Theo's Steak, Sides & Spirits
Our delicious cuisine, style and service can also be experienced during catered events held at our facility. Make it an evening to remember at "Theo’s Loft". The loft can seat up to 36 people for plated dinners, and up to 50 for cocktail receptions. The perfect space for intimate wedding parties, rehearsal dinners, corporate dinners as well as social gatherings.
Parties of 8 or more must be secured with a Credit Card. Failure to show or cancel before noon the day of the reservation will result in a $25 charge per person scheduled to dine.
Shannon’s level of service and friendly demeanor are beyond reproach. True asset
Very friendly and professional staff. Very nice atmosphere; the fireplace gave the room a romantic warmth. The food was fantastic; a little pricey, but worth it. I would definitely go back!
First the food was wonderful. Himalayan Salt Block Chimchurri Shrimp appetizer had great flavors.
Our server Shane was courteous and friendly. The atmosphere was great, we had reservations and I had ask to be kept away from doors as my wife is haha cold. Seated near the fireplace added to our experience.
I had the New York Strip with the mushrooms. (An upcharge from offered potatoes or creamed spinach.)
My steak was cooked and seasoned perfectly. I had kept some of the childbirth sauce to use with my steak but hardly touched it. My wife had the Theos Burger well done, cheese and bacon. She raved about it. So tasteful and cooked perfectly to her liking. Will be having dinner here our next visit to St Michaels!
One of the better filets I’ve ever had.
Enjoyed our food. I had the steak frites and my girlfriend has the tuna tar tar and fries. Service was great. The bar seemed like a good time as well. Great even on a cold day.
We come to Theo’s every year for my husband’s birthday, and it is usually outstanding. However, last night, not so much. The service, which is usually incredibly attentive, was bad; slow; plates weren’t cleared promptly, our food didn’t arrive all at once and two of us didn’t have utensils when it did, our wine hadn’t been served with enough time to breathe before our meal arrived, and one of our side dishes was undercooked, and it appeared that the server knew it, as she didn’t seem at all surprised when we sent it back.
In short, it was a terribly disappointing experience, especially for one that we only have once a year..
Love Theos and Ava’s the sister restaurant
Service, Food and Ambience I’d both are 4 star
Will continue to be regulars if both restaurants on St Michaels Maryland
Always outstanding, attentive/friendly staff excellent food
The filets were perfection. Great service.
Great evening. Shane did a great job!
Served a butt of a turkey round.
Pointed end served down the plate while the wide chunk flat facing up while lying on the side.
Was gross looking display while served with one nice slice of white turkey.
Overall presentation was awful.
Looked as just thrown on the plate .
Beans,stuffing,lump of turkey butt, dressing so small buried under the mixed mess next cranberry.
A bad day for the kitchen when previous dining there has been very good.
Great and friendly service. Steak and scallops were excellent. Enjoyed the casual atmosphere and the high quality food combo.
The BEST Extra Dirty Vodka Martini's EVER!!!!! One of my absolute favorite places in St. Michaels
We always love Theo's. It's our go to place when we have out of town guests, as well as a place we love when it's just us. The food is always excellent - steaks are perfectly prepared and sides are always well done (we really really love the fries).
Service is wonderful, whole vibe is perfect. If you are in St Michaels, be sure to eat at Theo's.
Outstanding, don’t miss this restaurant if you are in St Michaels!
Very good food and overall experience. Steak is a little salty, but excellently cooked. Be careful about sitting near the front & back door. Overall one of the best steak spots on the eastern shore of MD. Also try the happy hour for great deals.
Food was very good, place is attractive. Downside was service. Our waiter was mostly trying very hard, although we waited a long times for wine, bread, etc. - perhaps they were understaffed. But - we had a reservation, and still had to wait 25 minutes past our reservation time for a table. Even worse, the hostess brushed it off with a breezy "thanks for your patience!" - no apology, no explanation, no compensatory cocktail.... Not sure if I'd go back, because there are many other good choices in St. Michael's.
As always Theo’s never disappoints, the food is excellent as is the service. They have a great happy hour menu if you prefer a burger and the fillet is superb and perfectly cooked to my specification every time. You can’t go wrong visiting Theo’s
Lovely atmosphere and delicious meals. Our waitress was so welcoming and sweet.
We loved this place last year when we visited St Michael's and went back for more. Sadly, everything has declined - from the food to the service. Steaks were overcooked, missing side dishes and no apologies from management. Hopefully they can get it together.
Had an outstanding dinner here and none of us ordered the steaks! Delicious entrees for two vegetarians and we all loved the tuna and crab cakes. Outstanding server.
Shane masterfully table tended a spectacular meal from procurement to cooking to plating to service. The steaks were spot on but fell confident if you choose to move about the menu - solid here as well.
Great food, service, and ambiance! The filet steak was amazing! We found our go to place in St. Michael's
We were seated in the bar area, which I was disappointed about. Food was good!
Love Theo’s always and enjoyable meal, great ambience and staff. anytime at St Michaels I’m at Theos
Food was fabulous and staff was lovely! Our server Shane was particularly kind and helpful!!
We love Theo's, and need to come here more often! While everything we've eaten there is perfect (your steak always comes out exactly as you requested), the fries (yes, fries) are to die for. And we are total fry snobs. Our server was attentive and fun, and we really can't wait to come again.
The meal at Theo's was excellent. The food was outstanding. The service was very good but the noise level was a bit high. Ask in your reservation for a quiet table.
Loved Theo's!! We came for my husbands 40th birthday and they did not disappoint. Ambiance was warm, welcoming and cozy with small rooms. Spacious and intimate for a romantic date night. Service was exceptional. Food and drinks were fantastic and served quite quickly. We had a filet and salmon and both were under-cooked just as requested. They also were sure to make my husband feel special for his birthday. All around perfect evening and highly recommend! Many thanks to Shane who generously took several pictures for us!
Perfect service, steak and ambiance!
Were there for my wife’s birthday. Awesome meal. One of the best steaks ever eaten. Highly recommend for food, service, ambiance and special occasions. Our waitperson was extremely helpful and very attentive. Thank you.
My husband and I tried Theo's on our recent trip to St. Michael's. The service was not great and the food was not what we would expect for a $100 meal. It took about 10 minutes for our server to come a greet us once we sat down to take our drink orders. We received our drinks and ordered. The server only checked on us twice our entire meal and we had to ask for our drinks to be refilled. Both of our meals were very bland and did not have much flavor at all.
Ambiance was great, wine was good, my tuna steak was so dry I could barley bite through it. Not enjoyable.
Theos is our restaurant of choice when in St Michael’s. This was a business entertaining occasion and our guests were beyond pleased.
Always a wonderful dining experience.
Great,This is a great find. The food is excellent and the atmosphere is the best.My wife and I enjoyed our evening.The service was the best. Would recommend this restaurant to anyone for a good night out.
Was a first dinner date with a new awesome friend and asked for a quiet table with some privacy !
They absolutely delivered !!!!!! The waitress was just awesome!!!! She really set a mood for us and
was extremely respectful and even encouraged us to stay and get to know each other more !! What
great ambiance and respect!!! Thank You Theo's
Outstanding service and food. Would highly recommend and would definitely return.