Saturday: 5:00pm - 10:00pm
Always an excellent meal at this place! Wonderful restaurant.
Simply put, the BEST Italian restaurant on Long Island. ALWAYS great food AND service. The attention to detail and the fresh ingredients makes this restaurant stand out from the rest. Our server, Robb is AMAZING!!!
5 stars all around. Busy place, had a delay getting us seated, a delay with my drink, but they noticed both and immediately handled before I could even think about whining!
Just a great place to eat !!! The service was good.
Always a great time. Food was amazing and our waiter is fantastic. Rob makes the experience even greater.
We had a reservation at 7PM and showed up on time. There were multiple tables available and no one else waiting. The host told us that it will be about 10 minutes for a table, after about 15 minutes I asked again if we can be seated since there were multiple tables already available. He then sat us immediately. It was extremely hot inside which made it practically impossible to enjoy our time there (it was winter and we were in sweaters which didn't help). Food was good tasting although there was a huge difference in the amount of food between the entrees we received.
Excellent food and service. Friends from Florida found the restaurant to be a good deal.
Great food and service as always. Valet parking or self parking is limited
we went there with some out of town cousin, a perfect choice. They loved it as did my husband and I. We were lucky enough to get a waited named Gabby, he was a gem vey friendly and attentive, but not all over us. It is our go to place when we want to take someone to dinner for an anniversary or graduation.
Robert took over our table since he saw that no server came over to us. He took our drink and appetizer order and was back within a few minutes with drinks. Robert was very funny and provided excellent service. We were happy that he remained our server for the rest of the evening.
Love this place! Food always good!
Waiter was very helpful when it came to deciding on different choices. He pointed out some favorites and we ended up loving it. Overall great experience
I used to love this restaurant so I chose it for my birthday on the 10th. The food was so disappointing... what happened?
Went there for dinner. Food was good and the service was excellent.
It was wonderful
This was the second time we tried the restaurant. First time was terrific. Second time needed more work. Seated at very small table even though plenty of larger tables available. Took a long time to order food and then food took a long time to arrive.
As always, everything was excellent. Food, service, drinks, everything. We never have a complaint about Tony Colombo's!
The food here is incredible! As many times we’ve been here, the experience gets better and better. And having the chance to dine and catch up with Gabby and the rest of the staff is always a delight. Looking forward to returning again soon!
It was very good food and the service was excellent. Would recommend this for good Italian food.
Outstanding as usual
"I love the relaxed feel of this place – like a comfortable dining room . I definitely would return to try more dishes. The veal was Amazing thanks to Susan who treats us like family
Great food. Very nice workers. Portions were fulfilling. Very clean,
Good location good food a bit noisy but not too annoy
as always the food is like grandma used to make. the service is always friendly.
Food was very good but service was slow. Annoying fruit flies hovered near our table.
Restaurant was excellent as always and the service was exceptional.
Surprised no one said Happy Birthday to my husband- as I noted that in my reservation. We asked for a quiet table and was stunned to see that they placed everyone near us and the entire time there was a booth by the fireplace that would have been perfect. (I actually said to host we need a quiet table for my father in law). But the most disappointing was that we were shocked by being the first ones in the restaurant- and yet we waited for drinks, and subsequently waited for each course and had to flag down hostess and another server for our check. I thought service was really really poor. We are very frequent guests of Chadwicks and unfortunately this service was really bad by comparison. And we were there at 5:45 so it wasn't in the midst of prime dining time.
Always great food AND service. Fresh ingredients make all the difference. When you enter the restaurant, you are made to feel like family! Our server Robb is AMAZING!!! Ask for him for a fun evening!
Gabby is awesome.
Excellent as usual!
Everything was outstanding as usual
Great meal! Excellent service! We were seated timely for reservation. Only issue was It was loud. I’m sure we added It the noise level as well! Would go back.
Good Italian food...the fried calamari was perfect. Good house wine by the glass. Classic Italian food with some twist, like shrimp carbonara w/risotto! Our waiter was good..even though he rushed us.We were just finishing the calamari and the main course came out. I've been in the buisness for 47 years, so
I know he fired the tablet get us out fast. He acted surprised and said "I can't beleive the food is here so fast, you give the kitchen an order and blah blah blah.....I would recommend this restaurant.
Overall great time but hostess was not very friendly and food was very salty.
Everything was perfect! We could not have asked for more. Quick seating, quick service, delicious food.
Another YUMMY meal at Tonys. The food is ALWAYS delicious and fresh. The service in TOP NOTCH! Our server, Robert is AWESOME!!!
It just doesn't get better than Tonys. The food is ALWAYS fresh and delicious. Service is ALWAYS top notch. Our server, Robert is THE BEST!!!
Great as usual! Nice wait staff, excellent food. Yummy!
The food was amazing and so was the service. Really nice atmosphere and will definitely be back. A real gem