Tuscarora Mill

Food was excellent albeit portions were a little small for prices. Service was excellent however. Will definitely go back just not as often as we would like.

I booked this dinner for a beautiful night out and to propose to my girlfriend (she said YES!). Once I booked it, I messaged the restaurant to discuss my intentions.

Colin did an absolutely great job of explaining what he can offer and asking what I want and how I want it to go. Upon arrival, we were seated without the slightest hint that it was preplanned. Our table was prepared beautifully, and I immediately knew that they had done all that I had requested.

The dinner was incredible, the proposal went without a hitch, and the server promptly brought out celebratory drinks and dessert menus. It was a beautiful evening, and the service in the restaurant was off the charts. We will definitely be back…a lot!

Food was fine. For appetizer, oysters were good, fried green tomatoes were not as freshly made, seemed to have just been reheated. For entree - fish was a bit over cooked, not soft and flakey. Prime steak was good. Dessert was okay, not very creative.

Service was outstanding. Food was good, but we didn’t realize the Valentines menu was the Only thing available so we were a little disappointed in the entree choices. (The Valentines menu was not yet posted when we made the reservation and when we looked at it later, it didn’t say it was an exclusive offering)
Appetizers and dessert were very good.

Valentines dinner and happy anniversary

My wife had the House meatloaf lunch, which was a good value for $12.00, I had the house salad which was tasty a good value and seafood entree, which was tasty but overpriced for the amount of food My wife had a half glass of wine, I had a full glass, but both were significantly less than most of the restaurants we frequent. It took over 45 minutes for the entree’s to arrive at our table. Somewhat disappointed because this is one of our favorite restaurants.

Service was great-- waiter was SO knowledgeable about all the dishes. Delicious ciabatta bread while we waited... The main dishes were outstanding! I had a flank steak and my husband had rabbit. The whipped potatoes were to die for! For dessert we had maple crème brûlée. Beyond delicious. Wonderful experience!!!

Wonderful meal and exceptional service. Started with a very light and fresh salad topped with seafood. Had the lamb shank which was divine. Top notch waitress, definitely a great choice for a special night out.

Must go! The food, service and ambiance were all excellent!

We've visited Tuscarora Mill before, and enjoyed it. However, this time each of our meals wasn't as good as we'd had previously. Not sure if the ingredients in the recipes changed, or just the method of cooking changed, but something was just off with each meal. The julliened vegetables served alongside the pumpkin ravioli was especially bad (none of us could finish them). The fried green tomatoe appetizer was good, but needed salt. Unfortunately, it'll be some time before we revisit Tuskies.

It was a lovely evening with friends. Didn’t have to scramat each other. The food was very good. Megan, was an excellent server, knowledgeable and friendly.

Brunch buffet was spectacular!
Great selection of items, well presented and bursting with flavors.
Special shout out to the Chef for fresh vegetable prepared a perfect al dente.
Enjoyed some starters from the Lunch menu as well....all solidly executed. We will be back.

Very attentive and friendly service. Made very thoughtful recognition of special event.

It’s not that close to my home, so I usually come for my birthday and usually for the Sunday brunch buffet.

Hosted our get together for the 6th year. Everything was great as usual. Service was wonderful, food was great.

We had a family outing with 8 people. Everyone loved it and would highly recommend it to anyone. In our party we had 4 grandparents and 2 teenagers and 2 parents. Everyone got what they wanted and were highly satisfied. Very enjoyable conversation, great staff and delicious food.

Portions small.

Mark our waiter was fantastic. Give him a raise - now!

Always a hit. Crowded the afternoon we went so the noise level was higher than usual.

Great place, excellent food and service to match.

We have dined at this establishment numerous times and have enjoyed it. The food is excellent. The only issue was our seating. It was very noisy and the chairs in the booth were loose and kept rocking back and forth. The service was excellent as it always is and the server was very attentive

Great food and Great service...as always!! Highly recommend

As always, great food, wonderful service in a truly beautiful establishment!

One of Leesburg's outstanding places to wine and dine.

The food was great. I am a vegetarian and was pleased that there were several things on the menu for me to pick from. I also enjoyed the fact that I could hear the conversation at our table. So many places these days you can’t hear anything as it is so loud. And our waiter was very attentive. Great dining experience!

The atmosphere was wonderful and the food absolutely delicious. We enjoyed our date night and would definitely recommend to anyone!

A very nice place to spend several hours talking with family and friends while eating great food.

It was a little too loud in back room. Food was excellent and so was service

We chose this place for a much needed date night, and were not disappointed. Very cozy, amazing service, and the food was delicious. Will definitely be back.

Very good as always.

Competent. Personable. Professional. Our Server Pete was awesome and excellent.

We come to Tuskie's a lot and enjoy it more each time. Perfect!

We had not been at the Tuscarora Mill for several years and were happy to see it was still alive and well, serving the good food we remembered from past visits. The lunch menu has so many nice choices we all had a hard time making a decision. Everything was tasty, especially the signature corn chowder and the delicious squash soup. The gentlemen enjoyed the reuben sandwiches which were highly recommended by the waitress. We saw in the fireplace room which was perfect on a cold sunny day!

Pastrami Ruben was wonderful. Served piled high on marble rye with just the right amount of kraut. Fried green tomatoes were a nice starter.

We always enjoy eating at Tuscarora Mill. Been going there since it opened. Brunch, birthdays and special occasions. Waitstaff has always been just great and it's nice to see lots of them have been there for years.
Love the bar in the late afternoon. Always nice friendly bartenders and guests.

Really interesting building that shows a great history, wonderful service and food!!

Just not right when you're charged more on your receipt than the price is on the menu - over 10% more.
For example the braised lamb was $36 on the menu and the receipt said $40 - with no comment by the server.

We were waiting so long we thought our waitress forgot about us before we ordered and after we ordered. Paid over $30 for an overcooked buffalo steak and we waited so long for it I didn't send it back because I was hungry and afraid of how long I'd have to wait. My friend's steak was undercooked. We most likely will try a different restaurant the next time we go out and its unlikely we will go back.

My steak salad was fantastic, sweetest server and adorable ambiance. Was perfect for our ladies lunch out.

We had a lovely dinner at Tuscarora Mill for our 25th anniversary. Food was excellent and the service was perfect.