After presenting and personally visiting the restaurant we were very disappointed in their willingness to keep our party together. I even expressed that I'd go to another restaurant if they could not accommodate seating us in proximity where we could be together. The management were not willing to co operate on the day of our dinner and refused to accommodate, with any suggestions, including letting us have a table for which another party more than half hour late had as yet not shown up. It ruined the whole purpose for us to get together, especially, as we all rarely can get together . I will strongly recommend not to go to this restaurant if your party is larger than 6.
I would come back to this restaurant weekly if I lived closed. We had the cheese and meat mix for an appetizer shared for 5. It was okay, not the best I ever had. The wedding soup, mussels and the Caesar Salad was very very good. One of the nice things about this restaurant is you can get lots of dishes in small plates. Now for the main course the Veal Saltimbocca was great, Veal and Eggplant Parmesan was raved about. The Linguine Balinese had spinach linguine that was homemade pasta. It was the best I have eaten. They have great bread and lots of pasta are made in house. We had no room for desert.
Victor’s is our favorite restaurant in York. Food is delicious, service is amazing as well as the atmosphere. Highly recommend.
Best meal ever! We treat ourselves every couple months to a meal at Victor’s and are never disappointed. Had a Rockfish special with cannelloni beans and kale and it was one of the best meals I’ve had anywhere! Great bar and great service too.
The evening was delightful. Service was wonderful, the atmosphere was warm and welcoming and the food grand.
They also have a nice selection of beer, wine and liquor. I definitely recommend Victor’s Italian Restaurant.
We had dinner with two other couples. No one raved about their meal. My Kale salad was good, as was the Cresta de Gallo pasta dish. The Halibut and Salmon entries were over cooked for at least three of us. The risotto that came with the Halibut was the typical restaurant version, which I've come to expect, overcooked and over-creamed. The wine pours that came with the PREZZO FISSO Chef’s Italian Table selections were about 2/3 what I would expect in volume. Overall, not a good food experience, especially for the money. The service was good, not spectacular, and the dining room was quite noisy. That said, the restaurant was full on a Saturday night, so our experience may have been an exception.
Very busy on a Friday night. We had a 645 reservation but had to wait about 15 minutes for a table. We waited in the bar and it was quite comfortable. When we were seated we received good service and the gnocchi was excellent.
Halibut was tasty but the risotto and carrots were cold. I enjoyed the veal parm.
Always great food and service. Get a reservation because of the popularity.
I'm extremely satisfied with Victor's as my selection for this special evening. I will definitely darken their entrance again, and again. Thank you Victor's for showing me a fabulous time.
Great food, atmosphere and parking.
This is a fantastic restaurant! I took my girlfriend here for Valentine's Day. She had never been here previously and absolutely loved the place! The wine list is superb, the service is top notch and the food is phenomenal! We will definitely be going back.
In spite of it being Valentine Day - with all of the possible craziness that might mean - every aspect of our dining experience was efficient, cordial and delicious.
There was a special menu for Valentine’s Day and it was outstanding. Our service was excellent and we did not feel rushed despite having an early seating. Well done!
Great lunch, will return again.
The dinner I ordered “Chicken and Rustic Vegetables” was not what I received. On the menu the dinner was described as Chicken with turmeric and lemon rind served with rustic vegetables and olives. I asked the server what was meant by rustic vegetable. He said Carrots, celery, onions, “soup like veggies.” This sounded good to me. I ordered it. What I received was chicken (well seasoned!) BUT on top of sliced (unseasoned plain) white potatoes lying in a lot of grease. There were 2 carrots on the plate, a lemon wedge, a few sliced olives, and no other vegetables. This was not a good meal at all. Do not order this. Our salads were forgotten. They were delivered after the main courses arrived. My husbands filet was under seasoned and not cooked to the ordered temperature. We were very disappointed in this meal.
Always good and consistent. Servers are all personable and remember you and the veal Saltimbocca is awesome. Top off the meal with a tartufo...
Great food and excellent service. Tough combination to beat!
Valentines/Anniversary dinner. Great food, nice menu, great service!! We felt well cared for.
We had a nice dinner with friends; however, one guest's meal arrived cold. Needless to say, we were disappointed with that but the host addressed the problem swiftly. It's worth a second try.
Decided to go to dinner after the movies on "date night". The service was EXCELLENT and the food was great. The smaller available portions were just right for a late night dinner (especially with a good wine).
Will definitely be returning with my date of 28 years...
The waitstaff are well informed and friendly. They take time to explain and discuss menu and drink options. Food is always delicious and the chef is inventive. Recommend anything on the menu. Noise level can be high at times depending on customers.
A reliable and steady performer with interesting menu specials and a very good beet salad that can work as an entree. Tight seating makes the place cozy but not so that everyone is in your business.
A worthy alternative to the mid-price menu scene.
Very disappointed . Pasta was overcook.
Just was not worth the trip .
Service and food fantastic. House red wine was excellent. Will definitely come back next time I am in York, PA.
We meet old friends at Victors as it is a halfway point for all. Sat in bar watching Eagles, staff so helpful and friendly. Transition to dining room seamless where we hav a lovely long meal. We closed to restaurant but there was never pressure to finish. Food excellent had the most flavorful and tender pork chop ever. Portions generous, nicely plated. Nice wine and beer lists. We will definitely return.
great prix fix deal, allowing our group of four to taste more of the menu during our first meal there.
cocktails hit the mark
salads were well, dine and we all noticed rhe properly chilled plates
pasta were a hit! cresta de gallo won over the table, with the orzo being a revelation as well.
for secundi, the sicilian chicken was the surprise victor. perfection.
wine list was well balanced, our pinot noir was another surprise, in the best of ways
can’t wait for another reason to visit
Fun Friday Night! Enjoyed dinners, sandwiches, etc.
Dinner was fantastic as was our waitress. Loved the rosemary bourbon cocktail. Thank you
My wife and I love Victor's, which is about 35 minutes from our home. It's our favorite restaurant. We visited most recently on my wife's birthday. The Victor's cosmo is my wife's favorite alcoholic drink. She loved her beet salad and I enjoyed the Caesar salad, which is one of the best in the area. My wife was a bit disappointed with the sweet potato gnocchi, thinking it had too much oil. My veal parmesan was excellent. We both enjoyed the chocolate lava cake for dessert. The service was outstanding, as usual. The server even offered to have the gnocchi redone, which was not necessary. We will return to Victor's in the near future.
As soon as my wife and I entered it took 5 mins for us to be recognized as being there and it was by the manager who was extremely rude and simply looked at us and walked away. When we gave up waiting we said we would just sit at the bar and then they were immediately friendly. Our server was phenomenal and beyond helpful and nice. The price for what you got was high and wine was nearly $10 a glass. No one said anything to us when we finished our meal and left. Very disappointing and won’t return.
Terriable dinner. The waitress didn’t know anything about wines. She grab are plate off table even before we were finish eatting. I still had my fork in my hand when she grab my salad from the table and I wasn’t even done. The brushatie was way to spices with pepper. Than they steak we ordered the black pepper was why over powering it was so hot it made eatting steak difficult. Our friends order the veal and said it was Blane and terriable. To small of room for that many tables. Very loud. And waitress didn’t even offer us additional drinks. Very bad exsoerance.
The lobster bisque was amazing! (So was everything else we ordered; we need to visit Victor's more often!)
Always a pleasure to dine here for brunch, lunch or dinner. Personal favorites include sautéed mushrooms and stuffed mushroom appetizers Veal entrees are delicious ! The menu includes a variety of pasta dishes and seafood. I’ve never been disappointed in the food here
Victor's never disappoints. The food was on point and the wine pairings were awesome!
Good food and service.
We had tickets to the theater. Our waitress did an excellent job serving our party of 7 and had us out the door on time to make the show.
Best Italian food I have personally had in York, a little on the pricey side but overall decent food.
We always enjoy this restaurant.Alway very good food