread was cold. Soup was lukewarm. Appetizers and entrees were cooked well, but a bit on the bland side. More bold flavors, please!