One of the better Italian restaurants in the area
Pasta was so good
Rice balls so good
Excellent authentic Italian food, from appetizers to dessert
Celebrating a very special Birthday!
Thank you to Gabby for making it extra special ❤️
Very good experience.
Seriously, why would you want to eat Italian anywhere else. ALWAYS excellent food AND service. Hubby and me decided to ditch the regular menu and decided to eat from the specials. WOW, we were blown away! What flavor!!! The evening would not be complete without the BEST server, Robert!!!
As always this place is tops. Had the beef brocoila; it was just like grandma made!
Was very good...must get Rob as a waiter he made the whole night
Always on point. Service, food. Baby artichoke app and capellini columbo the best!!!
wait staff needs to be trained in appropriate behavior , too dark, too noisy
Delicious Italian food. Came on a Thursday night and it was quiet. Ambiance is nice. We sat in a corner booth by the window. Bread basket and appetizers were delish. We loved the hot antipasti except for the fried artichokes....the calamari was very good. My husband thought the music was boring and old school. I think there was some frank Sinatra thrown in there. It didn’t bother me much. Came here for my birthday and spent about $100 + tip. It was well worth it. Portions are a good size and we had left overs for lunch the next day.
Lovely hospitality with a great ambiance to match. Seems very family oriented & family friendly. The food was AMAZINGGGG! Definitely bringing our kids to enjoy it with us next time.
Usually, the food is amazing, but it wasn't as good this past time. My boyfriend ordered the Capellini Colombo and received an undercooked scallop. After we left, he got sick. As I said, usually the food is great but for some reason it wasn't as good this last time.
This was our first time hear and we made another reservation as we left, it was that good !
Lets start with a great friendly greeting from the hostess Susan, who seated us quickly and engaged us in conversation and asked if we were celebrating an occasion, which we were. The waiter was friendly and knowledgable about the food and how its prepared. Portions were large and well prepared.
The food was amazing! Meatballs were better than mine which I thought impossible! Service was horrible waitress totally ignored us!!!
Great vibe. Great food. Fresh and nice presentation. Great service.
What more can I cay about Tony's that has not been said before? EXCELLENT Italian food in a very warm and super friendly environment. Our server, Robert is AMAZING as usual!!!
We had a 5:30 reservation and the first thing we are told is that you have a 7pm after us… we didnt even sit down and are getting the feeling of feeling rushed.
Our waiter Gabby was fantastic.
It was wonderful. We used to go to the restaurant when it was Cafe Rivera and went back for old times sake. Everything was fab. We live in Vegas but will come back each time we are in town.
Great food all the time.Also the waiters are the best. Friendly and professional.Way to go Tony Colombos.!!!!😊
This was our first time here but it won't be our last. My husband had the good fortune (?) to be born on New Year's Day &, usually, finding a good restaurant open is hard enough, never mind if it also happens to be on a Monday when a lot of places are normally closed anyway. We always wanted to try Tony Colombo's so since they were open, why not? Very glad we did! Everything was perfect, from our waiter, Zack, to the décor, and of course to the food.
We'll be back for sure!
Tony Colombo's is absolutely my favorite restaurant in Rockville Centre. The food from the regular menu is always good and the specials are often exceptional. I am always warmly greeted by the hostess and the wait staff who work hard to ensure the meal is enjoyable. Tony, the chef, will make every effort to accommodate when I request a special dish that may not be on the menu. Top notch restaurant with a top notch staff.
The food is delicious and the service is excellent. Me and my wife originally tried Tony Columbos because of a Groupon but we’ve been back almost a dozen times since. Everything is great about this restaurant.
Great italian place, perfect for date or family get together. I ordered the baked clams sinatra - excellent. ordered penne al vodka and didn’t like it just because the pasta was al dente, which isn’t my favorite. Overall dinner was great
Every time my boyfriend and I visit NY we make it a point to dine here. The food is to die for and the staff goes above and beyond. Our server Zach was very attentive even though he was clearly having a busy night. We will continue to go back for years to come.
Our server Susan was fantastic. Food was absolutely delicious as usual.
Service was excellent. Staff was very friendly and pleasant. Would recommend this restaurant to others. Food was very good
There were 5 of us for dinner and I can only say great things in all aspects. The serving staff were
excellent, friendly and on top of everything. Great acoustics so conversation wasn't difficult. Highly recommend Tony Colombo's. An enjoyable evening! There was a problem with "OpenTable Reservations" reservations so be aware. Call if needed but hopefully that will be corrected shortly.
Fantastic food, great service.
I've been here many times, each time trying something different. This time it was the Chicken Colombo which was so good. Of course the meatballs are out of this world.
We were eight people celebrating a special birthday . The table was waiting for us ...the waiter was highly attentive... the food was delicious ...we definitely would go again and/or recommend to friends ..,great neighborhood find. Thank you Tony Colombos!!!
Great food and friendly servers. Dependable Italian fare.
We took our 86 year old mom for her birthday dinner at Tony Columbo's having never been there before. Both the service and food exceeded our expectations. the restaurant was cozy, our server Michael and the rest of the staff attended to our every need and Tony even came out to say hi. We will be back again even though we live in Manhattan. Well worth the ride!
Authentic food, excellent service peppered with local charm. Saturday night was our first time, but not our last. Can’t wait to go back. Everything we tried was fabulous(and I’m Italian!) Stuffed veal chop ... Bellissimo!
Very nice people. Seated promptly. Great waiter service. Delicious dishes.
Absolutely the BEST Sicilian/Italian restaurant this side of Italy! Fresh and flavorful ingredients make all the difference. LOVE, LOVE, LOVE eating @ Tony's. Once again, our server Robert was OUTSTANDING and added to the enjoyment of our terrific meal. Ask for him your next visit!
Great food and great ambience! Centrally located walking distance from train .
Lovely! Great food, service and atmosphere.
The food was excellent and the service was great. The place would make a nice spot for a date.
Poor table service and quality of food was inferior.
One word...eggplant !!! I’m not vegetarian and also not a fan of eggplant but WOW!!! My hubby had the chicken and it was amazing as well. We decided to try for restaurant week as we live nearby and never been and I’m so so happy we did! Great food, great service, great wine , great atmosphere! Highly recommend!