Wonderful dinner with great service and recommendations from the sommelier

Our first time there - poor service, the sommelier was sarcastic and the server was unhappy and grumpy. The food was fine - definitely not outstanding as promised. We were very disappointed.

Amazing pumpkin cheesecake like no other and very interesting presentation of the chocolate parfait. The presentation of the Peking duck was also lovely. Service was lacking in that we were not well attended to but it was obvious the staff was overworked. The location is absolutely spectacular. The sunset is priceless.

Excellent restaurant in a beautiful setting, food and service was excellent, extensive wine list.

Service and food were excellent. Arriving early enough we could see a wonderful sunset.

Lovely dinner. We were on the deck but had heaters to keep us warm! The sommelier was fantastic and gave awesome suggestions. We loved our dinners …. And of course the property was lovely as well. Super romantic!

Perfect for lunch and dinner !
The best place in Nantucket without a doubt
Crab and lobster cakes and white wine for lunch amazing

Wonderful spot and great service.

We celebrated our 43rd Anniversary with a lovely dinner at Toppers.
We really enjoyed the ambiance with fire in the fireplace, quiet and subdued atmosphere, privacy with well-spaced tables and exceptional service.
Our entrees were very good, but not remarkable. Our server was excellent,
knowledgeable and amiable. We will definitely return!!!

Simply the best !

Awesome restaurant. Food out of this world. Our favorite restaurant

My husband and I booked Topper’s for dinner on our minimoon. It was the best meal both of us have ever had. The service was also outstanding. We will definitely be back for multiple anniversaries.

Excellent as always!

Great food. Very nice service, but we had to get the servers’ attention. They were short staff,

Tourist trap really. Prices were high and food was so so.

Soooo disappointed!!! Been coming for years. It was like a whole different restaurant. Terrible service, got my 60.00 steak and vegetables cold and screwed up my substitution. Such a bummer since it was my husband’s birthday. Will not recommend or go back unless it gets a complete overhaul 👎👎👎👎

Although the food and ambiance was very good I felt that given our table was a group of 3woman , it was very much noted that other tables that had a man present were given preferential treatment . In other restaurants when a sommelier is present they offer suggestions on wines but the one at Toppers was curt and never came back to see how the wine was or to refill our glasses We had to ask every time we needed a refill but it was noted that the other tables were given suggestions and even a description of different wines to try

Tabitha took such good care of us and made our visit simply amazing!

Our server was Tabitha. She was friendly and very attentive…added to the extreme beauty of the atmosphere! The food was special, original, flavorful. We had a perfect experience!

Great service, food and drinks!

I loved this restaurant! Gorgeous location and posh decor!

Outstanding again. Best restaurant on the island.

There is a disconnect from what a highly acclaimed restaurant is and what Topper’s is. Likely, a lot of the accolades are in light of their location.

Outstanding!

Perfection outside Really enjoyed our dinner, excellent service, wines, food. Ambiance outside is beautiful.

Best restaurant on Nantucket. I encourage you to go.

Amazing wine list (USA, France, Italy)

Well done service and food. Jenn was fantastic with our table request and also helping to make our day special.

Consistently the finest dining experience on the island.
Fabulous cuisine, extensive wine list, impeccable service….
Toppers never disappoints!

First Class in service and food! Alex was a wonderful server! Yvonne, head of housekeeping, is amazing! She completely goes above and beyond to ensure every detail is attended to! We love her!

Lobster roll, excellent. Tuna nicoise, not so much. Wonderful cocktails and ambience. Excellent service.

Great place to catch the sunset

We had a great experience.

30 years of dinner experiences at Topper’s. Save this for that memorable occasion because it truly is a very special place. Ambiance , service and kindness exude from this establishment.

Excellent dinner at a scenic location. Food, wine and especially service was excellent, i.e. helpful, quick but not overbearing.

We had a fabulous boat ride and outside dining experience. We did return by boat which was also magical. Josh made it all happen and I can’t thank him enough for being so accommodating when we needed to change our reservation due to the impending hurricane.

Toppers has a very pretentious environment that does not make patrons feel welcome or relaxed. The food is good, the dining room and outdoor seating is pretty. Their lawn is nice for having a drink before or after dinner but the staff does not make it a cozy or nice place to enjoy dinner and drinks. The food was good but the entire staff there does not make it a place I would want to return except for one person— that is the driver who drove us back to town after dinner who has worked at the wauwinet for 30 years— longer than anyone else there in any position. The best part was the boat ride over from downtown to the wauwinet.

For a 5 star restaurant this did nothing meet our expectations. We ordered champagne and had to ask for our glasses to be refilled every time they were empty. The hamachi crudo and the chocolate dessert were great. The rest of the meal was good, nothing special.

Horrible service. Waitress messed up two of our orders. Wayover price for the level of service. My son’s meal did not come until after the rest of our party and already finished dinner. No apologies from the wait staff

Setting is great some of our mains were not up to the standards that we have had here in the past.