Tony's Italian Ristorante
Medallions of veal sauteed with mushrooms on a delicate Marsala wine demi-glace.
marinara sauce and mozzarella.
Baked crisp with gorgonzola cheese olives and a blend of herbs.
Outstanding food and service. Probably the best Italian food in Columbus!
Loved everything about it!
Tony was great to meet & the food was excellent! We will definitely be back.
Fantastic meal. Very enjoyable evening. Well worth a visit to Tony's.
Walleye special was delicious. My wife ordered veal picatta. You won't find better in the city.
For our 38th anniversary, we wanted Italian, and Tony's was recommended by a couple of
friends. They both had been to Tony's just once, but, both raved about the food. So, I checked some of the reviews and made a reservation. We had a terrific server and meal, and can't wait to get back for another meal.
Loved the service and the food.
good food at a reasonable price- will go back for sure
Another great experience at Tony’s! Gazpacho is my favorite- great Merlot and chicken Marsala too!
Perfect combination of old world food flavors, ambience and attention to service.
This is the best Italian restaurant in Columbus and the others don't compare. Perfect place to learn how to enjoy the Mediterranean lifestyle.
Best tortellini with chicken I've ever had. I was able to reserve a table on-line very quickly. Very pleasant staff. We'll definitely come here again.
My favorite Italian restaurant in Columbus - first time back in a few months and first time for friends who joined us.
As expected, food was great (our friends split an order of lasagna and a house special fettuccini - thought both were great), my wife had her usual Fettuccini Madonna and I had the house special Trout. The Madonna was a bit short on sauce, but my trout was outstanding. I hope, when the restaurant reopens, this becomes a regular offering. We shared a couple of appetizers and I added the sausage stuffed mushrooms as a side. They were fabulous. We shared two bottles of a nice blended red wine, all had coffee and dessert and the total was less than $220 for the 4 of us pre-tip. Add in the friendly service, free parking and general ambience and I don't know how it can be beaten.
We had a great meal served in a timely manner before our trip to the Ohio Theatre for a show.
Food was great! Our server Mike was very attentive. We'll be back!
Excellent food and service, comfortable and clean environment. Very gracious owner, Tony was welcoming and kind to us.
Tony’s is one of our favorites. Great service, atmosphere and food!
For a nicer restaurant they are unbending and not customer accommodating. My friend ordered a regular meal from the menu — not a special— and asked to substitute a vegetable for the linguini because she cannot eat gluten. Waiter told her there are no substitutes, she has to get the linguini, and if she wanted gluten free there would be a $4.95 up charge. She did not want to do that — just a potato or veg. instead of the linguini. Unacceptable policy for a nicer restaurant.
We were heading to the Columbus Jazz Orchestra February concert series and Tony’s is the perfect pre-concert dinner spot. Close by, quiet, feels like old school service and the food is excellent. We love it!
This place was such a let down. We’ll never go back and glad we only wasted our money once. The only thing we liked was the salad dressing and there wasn’t nearly enough of it. Everything else was worth forgetting the minute we left.
“Do better” Tonys’s if you plan to keep up the pretentious attitude towards middle class customers.
Food was average, calamari was just okay. Server didn't seem that friendly
If you like good, Italian food...Tony's is the place!
Amazing food, service, and environment. Took my wife for Valentine’s Day and we had a wonderful experience. Highly recommend
Great Italian food. Good service.
Nice meal , nothing really stood out . We didn’t leave thinking wow we need to come back here but if someone mentions going we would go back.
I used to go to Tony's at least a couple times a year, but I have not been able to make it for the last few years. Very disappointed in both the ambience and the food this time. The soup was extremely salty, and the main courses had very little flavor. Their signature pasta dish tasted more like flour than alfredo. The waiter was okay but not overly attentive. I ordered hot tea at the end of the meal and was brought less than half a cup of tea. I asked for some more and was brought even less the next time around. I was very disappointed as this used to be one of my favorite restaurants, and now I doubt if I will ever return again. On a side note, one of the owners kept coming to the table beside us and talking to the customers multiple times during the meal, which was somewhat annoying to our party, and you could see on their faces became annoying to them as well, but they did not want to say anything. He even had to move out of the way so we could leave our table.
Tony’s has been our ‘go to’ for Italian in the Brewery District for decades. Blackened scallops awesome, wedding soup, chicken parmigiana all fantastic.
This was our third time visiting Tony's and was disappointed. I ordered shrimp scampi and it only came with shrimp and a salad, nothing to put the scampi on. I thought that very strange. So basically paid $28 for 8 shrimp and a salad - not a good value. My husband ordered a veal dish and disappointed in with that dish. Probably will not be going back.
Best Italian Food in Columbus!
My friends and I had a great time eating great food. Chicken Parmigiana is to die for!
I had the chicken parmesan and it was delicious. There was an ample serving with spaghetti. It was Saturday night so the restaurant was louder than usual. i thought the salad could have had more dark leaves and a few more veggies for the price of the meal. The bread was good. i will be back when my schedule permits.
Tony’s has become our new favorite restaurant! We have had several meals there since discovering it and have never been disappointed. We are taking all our friends there now.
A table for four, three diners ok with their food order. Wait staff rushed generally overly irritated. Wait staff offered “upgrade to salad offering with meal to Caesar from tossed salad that came with the meal. The Caesar salad “upgrade was a joke a plate of iceberg lettus small amount of dressing and a whole anchovy laying on the end of the plate. I had lasagna 99% ricotta cheese, have never seen such a poor excuse for lasagna, salad then got charged over $6.00 for Salad, sad sad. Tony’s was a good restaurant once but not now. I could tell the kitchen was rushed and had no thought of quality.
We visited this time last year and it was great! We used entertainment book coupon. It brought us back again this year. Food again was outstanding but an issue arose with our coupon and managed denied our legit coupon. Something happened when they took my phone to run number. But the worst was how manager handled it. He became confrontational in front of other guests. I chose not to make a scene but he ruined our evening and we will not be back. Way to lose business by not exceeding a guests expectations. The entertainment book has at least 300 restaurants to choose from
Wonderful experience. Great service. Good food at a reasonable price.
Everything was great, but they weren’t that busy and we were at our table for two hours. We weren’t in a hurry, but 90 minutes would have been enough
My wife and I love to eat at Tony's. Great food...great price.
First time for my Mom and brother. The service, food, and restaurant was beautiful to them. They will come back.
Food is consistently excellent. Service is professional and friendly. Always a pleasant experience.
Authentic food and atmosphere. Great date spot that I'd recommend for anyone looking to depart from the normal big chain places. Food was mouth watering!
Someone at the restaurant, possibly the owner, hovered throughout the dining room the entire evening. Two waiters introduced themselves to us as our waiter, but one only ended up serving us. The food was good, but the overall atmosphere of the restaurant took away from the enjoyment of the meal.
First time eating at Tony's and we had a great experience!
Tony's Italian Ristorante offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (614) 224-8669.
Tony's Italian Ristorante is rated 4.5 stars by 471 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.