Our mission will always be to serve classic Mexican dishes prepared with the sophistication of a fine dining restaurant in a casual and approachable manner.
Tocolo Cantina serves refined, modern Mexican food in a friendly, high-service, and casual atmosphere.
Since no great cantina is complete without a lively bar and lofty cocktail program, Tocolo Cantina promises to deliver the best margaritas and sangrias around. The bar offers delicious specialty drinks, as well as a large selection of premium tequilas and mezcals.
We are located at The Gallery at Westbury Plaza in Garden City (2 doors down from Trader Joe's).
Instantly increase your points with dining rewards
See availability for bonus point tables
Mon 5:00PM - 8:00PM
Food and drinks were great. Guacamole was delicious as was the salad with the roasted corn and avocado. As for ambiance, it was a little bright in there. The LED spotlights were right over our heads. But they did turn them down a bit after another customer asked.
Mike is the best !!
Delicious food and tastes cocktails.
Fantastic food and service! Always recommend for any occasion.
Portions are way too small. Fajitas were not seasoned and def not worth the price.
Not a great value for the food. Everything is a la cart.
Did not entree that were previously on menu. No flexibility on special request on type of tacos
A group of friends and I were debating restaurant week specials at other restaurants when we came across Tocolo. Their everyday happy hour and lunch specials are a great deal! Delicious margaritas, food and large portions. Our server, who seemed to be handling most of tables, was also great and very attentive. We'll definitely be back!
The service is great. The dinner we had was ok.... my fajitas were plenty and my husband steak tacos were good too .
I had the Mexican salad for lunch. It was excellent. Lots of different things in it- avocado- tomatoes onions peppers crispy noodles Bibb and romaine
My wife thoroughly enjoyed her birthday at Tocolo, one of our favorites. We have never been disappointed. In fact, the experience is always amazing..
What a great place to enjoy some Mexican food and some drinks with family. The service was good and staff was friendly. The food was tasty 😋 and the price is reasonable.
It was fun!
I visited this restaurant on a date. The food and service were good. It wasn't too loud that we couldn't hear each other, but it was an active night. We'll definitely go to this place again.
The food was delicious! Our server, Mike was attentive, without being over-bearing and professional.
Great spot. Great atmosphere. Food is Excellante Gigante!
Always a good time! Everything was delicious from the guacamole to the churros! Can’t wait to go back!
Food is superb. We are regulars always consistent!! Service is always on point! Everything is fresh fresh fresh!! Love their guac and shrimp tacos
I'm not a margarita drinker and i tried two flavors and they were some of the best i've ever tasted! I think they are made fresh because they didn't have a pre-made taste and were not overly sweet. The food was absolutely delicious. I probably would not order the fish tacos because they had a fish smell and taste to them. Fresh fish shouldn't smell, so maybe the fish was previously frozen, i dont know and it doesn't matter too much to me, my bf and i plan on going back a lot! great place! We were also really into the latin music they were playing. Service was great too. Thanks guys, keep it up!
Wow! What a gem. It was a fall back plan after Besito fell through. I don't know what I was expecting but WOW. It has surpassed all expectations I had.
Empanadas. Empanadas. Empanadas. Don't want to bore you but you have to get them. Also best corn tortillas I have had outside of Mexico.
Think Besito but half the price and dare I say slightly better food. Menu selection is not as in-depth but it has all the favorites. Margaritas also good.
Very pleasant dining experience. Food was authentic and delicious Ambiance was very nice price was very reasonable
I’d go back
Food and service was amazing. Quiet vibe tho but we were there early (5-6pm). I would go a little later next time to see how it is then.
I loved our waitress. The margaritas were really good and the food was yummy.
The space is gorgeous! Love the paintings. Food is great and we love the lunch special options! The best of all is you have grilled fish tacos! Not many places has that as an option. However, I do wish you would have fish tacos as an option for kids. Also, mole and more enchiladas options.
Great mojitos - the best around. Love the fresh guac and spicy salsa
I love Tocolo. I’ve been to this restaurant many times and each time the food is delicious and the service is great. I highly recommend going on a Tuesday for the Taco Tuesday deal.
Receptionist had trouble seating us in an empty restaurant even though we had made a 5:30pm reservation. She took us to three different locations prior to seating us, saying that if we sat there we would have to be done by 7:00pm because someone had a reservation (so did we).
The food itself came quickly (mixed grill $45), unfortunately it was extremely oily and was bland with no flavor. We tried the restaurant due to its 4 1/2 star rating and sadly we were extremely disappointed. Thank you to our waiter who was very professional, aside from saying hello to him we will not return there to dine.
We had a great time on Thursday night, but were a little weary at first. When we first arrived there were a lot of families/kids - felt a little awkward as it was described to us as a good place to go out with friends - but the ambiance quickly changed in a few minutes. Overall, I would recommend this place, but would tell "ladies night" customers to come after 8pm!
Delicious as always!
Quickly and professionally seated by the welcome host.
Chips and water right away
Drinks were quick and good
Food was fantastic.
We had been here before and I saw it again on my open table list so decided to head back.
Top notch mexican dining
Have a reservation!
And my request for a real super hot habernaro were fulfilled with a fresh warm homemade habernaro sauce that was killer hot And tasty!
Hot sauce fans ,,just ask!!!
We will be back
Waitress was our favorite, the food was great. Thanks for the yummy hot chocolate!
Food and service is good
Everything was great from service to food!!
Tocolo is a real find. The guacamole is delicious and the wings are even better. The drinks are generous and the service is friendly.
Would definitely recommend, food was delicious and drinks where amazing
It was absolutely wonderful! Highly recommend this restaurant if you want to have delicious food, a great ambience, and music. The staff is wonderful and are super patient with picky eaters and indecisive people. We all ended up getting the Experience and were so full and satisfied. This was my second time back and there will definitely be a third!
Always very delicious and my server was awesome! He actually was the bartender...made what has always been great to awesome!
Doesn’t really have a Mexican feel. If not for the menu, it could be any strip mall restaurant.
We enjoyed our Margaritas and delicious Guacamole! Service was prompt and friendly....we will definitely be back and soon!