Come join us for such delights as Halibut topped with jumbo lump crabmeat or grilled filet Mignon topped with grilled lobster tail finished with béarnaise.
Whatever your choice may be, we promise to make your experience a memorable one.
Lovely BYOB in the heart of Cape May that is reliably very good. Decent atmosphere with a knowledgable
Birthday dinner. Filet au Poirve was amazing.
Pumpkin gnocchi out of this world.
Enjoyed a wonderful meal on Easter at TIsha's. The Seafood Rissotto was outstanding.
And the service was perfect. The staff were friendly . Couldn't have been better.
We had a lovely Easter dinner. Food is consistently great.
Wonderful to have had Easter Sunday brunch at Tishas. We usually do lunch and/or dinner monthly. Nice change.
Great EAster brunch. We got there early and were seated! Great value. The pancakes with lemon and ricotta were delicious as was Tishas benedict. We really enjoyed it and will be back when we visit Cape May.
Excellent meal and great flexible service. Very pleasant experience. The staff was very accomodating.
Excellent choice for a quiet dinner for two. Beautiful ambiance and excellent service. Highly recommend!
Great food. Our server Kat was great.
A nice place for foodies, interesting menu, very tasty salad, my salmon dish was too overwhelmingly sweet and in general I found the sauces and flavors a bit much, I prefer simpler dishes myself. Pleasant atmosphere and good service.
Always a good experience. Food is excellent. Service is always friendly and prompt. I have been here several times and will return. All four in our party loved their dinner.
Perfectly cooked, perfectly seasoned, and full of flavor. Can't wait to get back to back to Cape May to eat there again.
Unfortunately my pork medallions were under cooked even after I sent them back. My dining partners short rib Bolognese was bland. Needless to say to say we were very disappointed since this restaurant came highly recommended.
Food and service was excellent! We enjoyed every second there. Definitely we are going back soon. We like this place.
Love the revised menu, it's been a couple years since we've had a meal here. Food quality is excellent, and the house salad even shines with its lightly dressed fresh leaves and crunch topping. I have the chicken with a mushroom cream sauce, but it was not too heavy. Delish! the rolls were hot and crunchy crusted. My dining partner had the salmon with a Thai sauce (a little hot, a little sweet...) and she loved it. Friendly hostess and great wait staff. Thanks much
We will be back soon! :)
Appreciate the menu choices being friendly for all diet types for good health. Noticed that! But still fabulous variety of foods small and entree size. One page menu, maybe 10 appetizers, two salads, 8 entrees. Fantastique!
(Oh one thing, we were served a complimentary long-hot that day with quality dipping oil with herbs. The long-hot that day was extremely bitter, beyond being edible...and I normally love them. Also the oil needs just maybe a little tad of salt to bring out the herbs in my estimation. I am not a salt person either. Just a little...)
We've been to Tisha's before for dinner and it was outstanding. We received a gift card and decided to give lunch a try. We were a bit disappointed to say the least. Food was good but not the caliber of dinner. Not sure if it's because they are just opening up for the season or if they have a new chef that just does lunch. Service was subpar. Waitress only checked on us once when the meal was over, didn't ask us if we needed anything or wanted dessert or coffee and never came over to refill our water glasses. Besides another table of three, we were the only people inside the restaurant. All of the waitstaff was setting up for dinner so maybe they just wanted us out? We would give Tisha's another try but not in a rush to come back. We will stick to dinner next time.
Fabulous clam chowder! The oyster po boy was so fresh and delicious! Highly recommend!
Phenomenal!! Our waitress, Carmen, was very attentive & friendly. A definite come back
Delicious food. Attractive decor. Server attentive to our needs. Could hear staff kidding around in kitchen which disrupted the ambiance. Would definitely go back again.
Went for birthday dinner. Food was awesome. Service was great! Will definitely go back again!
Great as always - service - food - ambiance. Thank you.
Passed this restaurant 100 times and we are so glad we tried it. Location is super convenient if you are spending he day shopping but don’t compare Tishas to other places to eat in the area as it is another level. He food was and the presentation was awesome. Going to be hard to go back to Cape May and not go back.
Never had a bad meal there
We have been here numerous times and selections always excellent along with the service, ambience and lack of noise irritation. Have recommended to friends who live nearby and those who visit. Always a place to know that fits the bill for a magnificent dining experience.
Outstanding service, gormet tasting dinner in a cozy atmosphere provided the perfect experience to celebrate my wife's special birthday!
As always, food and service at Tisha's is wonderful. Calamari special appetizer was delicious.
Excellent as you expected from past experiences.
Gnocchi were mushy tasted uncooked and they called a pesto sauce but just threw in a few basil leaves. Desserts were impressive. Only 2 left.
We took advantage of prixfix 3 courses for $35. My Salmon was excellent my wife’s pork was on the dry side. Mussels appetizers were excellent. For dessert I had the bread pudding and my wife opted for the cheese cake. Both were delicious! Service was excellent! Tishas is on our short list of Cape MAY RESTAURANTS.
The dining expierence was great. The food and service were excellent. Never a bad meal here at Tishes. One of Cape May's best.
We have been here several times a few years ago but stopped when we were not happy with our meal. We wanted to give it another go today. We had a lovely dinner at Tisha’s on Sunday evening after a nice few hours walking on the main walkway of Cape May. Our waitress was Sarah, she answered our questions clearly regarding some menu options. We selected the price fix option of Mussels, salmon and chocolate cake which was fabulous. My husband selected the menu items of Mushroom Soup, Filet and the Apple and Ice Cream desert, he raved about all of it. We will be back again often as long as the food and the service remain as high as it was tonight.
We have been going to Tisha’s a few years. Always consistent with the food and service quality. You should try it. It’s also a BYOB!
Food and ambiance was great ! Would definitely go back to Tishas !!!!
The meal was delicious and we always look forward to having a relaxing dinner at Tisha’s. The menu never disappoints...
This restaurant is ‘a must’ every time we’re in Cape May. Excellent food and service, and easily the best chocolate flourless cake ever!
Excellent as always my fav in cape may. Excellent service n food, see ya soon
Great meals and service, byob always preferable.
Great food, great service.
We were very happy with the Seafood Risotto and Salmon and the dessert were outstanding.
Very good and friendly service as usual. We will be back soon.