Vintage Prime Steakhouse
served sliced & sizzling
sweet & spicy + baby greens + ginger dressing
It was by far the best tomahawk steak I have ever had. It was worth every penny. The waiter was courteous and thoughtful in how he engaged with us. Definitely will be returning for many more special occasions
Carlos our waiter was great as was the food great experience
Food and service was excellent
Delicious food. Excellent service.
Wonderful night out celebrating our anniversary . Great food, service and atmosphere.
Always an amazing meal at Vintage! The quality and taste of the food exceeds all expectations each time we go. The appetizers are always on point. This time we opted for the seared ahi tuna and thai calamari. The calamari is always outstanding and the tuna was seared to perfection and served with a duo of wasabi and sweet soy sauce. I could have made a meal of the tuna. But you don't come for the tuna, you come for the steak! My husband always gets the cowboy rib eye and leaves the plate empty except for the bone! I opted for the filet which was cooked to perfection. The accompanying bearnaise was delicious too. Our sides were parmesan truffle fries which were crispy and delectable, and the sauteed onions and hot cherry peppers. The cherry peppers were super spicy but went with our steaks and cut the richness of the fries. Of course there was no room for dessert but because it was our anniversary we were offered a slice of cheesecake which we took to go. Had great martini's with our appetizers and I had a glass of house cabernet sauvignon with my filet. All in all an amazing meal. If I had to make one complaint it would be that we waited longer than expected for our martini's. Can't wait to go back!!
Excellent all around. The food, service and manager were perfect unfortunately I don't live near St James. I highly recommend this restaurant
Truly outstanding experience. Can't say enough. Service was amazing, the meal was one of the best we've had in a long time..
Outstanding!! Our waiter was Carlos and he was on point!! Food was amazing. Best steak I ever had. We started with the watermelon salad special, then porterhouse steak for 2 with corn, mashed potato, onions and mushrooms. Everything was so good!! Dessert we had cheesecake and pecan pie wow!! We frequent Insignia and this place we better value and the quality of food blows them away. Service was above and beyond!!
I’m not from Long Island came out to take my mom for her birthday. Not expecting much from past restaurant Experiences in Suffolk county with that said if you don’t try this place you’re making a big mistake steak house prices so going in you know it’s not cheap but you will leave totally satisfied everything from Carlos our server to the drinks appetizers and porterhouse for two just top notch I have to say I think they put Lugers to shame! Can’t wait to visit again !
The service was excellent. Mario was our waiter and took care of us every step of the way. The food was terrific, and everything was perfect. I definitely recommend this place 100%
Delicious and great serv
Our steak was over cooked (asked for medium rare and it was medium well) and the waiter did not check on us to refill drinks. The lobster Mac and cheese had very minimal amounts of lobster. It just wasn’t that good to justify the high price. This was our 2nd visit. We came back because our first time was pretty good. For such an expensive place we really expected the experience to be better. I don’t think we will return.
Everything was excellent especially the calamari it was delicious
This is our go to steak restaurant on Long Island. Amazing steaks, great drinks and great service. You won’t be disappointed if you decide to dine here.
I enjoy this restaurant food quality id high and service is always excellent.
It was just ok. Prices have gone up but nothing changes. Quality was good but ambiance is bland. Will look elsewhere for future special occasions.
Great night, great food with great friends!
Mario our waiter was great. Food was excellent !!! Would definitely go back!!
Been a guest for years but was shocked at how we were treated this time. Sat as a family next to an obnoxious, large group of men using foul Language among other gestures while my 8 year daughter and wife were forced to listen. The place was not crowded at all. Disappointing to say the least.
Wonderful experience. Always consistently excellent!
Dined in a nice covered outdoor patio. Area. Staff professional, helpful and friendly.
Lump crab meat cocktail was fresh, delicious and a nice portion and easily shared with my wife.
We ordered the porterhouse for two. Perfectly prepared, one of the the best we’ve had. A side of sautéed mushrooms was outstanding and we finished the meal with creamy gelato.
We will certainly be back soon.
Awesome food and atmosphere.
Another outstanding dinner at our favorite steakhouse! Nicely done! Thank you.
Amazing food and service!!! Everything we ate was delicious!!
The food and steaks are always the best quality in the most tender. The manager, John is the best, professional and friendly. The wait staff is the best.
We would highly recommend this restaurant to anyone who loves steaks and or just a good restaurant
The meal and service was outstanding as usual. Vintage Prime is a consistently great dining experience.
Carlos our waiter, as always was amazing!!!
There was no wait which was a bonus since it was raining out. The table was in a good location, the waiter was pleasant and efficient and the food was as expected, delicious and plentiful! We've been there before and will be back!
I have been here so many times and usually live it. The last two times not so much and after my recent visit, I do t think I will be going back.
Ordered Maine lobster tails and they gave me some other spotted and slightly smelly lobster. It really ruined the meal and I should have sent them back. Salad was great and crabcakes were pretty good.
Excellent service....the best Tomahawk for two ever! Highly recommend....it is a bit loud indoors, but worth it! Definitely a neighborhood gem!
Great food and awesome service highly recommend vintage for dinner
Incredible food and great service
My only complaint.....My waiter came to take our order right away for drinks and somehow forgot about us afterwards I had to grab a different waiter for my food order. The food came quickly and service picked up again. Overall the food was amazing. We had the Calamari as an appetizer, they were nice and tender and the flavor was good. I ordered two appetizers as my main entrée: The French onion soup (so big and cheesy) and the lamb chops. The lamb chops were served over a salad with tzatziki sauce on the side. My husband ordered the cowboy rib eye which was cooked to a perfect medium rare, melt in your mouth deliciousness, with a side of creamed spinach. To end the night we had the bananas foster, where they came to sing happy birthday. Can't wait to go again, maybe try the Porter house for two next time.
Best steak ever. Reasonable service but could have been a bit better. Had to ask for salt and pepper as well as a butter knife. It's expensive but would go again for a special occasion.
Always fantastic service , best waiters around. I’ve been eating there for many years and food and service are always first rate. In my last visit, an obnoxious group of 4 guys came in, got loud and were dropping constant f bombs. They were seated close to two couples enjoying romantic dinners. The manager noticed immediately and politely shut it down. Was promptly and skillfully handled.
It is a place you can can have a quiet dinner but also one a larger party can have a good time and even get noisy (if not obnoxious). The point is they are attentive and manage the situation, they don’t just let it all go like so many lesser restaurants.
Noise level was unbearably loud inside - a large group of ladies were loud, laughing and screaming; it made it impossible for other patrons to talk. We asked, and were relocated to an outside table where the noise level was very comfortable. Maitre'd and staff were super accommodating. Following that, we had an absolutely superb dinner! Possibly the best steak we've ever had! It was all absolutely delicious. Aside from the perfectly cooked steaks, the calamari and creme brulee will ensure we return!
Vintage Prime Steakhouse is rated 4.8 stars by 1200 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.