Standard=Indoors. Your reservation can not be changed from indoor to outdoor and vice versa. Outdoor dining is weather permitting.
Please ensure that you are booking reservations for the correct number of guests. Incomplete parties will not be seated unless you intend to pay $50 per seat unoccupied at the table you reserved.
Due to the limited amount of tables & space, please notify us of any changes/cancellations ASAP. Any NO-SHOW reservations will be flagged automatically and any future reservations will be canceled.
Theresa's South will only hold your table for 10 minutes before canceling your reservation.
Party sizes larger than 8 can not be accommodated at this time.
BYOB: BEER, WINE; CHAMPAGNE ONLY. NO OUTSIDE FOOD/BEVERAGES/DESSERTS ALLOWED.
Face masks are mandatory.
- Surfaces sanitized between seatings
- Common areas deep cleaned daily
- Digital, disposable or sanitized menu provided
- Sanitizer or wipes provided for customers
- Contactless payment available
- Limited number of seated diners
- Distancing maintained in common areas
- Extra space between tables
- Waitstaff wear masks
- Diners must wear masks unless eating or drinking
- Sick staff prohibited in the workplace
- Contact tracing information collected
Fresh Mozzarella, Roasted Peppers, Roasted Garlic Cream, Basil Pesto Oil
Whole Wheat Fettuccine, Grilled Chicken, Fresh Mozzarella, Tomatoes, Kalamata Olives, Basil, Spinach, Olive Oil
Smashed Potatoes, Seasonal Vegetables, Wasabi Aioli Sauce, Topped with Sweet Corn Salsa
New Year's Eve Special Menus & Offers
Please be aware of the dining space you are reserving & note that not all of tables are under a tent. Standard = indoor. Dress appropriately if your reservation is outdoors as it is still very cold even with our heat lamps turned on. All reservations are allotted 1 hour and 45 minutes to dine.
Service always excellent. Menu choices many .prices high . Grilled shrimp app shrimp tasted like cooked on a dirty grill . Tagilitelle mushrooms always a standard fav . Grouper fishy ; cappellini mushy , sauce watery .
It was great!
Table was ready on time for our reservation. The wait staff was excellent. All questions were answered fully. The salads were excellent and so was our entrees. Definitely would return.
We got there for the tuna - always cooked sushi rare! Started with a shared home made pasta and a shared delicious for dessert.
Our server was excellent, professional and accommodating.
The service is the best around
Lovely restaurant experience! Our dinners were excellent. Atmosphere was nice. The service was professional but rushed. Not sure why because our reservation was early and it was not crowded.
We will definitely try again.
As usual the food and service were great! Nice and quiet after a busy summer! Highly recommended!
It was great!
It’s always excellent but last night our salad came out 5 min after ordering it and our main came out before we finished eating our salads. What’s the rush?????
Food was exceptional. Service good; server hustled. . Atmosphere was outside for now . Heat lamps on.
Great food. Great service. Never disappoints. Theresa, our server, always attentive, efficient and entertaining. All things considered, one of the best restaurants around.
Was disappointed with the crab/lobster stuffed raviolis. three of us ordered that dish and not one of us could taste or see any crab or lobster.
Beet salad to start was great. Blueberries added a nice touch. Short rib dinner and sweet potato gnocchi with short ribs really hit the spot. Our waitress,Ashley, was beautifully attentive. As usual a nice experience at Theresa’s.
Great experience from beginning to end. Thank you.
The server, Christina, was very attentive. Food was Great!
Food was delicious. We had a 5 pm reservation outside.
My complaint was that we were finished eating by 5:40 pm. We ordered the eggplant pancake, pasta and ravioli dishes and fried cheese cake for dessert with cappucino.
There was no time in between and we were rushed. Menu says 1 1/2 hours is alloted for table.
Not sure what the rush was- several tables were empty when we left.
As always, table is ready and service and food are superb. Friendly staff, quiet ambiance and a relaxing dining experience.
The service could not have been better Teresa was our waitress she is the best
Our go-to Saturday night restaurant. The food and service are always consistently excellent.
Kyle was awesome.
The food is always delicious and never disappoints.
Amazing service and out of this world food!!!! Great job!!! Would Highly recommend!!!
Went last night to celebrate my birthday , they had a birthday card waiting for me on the table ,I thought that was a nice touch . The food was fantastic, service was wonderful . They never disappoint ALWAYS delicious
excellent food!!. And great service. Jennifer is a rock star!!
Very good food and service, pleasant dining rooms, all around good experience. We had the eggplant pancake- special treat and quite delicious. We followed up with soft shell crabs and grouper. Both mains were excellent. A key lime pie was just the dessert we needed to close out the meal. We will return.
Food was excellent - our server Taylor, as always, was friendly and service was wonderful. My request for a certain area for seating and for our server was met!
Great feature about open table is a section to make requests for your preferences!
Great dining experience.
Went with wife and two older children for her birthday dinner. We felt like they were doing us a favor in serving us. Our waiter was ok but didn’t show any emotion or seemed like he cared. He leaned against the walk when taking our orders. Every time we asked for something we felt like we were bothering them. We asked for a second bottle of bottled water and when the server brought it to the table he practically threw it on the table unopened and we had to open it and serve ourselves. The food was okay but not worth what they are charging. We will not return.
Awesome as always
Food was excellent!! Highly recommend the eggplant pancake and mushroom pasta!
The food and service was excellent. My wife and I like to split our courses. We generally order 1 appetizer or salad, a pasta dish, a main entree, and a desert. This gives us the opportunity to try multiple dishes and still have room for desert. Unlike some restaurants Theresa's South had no problem with us sharing each of our courses and they perfectly timed the delivery of each course to our table. For us this restaurant has become our special occasion restaurant. We have always had excellent food and the servers are very friendly and accommodating.
Always a very good meal at Theresa's South, probably our favorite restaurant in the area.
Really quaint place with indoor and outdoor seating. Nice menu with daily specials. Byob great too! We had tuna tartare and fig salad for appetizers - both outstanding! For entrees had grouper and tuna- loved them both too. Service very professional as well. We will be back for sure!
Quality ingredients carefully crafted. Very satisfied.
Food not what it used to be, quality has gone down. Don't know if it was different chef? We're long time customers and will go back for another try, however if we this was our first time dining at Theresas South it would have been our last time
Great homemade pasta! Everything we ate was delish.
Food and staff and Service were great
LOVELY DINING EXPERIENCE OUTSIDE WITH THE EXCEPTION OF THE VERY NOISY AC UNIT ACROSS THE STREET
Theresa’s South offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (732) 892-1555.
Theresa’s South is rated 4.7 stars by 1866 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.