Theo's Steak, Sides & Spirits
- Surfaces sanitized between seatings
- Digital, disposable or sanitized menu provided
- Sanitizer or wipes provided for customers
- Contactless payment available
- Limited number of seated diners
- Extra space between tables
- Waitstaff wear masks
- Diners must wear masks unless eating or drinking
- Sick staff prohibited in the workplace
New York Strip
Amazing experience! All of their staff was extremely friendly and knowledgeable on suggestions! We had an amazing dinner and will definitely be back! Try their cocktails you won’t regret it! Steak was cooked perfectly and the shrimp appetizers was so good! Highly recommend trying Theo’s if you are in St. Michael’s!!
My husband and I love this gem of a restaurant. From the food to the service to the atmosphere, everything was fantastic. The food was amazing. Their brussel sprouts were out of this world delicious and the jam burger was exceptional. Our waitress was attentive and sweet. The cocktails were superb- I had a rosemary margarita and peartini. We will definitely be back again on our next visit to St. Michael's!
The service, food, drinks were all excellent.
One of the best meals we have ever had! From the bread basket to the dessert, everything was absolute perfection! And if the food was not enough, the staff were nothing short of amazing, making us feel like VIPs the entire evening.
Definitely great for a date night :) They have a great selection and the happy hour cocktail prices couldnt be better.
Excellent dining experience. Great menu and food. Oysters, shrimp, steak, chocolate mousse, wine & spirits.
We had a great experience at Theos. The steaks and burgers are the best. Salads are great. I have celiac disease and had many gluten free options.
Our waiter was so friendly and helpful. We will be back
Another excellent evening at Theo’s. Thank you. Your food is outstanding and the service superb, from everyone.
FYI, we like your onion rings better than the onion straws.
1st time at Theo's we were celebrating our 17th wedding anniversary. The service and food were outstanding. They truly helped to make our anniversary memorable.
We ordered four steaks and three were not cooked to preference. One filet was over cooked and had little taste, and the other two (strip and rib-eye, which was $85) were both very under-cooked even after being sent back. Our waiter seemed very busy and we relied on another server for getting items. The steaks come with mashed potatoes but if you want to substitute for a baked potato you will add $4 on top of the entree price...I feel that is a little much. For a steakhouse, we were very disappointed and will not go back on our next visit to St. Mikes.
Great dinner to usher in the new year. The filet was excellent and service was outstanding.
Always great food! Friendly peeps!
Great except don't see need for a tv in this type setting.
A wonderful dinner on Christmas Eve!
Theo's St Michaels is one of our favorite restaurants! Always good, always fresh, and the service is fantastic.
Terrific Sunday supper add in great service, nice evening all around
The atmosphere was very soft and laid back. We were in the upstairs portion which was amazing. We were able to have a great experience! The service was outstanding, the food was amazing!! We will definitely be back for another epic experience...
Porterhouse for two and the oysters Christopher, and diver-oysters (raw) were fantastic. Please bring back the Boston Creme Pie-cake to St Michaels and keep it in Rehoboth!
Always look forward to theo’s for a really nice evening!
Love the ambiance in Theo’s and the food is consistently excellent. We had brunch that day and everyone was very happy with their choices
Good but a little expensive. Service was good a d such a cool place.
We dine frequently at Theo’s and always love the food and the service.
Very good meal and service. Shrimp tempura excellent. Bartender made a perfect Cosmopolitan with a dramatic pour. The fireplace made a chilly day cozy
My friends and I went for brunch. The place is gorgeous and the ambiance is amazing. I had the steak and eggs and the steak was prepared to temperature and excellent. The service was fantastic. There are outside seating available with a fire pit which we loved during this times. I would highly recommend
Theo's was the perfect place for the my Annapolis neighbors to join us to celebrate my husband's birthday. The food was delicious, the service unobtrusive and kind, and during the Pandemic, we felt safe and cared for.
Perfect restaurant to celebrate hubby’s birthday...good food, good service!
The half-price burgers were wonderful! Great Value!!! The wait staff are very attentive and friendly! We love Shannon & Maddy and then there's Andrey who is our friendly greeter! Theo's is a regular stop for us. We go at least once a month!
Always a pleasure, they check every box
The food is always amazing but the staff and the service made our date night perfection. Every accommodation was made for dietary needs and for comfort while eating outside on this chilly, rainy night. We will be back every time we’re in St. Michaels!
If visiting St. Michaels ‘Theo’s’ is a must!! Relaxing atmosphere with amazing food!!!
It's a shame. We've been here several times, and it was great before this visit. This time was really poor. New York steak: not one tiny bite without gristle. Empty water glass for the entire dinner. Glass of wine (ordered at time of ordering dinner) arrived more than half way through dinner (after reminding waitress twice after ordering-- that's three requests). In other words, nothing to drink while trying to eat steak, which my jaws gave up on after eating one third of the steak. Oysters on half shell were tiny and were not detached from the shell before serving (try pulling them off with only a tiny fork). Waitress disappeared for 20 minutes. A very expensive, worthless dinner. So bad that we took nothing home. This place deserves to fail if it continues on this trajectory. Very disappointed. Looking for a new place for birthday/anniversary dinners.
Always a wonderful dining experience. Great food and cocktails. Madelyn goes above and beyond as well as Audrey, the host. Thank you to all.
Theo's is dependable for good steaks and burgers, excellent sides and efficient good humored staff. 1/2 price burger night is a huge deal....any burger, 1/2 price, includes house made fries. We had a great meal with wine for a little more than 30 bucks!
Service and food were excellent! Cute spot too right in the heart of town.
Server was very knowledgeable and recommended great wine suggestions that weren’t just the most expensive. Only gave 4 stars on food due to mashed potato being a bit gluey and bearnaise was lacking tarragon and punch from the vinegar reduction. However, I will return.
Great restaurant for special event. Restaurant was originally a home & the tables are in small rooms. Very nice atmosphere. Had Chateaubriand (large serving) & it was cooked perfectly. Had brownie for dessert which was under a mound of ice cream & whipped cream. One was plenty for a couple. Reservations are a must.
Exceptional food and service for a very special occasion!
Great food, met the owner, nice place - will return again
Theo's Steak, Sides & Spirits offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (410) 745-2106.
Theo's Steak, Sides & Spirits is rated 4.7 stars by 1004 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.