Come join us for such delights as Halibut topped with jumbo lump crabmeat or grilled filet Mignon topped with grilled lobster tail finished with béarnaise.
Whatever your choice may be, we promise to make your experience a memorable one.
- Surfaces sanitized between seatings
- Common areas deep cleaned daily
- Digital, disposable or sanitized menu provided
- Sanitizer or wipes provided for customers
- Limited number of seated diners
- Distancing maintained in common areas
- Extra space between tables
- Waitstaff wear masks
- Sick staff prohibited in the workplace
We always go to Tisha's during our holiday get-away during the Christmas season. I had made reservations for 4 people a few weeks ago. When I found out another couple wanted to join us , I could not change reservations online. I stopped by there a few hours before the reservation and the person I dealt with was so pleasant and accommodating. She was able to change the reservation to 6 people! The food was fabulous. Our server was pleasant and efficient and we had a wonderful round table... our absolute preference. Once again this place did not disappoint. It's a true Cape May gem!
Beautiful place. Our server Skyler was charming and very helpful. She made the evening very pleasurable. the food was well prepared and delicious. A definite place to come back to this spring.
Food was excellent. Service was excellent. One of the best restaurants in Cape May. Will be back.
We have been going to Tisha's for years and have NEVER been disappointed. The variety of food, the presentation, and the employees are all outstanding. Go eat there!!!
We are cape may locals and come to Tishas a lot! I always make a request for a specific room and they always honor it! The food was delicious and service was good . Never disappointed whenever I go there whether it’s for lunch or dinner!
We both had the filet, which is my go-to meal here. It was as delicious as always. The burrata salad was amazing also.
Coming w pleasure every time.
As a suggestion, a rack or s’thing to hang ur winter jackets will be helpful
A great place on Washing Street Mall. Medium but good menu for lunch. Ownership is always present - I'd recommend you make a reservation - it is popular place.
We had a great dinner at Tisha’s. Our server, Deanna was excellent. She recommended the filet and it was the best filet I have had in Cape May
Overall service was superb and food quality and portions a great value. Highly recommend!
Consistently great food. Attentive service. Have been going here for years and never been disappointed. A bit pricey, but worth it.
Excellent lunch! Had the award winning New England Clam Chowder and it has truly earned it's reward. Lots of meaty clams, potatoes, etc - loved it. Finished with the Harvest Salad with crispy chicken. A very big salad so be forewarned! It was very good with butternut squash, Granny Smith apples, Stilton, greens. Quite content after that meal and will definitely go back!
One of Cape May’s consistently reliable restaurants. The food is very good. Service is excellent. Always packed. Added plus, it’s a BYO. Highly recommend it.
Very accommodating on our request to eat outside when temps were in the mid 40’s. (They had outdoor heaters). Food and service was great,
The Lobster Bisque was not on the menu inside the restaurant however it was offered for lunch. We ordered and did not ask the price, my bad? It turns out the soup was $17.00 a bowl!!! Watch the prices if you order a special or an item not listed on the menu. Barring this experience I would recommend Tisha’s.
Tuesday night in the off-season and Tisha’s was busy! It’s a Cape May tradition with a well-deserved reputation for good food and service. We sat next to a couple who were at Tisha’s for the first time; they will be back!
Everything was excellent. Mushroom risotto is a must for an app. Scallops sambucca was delicious. As well as the crabcake BYOB but they do offer local wine. Apologize cant remember our servers name began with an L. She was excellent and very attentive. Thanks again for a wonderful anniversary dinner!!
The Harvest salad was perfectly dressed and delicious. The filet was cooked just right and outstanding! Tishas never disappoints!
As always, we enjoyed an impeccable dinner at Tisha’s. The service and food are always outstanding.
Wonderful food and hospitality, warm and cozy.
Our first visit after many trips to Cape May. Plan to make it one our favorite dinner spots.
Great place to eat, we will comeback to eat here again!
I have always had a nice experience at Tisha's and I again enjoyed a nice meal. Thank you!
The service was courteous and timely. My seafood risotto had perfectly cooked shrimp, scallops and clams. The risotto with mixed mushrooms was creamy and well seasoned. My wife’ halibut was perfectly cooked. Exceptional value.
Tisha’s is a long time favorite, and will continue to be so! The hostess seated us at a four top allowing for comfortable
dining. We both enjoyed our meals, my steak cooked to perfection. Service was excellent. Thank you!
We celebrated a friend’s 80th bday. Food and service was excellent.
GOOD FOOD AND GOOD SERVICE LED TO A GOOD, GOOD TIME. LEFT THE RESTAURANT SMILING.
Oh, the Clam Chowder! Absolutely the best and so unique! Friendly, accommodating service, and all the entrees were enjoyed thoroughly too. Desserts were very excellent too; great experience overall and we will look forward to the next time we dine there! One of the best meals in Cape May!
Consistently wonderful. Our server, Lilly was also awesome 👌 Thk you Tisha's.
First time dining at Tisha's and it did not disappoint. Our table was ready when we arrived, the waitress was super nice and cheery. The Salmon & Shrimp in sweet thai chili sauce was absolutely fabulous, it melted in your mouth and had so much flavor. The same with the special of the night halibut with crab.
We will be back!
The food was outstanding but it was freezing In the restaurant that it spoiled our evening. I also asked before hand for a candle on a piece of cake for a special occasion but it was forgotten about by the staff for my husband significant Birthday .
If your looking for delicious food highly recommend it.
Great meal with friends, our food was creative and tasty. Always a favorite for a special night out.
Another delicious meal at Tisha's! Our server, Sandy was very good. We always enjoy our dinners here!
Vacation - birthday. The most delicious food ! Great staff and service
We dined at Tisha's for our 45th Wedding Anniversary on recommendation from my wife's hairdresser. The meal and service were fantastic. It is BYOB and they take care of your wine needs. Definitely will return on our next Cape May visit.
I have eaten at Tisha’s for years and always loved it. Not so this time. Very disappointing. I was a party of one, and felt looked over as larger parties received a good deal more attention.
The food was disappointing as well… calamari while tasty, was very over fried. The gnocchi was light but too crispy and sitting in a pool of butter, to excess.
Always consisten good well prepared food and requested an area for seating and was accomodated.....OUr server was very polite and attentive...We had a wonderful evening at one of our favorite restaurants
Outdoor dining in warm November weather was perfect. Staff was outstanding even if the were understaffed. Please consider this when dining anywhere. Food was fantastic. Ambience was as well.
tishas has been in business for many years and always provides outstading food and attentive service.
Delicious as always. Great, friendly, attentive service!
My favorite restaurant in cape May. Always delicious
Tisha's is rated 4.7 stars by 5277 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.