Tony's Italian Ristorante
Traditional Wedding Soup
Chicken broth, eggs, spinach, pastina and parmesan cheese.
Pan-Fried Trout Milanse
Fresh rainbow trout breaded and pan-fried, topped with lemon butter.
The food and service were fabulous!
I love the ambiance of this place the martini are nice stiff, the food came out fresh and hot.
The food is always incredible, and we had some of the best service I’ve ever had.
Incredible authentic food.
Great hospitality. Quaint atmosphere
the personal service and impeccable food is always the best at Tony's
I had.not been to this restaurant for 40 years- got engaged to my ex husband there. I had Ciopino and my husband had Tony’s Fettuccine both were delicious!
Had limoncello cake for dessert- light as air and delicious!
Everything was excellent. Due to Covid we had not been out for several months. The evening was perfect.
Food is subpar and not prepared in traditional Italian style and Staff is overworked , resulting in lack of customer focus.
Great place! Everything was excellent, food, service, and ambience.
Delicious food and excellent service! Great place to eat in German Village
Great find-what a little gem! The food was delicious and the staff was very attentive. Great wine selection, too. The prices (both for food and wine) were very reasonable. We had a wonderful dinner. We’ll totally be heading back there. 👍🏻
It’s a little upsetting when you make a reservation for a specific time and still have to wait 20+ mins to be seated. Megan our server was phenomenal. She was honest and up front during our experience and I couldn’t be more grateful. She is what made our experience worth it.
Fantastic Italian meal as always to celebrate our daughter’s birthday!!
Delicious late night dinner. Very friendly staff.
We had an excellent experience our Friday during Lent seafood dishes were excellent. The desserts ( tiramisu and lemon cake ) were also delicious. Our server was attentive without being intrusive. We will definitely dine again.
Amazing. Excellent restaurant. We’ll be back!
The food was very good, especially the homemade pasta. The sausage and peppers I’ve loved for years are no longer patties but now Italian sausage links - seemed store bought as opposed to the advertised house made but I’ll overlook that given Covid cost conditions on restaurants. Our server, however, I cannot forgive. She seemed downright resentful to be serving us. I’ve been going to Tony’s for 25 years (though admittedly this was the first since Covid hit, and I’ve never had bad service. She said she just started in February but it wasn’t inexperience or unfamiliarity with the menu - it was just an outright bad attitude.
Beautiful location, amazing food, wonderful experience!
We always have a wonderful experience at Tony’s! We love the ambiance, the personal attention. And the food is delicious. Fine dining with fair prices.
Best service and food in German Village
As always, Tony's does a great job and the ambiance is what you want in an Italian restaurant.
Great food, good portion size, excellent service, cozy atmosphere, authentic Italian, and a good wine and beer selection. Checked all my boxes for a great night!
Always a pleasure dining with Tony. Best tiramasu I have ever had.
We've been coming to Tony's for over 25 years. It was our first date... now our grown kids come with us. They love it too.
What a wonderful restaurant to enjoy a great meal. Service was great. Atmosphere was wonderful, food was really good. Will certainly be back
Great authentic Italian restaurant. A Columbus staple.
Very nice and romantic restaurant to enjoy a night out with the wife.
The place is very romantic. However, the food was just okay and wouldn’t recommend the place for the price.
Great. Tony is welcoming and the food was delicious.
Four different diners with four different orders and all were delicious!
Ftantastic food, amazing friendly staff - always a pelasure to dine at Tony's !
Great dining experience at Tony’s. The food was delicious. We will definitely be returning.
Food and service as memorable as I recall from past visits. Always gracious and much attention to detail. Escargot was wonderful and chef's special was very delicious.
My 3rd time here and food is always good. Nice quiet place and nice evening out
Horrible service, food was lukewarm. Really disappointing because we have always had excellent service and food there in the past.
For the past 30 years, Tony's never disappoints. Tables are distanced, as are seats at the table. All servers wearing masks. Food hasn't missed a beat since new chef joining. Wedding soup is still the best in town. Veal Marsala was so tender and flavorful, Chicken Parm and trout were done to perfection. Quiet enough so a table of 4 doesn't have to yell. Tony is the best host and makes everyone feel like an old friend
Outstanding food and service. Probably the best Italian food in Columbus!
Loved everything about it!
Tony was great to meet & the food was excellent! We will definitely be back.
Fantastic meal. Very enjoyable evening. Well worth a visit to Tony's.
Walleye special was delicious. My wife ordered veal picatta. You won't find better in the city.
For our 38th anniversary, we wanted Italian, and Tony's was recommended by a couple of
friends. They both had been to Tony's just once, but, both raved about the food. So, I checked some of the reviews and made a reservation. We had a terrific server and meal, and can't wait to get back for another meal.
Tony's Italian Ristorante offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (614) 224-8669.
Tony's Italian Ristorante is rated 4.5 stars by 507 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.