Food was excellent. Highly recommend the lobster bisque and the New England clam chowder. The seafood risotto was superb.
My only complaint was it was quite chilly in the front room. Every time the door opened cold air filled the room.
My husband and I ate here 2 years ago and he's been dreaming about the short rib Bolognese. So....we hopped in the car and drove the 90 minutes to try it again. Tisha's did not disappoint. I started with the kale Caesar and ordered the seafood risotto thanks to our lovely server's recommendation. It was the most amazing thing I've tasted all year! The seafood was so fresh. My husband enjoyed his arancini and of course the short rib Bolognese. He said it was just as delicious as he remembered. Great service, great food, totally worth the 90 min drive! We'll be back!
Tisha's is always fresh and great. My favorite place in Cape May, NJ. Its also a BYOB so you can pair your meal with your favorite wine OR you can buy wine there.
We went down to cape May to enjoy the Xmas setting with company from Florida. Tisha's was a last minute find. What a fantastic meal!! From start to finish the good was amazing. The waitress was friendly, humourous, and paced the meal perfectly ( Logan ). Everyone had an appetizer that we all shared because each one was delicious. Our main course selection were all done to order and everyone enjoyed their meal. Lastly, dessert topped off a great meal. Oh, and our Florida company picked up the check so WIN, WIN!! We are from OC and have Tisha at the top of our cape May eating list!!
We visit every time in cape May love it never miss a chance to eat there
Excellent food and service. It was a very casual atmosphere. Menu options were terrific.
My wife and I returned to Cape May for the Christmas weekend and made reservations at the Washington Inn, the Ebbit Room and Tisha's. The Washington Inn was great as usual but Tisha's was by far the superior restaurant in every category, save ambience, since it's extremely difficult to surpass the décor at the Washington Inn. The food at Tisha's was superb; the service was even better and it was the least expensive of the three. We've truly never once been disappointed at Tisha's over the years.
food was fabulous along with the great service ... we'll be back
We've been to Tisha's many times. Every time the food is outstanding and the service is excellent. They didn't have fried calamari two nights in a row which is strange but other than that delicious!
We go to Tisha’s every time we’re in Cape May; the food is fantastic and the service is wonderful.
Have visited tishas many times..1st time for husband..we were not disapointed..lobster bisque very good lotta meaty chunks.
Crab tacos good ,lunch portion 2 . Byob..they do sell nj wines,but only bottles..but at lunch,ice tea fine..server could have used bit more help..
You can always count on Tisha’s for an excellent meal. We come every year to celebrate my birthday in December and also during the warmer months since we live close by in Linwood. Always our first choice ! Food is always delicious and staff friendly and efficient! Highly recommend to all our friends!
Food was excellent and service was great. Can’t go wrong dining at Tisha’s.
Tishas is very pretty inside, not fancy but simple elegance with nice room between the tables. The hostess and server were friendly and attentive, it’s very pleasant.
It’s a BYOB so you don’t have the expense for drinks, but plan on spending over $100 for 2 people with just entrees and coffee. It’s very expensive.
The bread with dipping oil is delicious and we were offered more :) I had seafood risotto cooked perfectly and deep fresh flavors. Just the right portion to enjoy with none left over. My husband had the filet au poive which was on mashed potatoes with green beans on the plate also cooked to perfection. The portion also good for one meal, no leftovers.
All of the options are ala carte so no soup or salad unless you added them. The menu has a great variety to choose from but we just had our entree & coffee.
Perhaps the high cost is because of its location, which is great for walking around Cape May.
Another fine dining experience at Tishas.
From the appetizers to the entrees, the dishes were presented beautifully and so flavourful and delicious.
The service was over the top.
We will be back.
We are never disappointed here! The food and service are impeccable! I’d recommend Tisha’s to everyone!
Food was incredible, service was great and the leftovers were just as good the next day.
Food was amazing. It was our first time in Cape May and our waitress Logan gave us tons of pointers on things to do and see..
Our dinner at Tisha’s was good albeit pricey. My husband had the clam chowder, which was okay, followed by the pappardelle with short rib. I had the jambalaya. They were both good, but nothing outstanding. Service was fine. So a good dinner but at somewhat high prices.
We had another superb meal at Tisha's in Cape May. We usually stop for lunch and have a bowl of their delicious clam chowder but this time, we had dinner there. Each of our meals was excellent. Salmon, veal, pasta and seafood risotto. Tisha's is a BYOB restaurant. We look forward to returning to Cape May and Tisha's!
Wonderful meal on a cold night in Cape May. Not many restaurants are open on a Tuesday in Cape May at this time of year. Fortunately for us Tisha's was. We had a great meal with very good service . It's a tradition with us. We stay at Congress Hall and eat at Tisha's. There were four of us and we all loved our meals.
Came to celebrate my birthday! I was not disappointed! Great food, great service!! We will be back again!! I had the seafood risotto and my husband had the salmon both dishes were so tasty and fresh!!!
So good 😊. We love this restaurant. It our go to place in cape May
Excellent food and service!
We were late for our reservation, but our server could not have been more gracious. The dining room was clearing out and she made sure to confirm that there were still tables dining in the back. Our meals, as always, were excellent. Lobster Rachel and Shrimp Curry. This is one of our favorite restaurants in and out of Cape May.
Tisha's is consistently excellent and conveniently located right on the Washington Street Mall. We celebrate my daughters birthday and enjoyed the filet and the lobster ravioli special. We were also pleasantly surprised with a local Cape May Chardonnay. Tisha's does not have a liquor license but can serve local wines. Our service was also very good and we look forward to returning. I would definately recommend Tisha's.
Joe was a great waiter. It was even better when it started snowing and we were seated by the window!
Great service , delicious food . I will definitely be going back next time I visit the cape. Very attentive and friendly wait staff . Try the mussels in red curry you won’t be disappointed.
Tisha's never disappoints and this was no exception. Everyone in the group is still talking about the amazing food and we cannot wait to return. Risotto with scallops, fabulous beef and a veal tip special with risotto all five star quality!
Absolutely top notch!
The food is always fresh, delicious and priced fairly.
The staff is knowledgeable and friendly.
The ambience is relaxing and comfortable. We've loved Tisha's for years and recommend it to many!
This was our third visit to Tisha’s and not disappointed. The food is excellent, the staff courteous, no long delays in service. Very nice experience, will dine there again.
We have made many trips to Cape May and This was our first time eating at Tisha's. We had a reservation and were quickly seated at a table in the back of the restaurant. The food was exceptional, we split an appetizer of lobster bisque that was amazing. My husband had the filet and it was very tender and very flavorful. I had the seafood risotto and it was also wonderful. We plan to visit again very soon.
As always, Tisha’s is one of the best restaurants in Cape May. Quiet and cozy - perfect for romantic dates or small groups. The food is always prepared perfectly. The servers are friendly and knowledgeable. If tou can’t tell this review is G L O W I N G!
The food and service was outstanding, always an enjoyable dining experience that makes us want to come back frequently!
Food was phenomenal, as usual.
Service was excellent.
Very nice ambiance, delicious meal with many choices. We love BYOB and especially like that this restaurant is in the heart of Cape May shopping. IT was a nice treat after the trolley holiday tour
It was great
Fantastic meal and service as always. Constantly excellent.