Great service by an attentive waiter. Bacon slab appetizer was amazing. Steak was cooked perfectly!
Wonderful server. Wade was awesome!! Love to come back . Made my first time in New York great
Very positive causal experience The food was perfectly prepared, generous and tasty
Especially good service. Really good meals!
There was nothing wrong with the food. Anyway the service was sort of halfhearted.
Great steak and a very good waiter with the right focus and not too busy, very relaxing and a great atmosphere.
I have been taking my better clients here for the past two years during shows at the Javit's center and they all have been more than impressed.
Great Evening our waiter made the evening awesome great service.
The food was out of this world! The filet was cooked perfectly and super super tender. The wine, salad, steak and dessert, along with the service was just fabulous. Worth every penny and when we come back to NYC we will make sure we come back. Will recommend to everyone!!!
Excellent as always. I used to go to Peter Lugers once a month but find the West Side Steak House much closer, less expensive, cozier, and just as good with much prettier servers.
Our steak (POORTER HOUSE FOR TWO) was fantastic. Cooked perfectly and cut was nice and thick.
It is a very nice place to have an enjoyable steak dinner, without all the pretentiousness of the big name places. Friendly staff and low key atmosphere make it worth a visit if you want a pre theater meal without all the noise.
Amazing steak and sides , excellent value friendly staff !
Food and service were very good. Would prefer small upgrade in Pinot Noir selections- add California sourced from Sonoma, Monterey or Santa Lucia Highlands-otherwise, will return!
The food was good but what made it was the amazing staff.
Amazing food (steak was spectacular), great service, this was simply the best choice for our valentines meal.
It wasn't terrible but I ordered steak medium rare. It came just shy of well done. Two others with steak also found it done to a far greater degree than ordered. No. We didn't send it back. We didn't want to wait to start over. But at a steak house they should be able to get the steak right. No one asked us if we were satisfied with the way it was prepared. The side veg was good. The service was OK. I don't go to restaurants to make friends but it is nice if they seem happy you showed up. Server also was just adequate. We did not feel she particularly cared. We were taking friends from out of town so I had hoped for more.
Loved the owner, Nick! He serenaded us with Derp in the Heart of Texas. Food was delicious and the service was great. Quaint and cozy!
This was my first time dining at WSS after a tiring google search for a steakhouse in nyc. The menu and its comfortable prices caught my eye. A Porterhouse for 2 under 100 bucks is PHENOMENAL. I was blown away. The meat was wonderfully prepared and packed all the flavor its supposed to. From the sides to the service everything was stellar. The atmosphere was cozy qnd had a warm feeling that was very inviting. Creamed spinach was to die for. And dont let me get started on their out of this world wrapped scallops. 👍👍
This is a wonderful place to go if you're seeing anything at the Signature Theater center on 42nd Street. The porterhouse for two is outstanding, the first courses are exactly as expected, and the service is intelligent, personable and unhurried.
Excellent, excellent food and service. We arrived 5pm there weren’t too many people, the place was quiet and comfy. We ordered the T-bone with asparagus which was on par with the top-notch restaurants in the city, definitely will become one of our favorite places
I used to live across the street from the West Side Steakhouse and ate there often for lunch and dinner. Great hamburgers, great fries, great steaks, great fish (especially Chilean Sea Bass and Salmon) and great lamb chops. Comfortable, clean, nice ambiance and super nice original owners (Nick and Ilina). Close to Times Square but without the Times Square crowds. Although I live in Florida now, I visit the steakhouse whenever I go to NYC (like I did last week when I was there for BroadwayCon).
We ran into this place as it was close to the hotel. Awesome Italian with New York flair!
NYC local who was looking for a steakhouse reservation on short notice that wouldn't be loaded with bankers or tourists. Don't let the fact that it doesn't have a stodgy steakhouse vibe fool you here... All the food, wine, and service was exceptional! Great cuts of meat served at a textbook-level example of the proper temperature preparation. Sides were also very good. Well done! (Bad pun intended)
This place was amazing Best steak I have ever eaten
Had a reservation for 7:30 after cold day sight-seeing. Decided to try moving time to an hour earlier and were quickly accommodated. Food was great!
Been there several times-always great service and food. Not loud, lighting level is comfortably low. Also my vegan sister liked it too, even though it's a steak house.
Bacon was sooooooo good
Took my husband on a whim for lunch on his birthday. I'd walked past the restaurant many times, and always thought it looked inviting. Dark wood, white table cloths, small but what looked like a well stocked bar. Nice wine list. Menu had several inviting options. Excellent service by Wade. Spoke to the owner on our way out, and complimented him on his little jewel. If you want a nice meal in a comfortable setting this is the place. Prices for Manhattan are reasonable. I look forward to going back. Oh - the lava cake is amazing, thanks to Wade for the birthday dessert!
Good place. The food was very good quality.
Reasonable prices. The steak and burger was well worth a go to. Slab bacon worth being a entree. Good out of the way. Good local place.
Eve though it was very cold (i guess that being near the window wasn’t the best idea :-) ) the food and the service were great.
I recommend it!
Really enjoyed our meal. The steaks were perfectly done. The mushroom soup was wonderful. The vegetables were excellent. And Wade, our waiter, was great!
We had travelled to New York for Chritmas and this is where we had our Christmas meal. The staff were fantastic, our table was ready within a minute of our arrival, the food was amazing. This is definitely a restaurant that you should put on your list to eat at.
The service was very good, the food excellent, wine-list very various
Nick is the perfect host.
Excellent. Never a bad meal.
From the moment we arrived the atmosphere was fantastic. The service was prompt the food options were decent and we loved the creme brûlée
What a great place. Very cozy and the steak was one of the best I have ever had. Service was great. Highly recommended
its a cozy small place, the calamari was REALLY good , and the waiter service was decent...
don't go for a birthday dinner if you expect them to sing or anything because they just kinda place it infront if them with a candle and walk away...
otherwise I would probably go back..maybe..not a bad place, it did get loud when a group came in and sat by the bar though which was sort of annoying
Great meal. NYC steak house experience for out of town guests.