Trophy Room at Old Kinderhook
Was very surprised to have such a high quality food and service for the area. Manager came and checked on us too if we were satisfied with food and service . Definitely 5 out of 5 . Also great wine selection ❤️❤️❤️
Only table in the dining room, waitress was impatient to get our dinner order in and then never returned to refill the drinks.
Great NYE dinner menu! Choices were great and good value with the price. Service was outstanding.
Had a great dinner and great waitress! Highly recommend!
Our server, Asia, was amazing! Everyone was very accommodating!
Christina is our favorite server, she is just so friendly and always smiling. We usually ask to sit in her section. She is the best. Food was delish too. We love to celebrate special occasions at the Trophy Room.
The Trophy Room is a great place to have dinner. Food is always amazing and the service is great!
We were in a very elegant restaurant and as a party was leaving, girls started shouting for another person’s name. Other than that everything was awesome! Thank you. Mia is a very nice and good server.
The Trophy Room is always a fun place at Christmas time as you can overlook the ice skating rink and the fire pits are going. Such a cozy holiday atmosphere 🎄♥️
Great food! Ambiance inside is wonderful! Windows overlooking golf course and skating rink the best anywhere at Lake.
Terrific staff, great feel as soon as you walk through the door. Food is really good!
We have eaten Thanksgiving dinner here several times in the past and the experience was very satisfying. This is first time since Covid that we have eaten at Kinderhook. Turkey was dry and breast meat only. The rolls were stale and crunchy The deserts were lackluster. The service was outstanding as usual.
We have done Thanksgiving at Old Kinderhook two times in the last few years . We have come to the lake as a meeting place for our family just to have Thanksgiving at Old Kinderhook. We have a home at the lake but leave the end of October. We have never been disappointed . We Love the food, the ice skating, the fire pits and most of all the beautiful lodge. It’s 5 star for us!!
2021 was our 4th Thanksgiving year at Old Kinderhook, and we're planning to go again in 2922. Great service, great cuisine, personable and efficient staff, beautiful setting. Broccoli slaw is the best ever. Dessert varieties are yummy and beautifully presented. THANK you!
Mia our waitress was great!!! Hands down the best , she made our experience even better😃
The dining room is to noisy for someone who has hearing problems...
Excellent food, service and atmosphere. Robin was an excellent server. Will be back often as we live local.
Great place. Food was fantastic. I would recommend highly
Christine was amazing. She really made our night special.
We celebrated a quiet birthday as two old friends and enjoyed the quiet ambiance and lovely view from the dining room. Our server, Christina, did a fantastic job of taking care of us, without being obtrusive, while being warm and friendly. It's a special skill. The food was awesome and perfectly prepared.
And on top of it they refused my open table points. New chef is not making it. Food is no longer good and service is marginal or worse. Too bad😰
Our waitress Robin was very good
It was my 88th birthday and she
Brought me a wonderful dessert as well as had the guests sing happy birthday for my special day
Friendly and efficient staff. Great food options and very tasty.
Calamari was great, especially the sauce. Caesar salad and dressing was fabulous, Rib-Eye was cooked to perfection [rare]. Asparagus was cooked just right. . Halibut was wonderful.
Service was better than good.
Only down side, we brought a $250+ bottle of wine and no one knew how to decant it. Even the bar keep had no clue. You might think about getting a decanter for those bringing an exceptional wine of their own.
Our server was super friendly & very nice. According to our receipt her name was Becky.
Very nice experience and the food and service was great.
Wonderful, as always!
Beautiful view of the golf course from the dining room.
Food was very good. Our first time there since bringing a new chef aboard We’ll go back again on another trip to the lake.
Not sure what was going on in the kitchen but we were told that they were out of bread so we wouldn’t be getting that which was fine for us. But we ordered the Calamari appetizer and she brought it out with our meal. So we didn’t eat it for fear our dinner would get cold. Food was very good. It just took a little while to get which we are fine to take our time while we are out at a nice dinner if we have a cocktail or two. But…getting drinks seemed to be a bit challenging. The bar was out of several different liquors, which we found surprising as it was a Friday night. Then it took about 15 minutes to get our drinks and then had to wait about the same amount of time to get someone back over to take another drink order and another 15 minutes to get them. But the food was good so you have the time for a long dinner you’re good.
Give it a try
The atmosphere and views were amazing. The prime rib special was very good. The steak was very disappointing and not worth the hefty price tag. The halibut was ok but has very little flavor. We will eat there again because of the location, views and atmosphere, however we will choose from lower priced items like sandwiches, burgers and pasta that is hard to mess up. We would recommend to a friend but only for drinks, appetizers and sandwiches…certainly not for fine dining.
Everything was excellent as always.
They were i understaffed, poorly trained, and management was unwilling to provide assistance to the wait staff.
Our salad was delivered after our entree (only after we let the server know that we had never received it. Our water glasses were never refilled, and we weren’t offered dessert before the server brought our check. In addition, our server had no idea what Sauvignon Blanc was, when we ordered a bottle of wine.
For a fine dining establishment, the service we received was very substandard and very disappointing.
However, the chef did a good job - the food was very high quality.
Lisa was an amazing server, so pleasant!
This was our first time dining at old kinderhook, we were looking to try somewhere different. The restaurant and view are beautiful. Our server gave us fantastic service. I started off with the blue cheese wedge salad, and my husband got the vegetable beef soup. Both were great. For dinner, my husband got the ribeye, which was cooked perfectly and very good. I got the sea scallops, and they were truly amazing. Cooked and seasoned perfectly, and were some of the largest I’ve ever had. We finished off with the brownie and ice cream desert. Pricey, but worth the money. We will definitely be back!
Our server Mila was wonderful!!
Very nice option for the area and many selections available for food and wine
We loved our waitress Lisa!!!! Beautiful view and great food.
We had a small wedding dinner and it was wonderful. When we booked, we didn’t know we needed to specify we wanted the main dining area, so we were seated in the bar area. It was a little noisy here, but still very nice. Our waitress, Robin, did a wonderful job making sure we were taken care of. The food was delicious and beautifully presented. Thanks for making our evening a success.
Trophy Room at Old Kinderhook is rated 4.7 stars by 476 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.