The Smith - Midtown

Everything was delicious!

Food was good, service excellent. But seated directly in front of a large pile of garbage on the street. Im glad they had outdoor seating but not appropriate to have a table situated like this.

When the food was served, the waiter disappeared and we didn’t even had glasses in the table. The salad they served me was old and brown.

Omg my sister and I went to the Midtown location on a Monday night at 8:15pm and we had the BEST time. We started with drinks at the bar, we got the Pear Sangria which was delicious and tasted like fall in a cup! We then got to our table and ordered the Caesar salad + the tomato soup, so good! We then spilt the Brick Chicken and mashed potatoes and it was SO good! We ended with the s’mores in a jar for dessert and it was the perfect ending to an amazing time!! The staff was incredible and we loved every minute. I never write reviews but I loved The Smith and will definitely be back!!

Waiter was kind, helpful and very attentive. The food was amazing!

Dependable. Friendly and efficient service. Good value for excellent cuisine. A must stop each time we visit NYC.

Birthday Brunch. Accepting reservations is what we liked best. They were even able to seat us early on this very busy Sunday afternoon. We enjoyed our visit very much.

I had a reservation, but getting seated took an extra 20 minutes, even after a few follow-ups. The table was in the center of a noisy area, which felt like it was arbitrarily placed. The servers took quite a while to take drink orders and food orders, and on top of that, our dining experience felt rushed when our plates were practically taken away before we were finished.

We had a family get together for brunch and the Smith was a great location. The food was delicious and the service was great. I highly recommend this place.

The service was great, and the prices were very reasonable especially given its location in the heart of NYC. Food and wine options complemented each other well.

Really loved the food! Really liked the vibes in there and was very aesthetic. Everyone is vey nice there as well but our waiter was a little impatient. But overall great experience!! :)))) I recommend to go with your friend/s!!

The Smith is one of my favorite neighborhood go-to's for a fun casual meal. This includes breakfast, brunch, lunch, dinner, and post-theater eating. The Smith is busy in general, but the staff is always friendly and attentive and the food is consistent.

Usually love the food! Ricotta gnocchi is our favorite! Seemed much smaller than usual for their dinner size. Service was this biggest issue. I get it's a busy restaurant and we were sitting outside but we were neglected for over 20 minutes before even being served water, then another 15 minutes after that to get our order taken. Usually this isn't as bad of an issue...

The Smith - Midtown exceeded our expectations.

Food was excellent. Lobster guacamole is a must try! Took a while for order to be taken but then things moved quickly. Wines by the glass need to be upgraded. Beautiful interior of the restaurant.

Several pigeons walking around in the restaurant...

Our server was amazing. She was very professional and helpful. The food was very good. Going during the week is the best. I have been for brunch and it was way too noisy. Lunch was very relaxing and delightful.

Always consistent & incredibly tasty. Big open place that’s always busy & has a great energy. More on the expensive side (for me), but affordable enough to visit spontaneously. Would definitely recommend.

You really can't go wrong with the entrees at the Smith. The choices and quality of the food is continually outstanding. We really miss the pretzels on the appetizer list. The appetizers really need to be updated. We had a large group (7) and everyone was very satisfied with their entree. My company frequently orders in from the Smith and we are all big fans. We will return, just like we have for the last ten years.

Indoor tables were spaced perfectly per COVID guidelines. Outdoor seating looked comfortable as well. I have a food allergy (avocados) they took the time to assure me that they’d prepare my orders separately. Server was pleasant. The manager came to check on us twice and was very personable when we left. Good food, great ambiance. We felt safe and taken care of. I will definitely be back.

Booked for a birthday
No acknowledgement for my group member.
Steak delivered cold but got back warm.
Place is ok but for a special occasion seek somewhere else.

Everything was amazing. Our server was very personable. Food was delicious

Made a reservation early for a date. Was put between the bathroom door and a family of 8 (which in included a 6 month old baby). Food was cold, bland, and the space was too loud. Was incredibly disappointed. I had been there pre-covid and loved it. Now: Meh.

An amazing time. Food was excellent.

Good Bloody Mary and the food was great. Waiter didn’t come check on us though so I was never able to get another drink.

Always a winner. This place has become a default when we don't know what we're in the mood for because their menu is so varied and the food is always excellent.

Food is good and consistent. Servers are friendly.

I made an error and asked for outside seating- way too loud and disrupted because of the motorized bikes in the bike lane next to us. Lovely waiter, Oscar - so sweet and attentive. Food was better than delicious. I love The Smith!!!!

The Smith is always good, the service excellent and the vibe great, that’s why it’s so popular.

Outdoor seating was great, great selection of food, service was spot on!

Burger was excellent. Oysters were lackluster. The damper was the staff clearing plates before we were done and the waiter dropping the check before we asked. Came back multiple times to see if we paid. If I have a $15 dollar glass of wine in front of me and I have not finished it, don’t drop the check.

Enjoyed our outside table and dining experience. Food amd service were great.

Busboys kept coming to us every 5 minutes to ask us aggressively if we were ready when we were clearly still eating. It was very uncomfortable and not enjoyable. This started 60 minutes into the meal, not even close to the time limit. I used to love this place and came often during covid for outdoor dining but the service has become terrible.

Food was good, however portions were small
Also no bread was offered at the table

Pretty solid spot, servers are pretty on top of everything and the food is very good here.

Calamari is a bit too salty. But the ink source pasta is absolutely delicious.

Micheal is a great server ! Excellent customer service :-)

quality of the place has gone down as i have been in the neighborhood for ten years and this was the worse so far:
1) made reservation five days ahead got there on time but was unwilling to give a more preferred table when I have already dine there three times past month -- always gave me the worse seat
2) cocktail mix was off compare to last two times
3) ask for napkin towel and gave me toilet paper
4) steak was cooked with no seasoning and dry inside

We had a wonderful dinner, great service and able to eat outside. I will definitely be recommending The Smith Midtown to friends and family!

The waiter need pay more attention to the customer.