Let us tantalize your tastebuds and awaken your inner foodie.
Come join us for such delights as Halibut topped with jumbo lump crabmeat or grilled filet Mignon topped with grilled lobster tail finished with béarnaise.
Whatever your choice may be, we promise to make your experience a memorable one.
Cape May, NJ 08204
Contemporary American, Italian
Hours of Operation:
$30 and under
AMEX, Discover, MasterCard, Visa
On-street metered & non-metered parking available.
Private Party Contact:
Lauren K Vitelli: (609) 827-3140
BYO Liquor, BYO Wine, Non-Smoking, Outdoor dining, Wheelchair Access, Wine
Tisha's Ratings and Reviews
Dinner was spot on for our belated Valentine's Day dinner. Service was excellent with all the attention to the detail that makes dining out enjoyable. Karmen, our server, anticipated our needs with the correct timing. Our table for 4 was comfortable with ample room for our wine bottles and the number of plates we had enjoyed. Our entrees included filet of beef, parmesan chicken, and salmon with shrimp. From salad to the end of the meal cappuccino, Tisha's deserves 4 + stars.
We have long been fans and bragged that Tisha’s was best food and our favorite restaurant in Cape May. We are local to Cape May and come here often.
Our meal on Feb 14 was nothing like so many meals we had enjoyed before. The quality of the ingredients was only poor to fair and the taste was poor.
We did inform the staff and they were responsive, offering a free dessert. Unfortunately that too was not up to even par of what we had before.
We will probably visit again, and hopefully this was just a bad night
Bad management. If you are going to serve just what you have left before closing for the winter--then tell your customers, or make an accommodation. an apology would be nice as well.
My wife and I were in town for New Years Eve and New Years Day. I know it is off-season, and, not surprisingly, many places were closed. But Tisha's was rated well, the menu looked interesting and so I booked it for January 1.
Short story: half the appetizers were "out". Some of the entrees as well. My dinner came with a "substitute" pasta that a) changed the dish completely, b) was overcooked and mushy, and c) came without a warning that the fettuccine was out.
Dessert? 3 out of 6 out--and no ice cream for the remaining ala mode items.
All not the end of the world--but no warning given. Nothing on the website or the Open Table reservation that the menu would be limited. We would have gone elsewhere.
Food? Stale bread. My appetizer of pumpkin gnocci was burnt and swimming in oil. My wife's appetizer of New England clam chowder was excellent. My wife's dinner of seafood risotto came without the clams--the server caught it and made the addition. Mine came--I looked at it and said, this isn't what I ordered--and I got a half-baked, oh, sorry, we're out of what you ordered, we substituted this. In other words, f.u.
Clearly everyone from the non-smiling hostess to the kitchen staff had one foot out the door. Fine. Just warn us--or, heaven forbid, cut the price.
We weren't even offered a cup of coffee on the house--again, bad management, bad service,-- just a really bad experience.
We had a delicious dinner at Tisha’s on New Years Eve! Both the food and service were excellent. The short rib pappardelle was great comfort food for such a freezing cold night. The kale caeser salad was also delicious. Worth a visit. You won’t be disappointed!
Our dining experience last eve was as phenomenal as the 3 times before! Excellent food, wonderful ambience and a staff that is truly first rate. Brenda continues to be a delight to see as we 1st walk through the door. We vowed to try as many different restaurants as we possibly could now that we are here on a regular basis...But- we keep finding ourselves drawn to Tish’s!
My husband and I ate here 2 years ago and he's been dreaming about the short rib Bolognese. So....we hopped in the car and drove the 90 minutes to try it again. Tisha's did not disappoint. I started with the kale Caesar and ordered the seafood risotto thanks to our lovely server's recommendation. It was the most amazing thing I've tasted all year! The seafood was so fresh. My husband enjoyed his arancini and of course the short rib Bolognese. He said it was just as delicious as he remembered. Great service, great food, totally worth the 90 min drive! We'll be back!
We went down to cape May to enjoy the Xmas setting with company from Florida. Tisha's was a last minute find. What a fantastic meal!! From start to finish the good was amazing. The waitress was friendly, humourous, and paced the meal perfectly ( Logan ). Everyone had an appetizer that we all shared because each one was delicious. Our main course selection were all done to order and everyone enjoyed their meal. Lastly, dessert topped off a great meal. Oh, and our Florida company picked up the check so WIN, WIN!! We are from OC and have Tisha at the top of our cape May eating list!!
My wife and I returned to Cape May for the Christmas weekend and made reservations at the Washington Inn, the Ebbit Room and Tisha's. The Washington Inn was great as usual but Tisha's was by far the superior restaurant in every category, save ambience, since it's extremely difficult to surpass the décor at the Washington Inn. The food at Tisha's was superb; the service was even better and it was the least expensive of the three. We've truly never once been disappointed at Tisha's over the years.
Have visited tishas many times..1st time for husband..we were not disapointed..lobster bisque very good lotta meaty chunks.
Crab tacos good ,lunch portion 2 . Byob..they do sell nj wines,but only bottles..but at lunch,ice tea fine..server could have used bit more help..
You can always count on Tisha’s for an excellent meal. We come every year to celebrate my birthday in December and also during the warmer months since we live close by in Linwood. Always our first choice ! Food is always delicious and staff friendly and efficient! Highly recommend to all our friends!
Tishas is very pretty inside, not fancy but simple elegance with nice room between the tables. The hostess and server were friendly and attentive, it’s very pleasant.
It’s a BYOB so you don’t have the expense for drinks, but plan on spending over $100 for 2 people with just entrees and coffee. It’s very expensive.
The bread with dipping oil is delicious and we were offered more :) I had seafood risotto cooked perfectly and deep fresh flavors. Just the right portion to enjoy with none left over. My husband had the filet au poive which was on mashed potatoes with green beans on the plate also cooked to perfection. The portion also good for one meal, no leftovers.
All of the options are ala carte so no soup or salad unless you added them. The menu has a great variety to choose from but we just had our entree & coffee.
Perhaps the high cost is because of its location, which is great for walking around Cape May.
Our dinner at Tisha’s was good albeit pricey. My husband had the clam chowder, which was okay, followed by the pappardelle with short rib. I had the jambalaya. They were both good, but nothing outstanding. Service was fine. So a good dinner but at somewhat high prices.
Please sign in to record your input. Thanks!
Report this review as inappropriate?
If you believe this review should be removed from OpenTable, please let us know and someone will investigate.